JERUSALEM: Israel said on Saturday that the Gaza war would not end as long as Hamas retains power, raising questions of timing and interpretation over a truce offer that US President Joe Biden has advanced and the Palestinian militants have cautiously welcomed.
Biden said on Friday that Israel had proposed a deal involving an initial six-week ceasefire with a partial Israeli military withdrawal and the release of some hostages while “a permanent end to hostilities” is negotiated through mediators.
The proposal, Biden said, also “creates a better ‘day after’ in Gaza without Hamas in power.” He did not elaborate on how that might be achieved. The Iranian-backed Islamist group has given no indication it might step aside or disarm voluntarily.
However, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office said on Saturday any notion that Israel would agree a permanent ceasefire before “the destruction of Hamas’ military and governing capabilities” was “a non-starter.”
Hamas said on Friday it was ready to engage “positively and in a constructive manner.” But senior official Mahmoud Mardawi said in a Qatari television interview that it had not yet received the details of the proposal.
“No agreement can be reached before the demand for the withdrawal of the occupation army and a ceasefire is met,” he said. Hamas remains committed to Israel’s destruction.
The talks, mediated by Egypt and Qatar with US backing, have stumbled for months over a clash in core positions. Israel has been willing only to suspend the war in exchange for hostages, saying it would then resume the campaign to eliminate the Hamas threat. Hamas wants any deal to entail concrete Israeli moves to end the war, like a full troop withdrawal.
A senior Biden administration official, asked about a potential rift in the US and Israeli viewpoints on the future of Hamas, suggested this may be open to interpretation and would come down to future Egyptian and Qatari sway over the movement.
“I have no doubt that the deal will be characterised by Israel and be characterised by Hamas,” the official told reporters.
“And I think the arrangements and some of the day-after planning, you know, helps ensure that — that Hamas’s military capacity to regenerate in a way that can threaten Israel would be very much foreclosed under this arrangement and, I think the president said in his speech, ensuring that Hamas cannot rearm.”

JABALIA, Palestinian Territories: Mohammed Al-Najjar, a 33-year-old Gazan, said Saturday he was “shocked” and feeling “lost” as he returned home, only to find much of Jabalia refugee camp in ruins after an Israeli offensive
“All the houses have been reduced to rubble,” Najjar told AFP in Jabalia, in the northern Gaza Strip.
“You are lost, you do not know where exactly your house is in the middle of this massive destruction.”
Israeli forces carried out a massive bombardment campaign in Jabalia in recent weeks, part of a fierce ground offensive in northern Gaza — an area the military had previously said was out of the control of Hamas militants.
“I was shocked by the extent of the destruction in the latest aggression on Jabalia camp,” said Najjar.
In recent days, AFP correspondents have seen scores of Palestinians streaming into the area, trying to find their homes and salvage whatever belongings are left.
Men, women and children were walking through streets where their houses once stood, now full of grey concrete slabs.
Charred furniture, beds and mangled iron doors littered almost every street in the camp, an area once bustling with activity and home to more than 100,000 people, according to UN figures from before the war.
Many families carried their belongings on donkey carts, while others walked with beds and mattresses on their heads.
“We have no other place other than our homes,” said Suad Abu Salah, 47, who has also returned after having fled the area earlier on in the Israel-Hamas war, now nearing its eighth month.
But “Jabalia has been wiped off the map,” she said.
The war was sparked by Hamas’s unprecedented October 7 attack on southern Israel, which resulted in the deaths of 1,189 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on Israeli official figures.
Militants also took 252 hostages, 121 of whom remain in Gaza, including 37 the army says are dead.
Israel’s retaliatory offensive has killed at least 36,379 people in Gaza, mostly civilians, according to the Hamas-run territory’s health ministry.
Despite the destruction, Najjar said people were “determined” to return to the neighborhoods they had left to avoid the fighting.
Residents were willing to “set up tents and temporary shelters in the middle of the rubble,” he said, even though “there’s fear, fear that the (Israeli) occupation might come back.”
“But we will stay on our land. We have nowhere else.”
On Friday the Israeli military announced it had completed its mission in eastern Jabalia, where it had previously said Hamas militants had regrouped.
On Saturday Jabalia residents said they could still hear constant gunfire and artillery shelling from the east.
Fresh fighting erupted in the north in early May, around the same time Israeli troops took control of the Palestinian side of the Rafah crossing, on Gaza’s southern border with Egypt.
During the latest operation, Israeli forces in Jabalia had retrieved the bodies of seven hostages, and last month the military reported “perhaps the fiercest” fighting there since the start of the war.
Mahmud Assaliyah, 50, said “houses have been torn apart and entire apartment blocks have been completely destroyed in Jabalia.”
“There’s not a single house that has not been targeted by the Israeli occupation army.”
He has returned to find his house, too, had been flattened.
“Cement pillars have fallen, walls have been destroyed, furniture has been scattered, burnt down and torn apart,” Assaliyah said.
Abu Salah said many residents are tired of being displaced and just want to stay put, whatever happens.
“We want to live like other people in the world,” she said.
“We need a solution and an end to this war, so that we can live in peace.”