EU report raises concerns over state of human rights, democracy in Pakistan

European Union flags fly outside the European Commission building in Brussels, Belgium on June 16, 2022. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 22 November 2023
Follow

EU report raises concerns over state of human rights, democracy in Pakistan

  • The report was compiled under the GSP+ scheme which requires Pakistan to enforce 27 international conventions
  • EU expresses concerns over enforced disappearances, press freedom and politicization of anti-corruption rhetoric

ISLAMABAD: The European Union highlighted several human rights challenges facing Pakistan in an evaluation report released on Tuesday, acknowledging the country had strengthen its legal framework to deal with issues like torture and labor rights while noting their proper implementation was still a problem. 

The report, which was compiled under the Generalized System of Preferences Plus (GSP+) preferential trade scheme, covers the period between 2020 and 2022. The scheme allows developing countries to bring their exports to the European markets without paying much tariff after agreeing to implement 27 international human rights conventions related to environment and good governance. 

The EU is Pakistan’s second most important trading partner, accounting for 14.3 percent of the country’s total trade in 2022 and absorbing 29.8 percent of its total exports. In 2022, Pakistan’s exports to the EU were 58.9 percent higher than in 2019, while imports from the EU witnessed an increase by 9 percent over the same period. 

“Since 2020, Pakistan has adopted important laws in the field of human rights, namely regarding preventing and punishing torture, the protection of journalists, gender-based violence, preventing domestic violence, and, at provincial level, promoting women’s rights,” the report said. 

“While legislative reforms are significant, important concerns remain, notably on enforced disappearances, on allegations of torture as well as on restrictions of freedom of expression, and media freedom,” it added. 

The EU report also noted that political and economic corruption was perceived to be rampant in Pakistan, though it noted that anti-corruption rhetoric and legal cases were “heavily politicised.” 

It also expressed concern over military’s involvement in politics and the national economy, saying this was “despite continuous civilian rule since 2008.” 

As the largest exporter to the EU under the GSP+ scheme, Pakistan needs the preferential trade mechanism for continued access to the lucrative European market. However, EU states have frequently expressed concerns over the state of human rights issues and democracy in the country while even calling for European authorities to review Pakistan’s GSP+ status. 

However, the EU Parliament in October voted to extend the current GSP+ rules, rolling over the special incentive arrangement for another four years for developing countries, including Pakistan. 


Thousands flee northwest Pakistan after mosques warn of possible military action

Updated 11 sec ago
Follow

Thousands flee northwest Pakistan after mosques warn of possible military action

  • Residents of the Tirah Valley said they have moved out of the area into nearby towns despite heavy snowfall and cold winter temperatures
  • Defense Minister Khawaja Asif denied any operation was planned or underway in Tirah, calling the movement a routine seasonal migration

BARA/KARACHI: Tens of thousands of people have fled a remote mountainous region in northwestern Pakistan in recent weeks, ​residents said, after warnings broadcast from mosques urged families to evacuate ahead of a possible military action against militants.

Residents of the Tirah Valley, in the Pakistani province of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa that borders Afghanistan, said they have moved out of the area into nearby towns despite heavy snowfall and cold winter temperatures because of the announcements to avoid the possible fighting.

“The announcements were made in the mosque that everyone should leave, so everyone was leaving. We left too,” said Gul Afridi, a shopkeeper who fled with his family to the town of Bara located 71 km (44 miles) east ‌of the ‌Tirah Valley.

Local officials in the region, who asked to remain unidentified, ‌said ⁠thousands ​of families ‌have fled and are being registered for assistance in nearby towns.

The Tirah Valley has long been a sensitive security zone and a stronghold for Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, a militant group that has carried out attacks on Pakistani security forces.

The Pakistani government has not announced the evacuation nor any planned military operation.

On Tuesday, Pakistan’s Defense Minister Khawaja Muhammad Asif denied any operation was planned or underway in Tirah, calling the movement a routine seasonal migration driven by harsh winter conditions.

However, a Pakistani military source with knowledge of ⁠the matter said the relocation followed months of consultations involving tribal elders, district officials and security authorities over the presence of militants in ‌Tirah, who they said were operating among civilian populations and ‍pressuring residents.

The source asked to remain unidentified as ‍they are not authorized to speak to the media.

The source said civilians were encouraged to ‍temporarily leave to reduce the risk of harm as “targeted intelligence-based operations” continued, adding there had been no build-up for a large-scale offensive due to the area’s mountainous terrain and winter conditions.

Pakistan’s military media wing, the Inter-Services Public Relations, the interior ministry, and the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provincial government did not respond to requests for comment made on Friday.

NOT ​THE COLD

Residents rejected suggestions that winter alone drove the movement.“No one left because of the cold,” said Abdur Rahim, who said he left his village for Bara ⁠earlier this month after hearing evacuation announcements. “It has been snowing for years. We have lived there all our lives. People left because of the announcements.”

Gul Afridi described a perilous journey through snowbound roads along with food shortages that made the evacuation an ordeal that took his family nearly a week.

“Here I have no home, no support for business. I don’t know what is destined for us,” he said at a government school in Bara where hundreds of displaced people lined up to register for assistance, complaining of slow processes and uncertainty over how long they would remain displaced.

Abdul Azeem, another displaced resident, said families were stranded for days and that children died along the way.

“There were a lot of difficulties. People were stuck because of the snow,” he said.

The Tirah Valley drew national attention in September after a deadly ‌explosion at a suspected bomb-making site, with officials and local leaders offering conflicting accounts of whether civilians were among the dead.