Finance advisor says the rich, businesses to be taxed to meet Pakistan’s revenue targets

US Special Representative for Afghanistan & Pakistan Richard Holbrooke (L), co-chairs a session with Pakistan's Finance Minister Abdul Hafeez Shaikh during the Pakistan Development Forum in Islamabad November 14, 2010. (Reuters)
Updated 13 June 2019
Follow

Finance advisor says the rich, businesses to be taxed to meet Pakistan’s revenue targets

  • Rs.8.2 trillion budget released on Tuesday for the fiscal year to June 2020
  • Pakistani stocks rose on Wednesday, business community gave mixed reviews of PM Khan’s first budget

ISLAMABAD: De facto Pakistani finance minister Hafeez Shaikh said on Wednesday the government would collect more taxes from the rich as well as businesses to meet the ambitious tax collection target of Rs5.5 trillion ($36 billion) set in the annual budget.

The Rs.8.2 trillion budget released on Tuesday for the fiscal year to June 2020 underlined the scale of the economic challenges faced by the government of Pakistan, including pushing ahead with reforms and measures to curb ballooning current and fiscal account deficits.

Successive governments have promised to rein in tax evaders and boost revenues but face fierce resistance to change, including from the many politicians and businessmen believed to be among those dodging their taxes. Only 1.8 million people file income tax returns in the fast-growing South Asian nation with a population of 208 million and a large informal economy.

“If we want to stand tall in the comity of nations, we will have to collect our taxes,” Shaikh told reporters at a post-budget press briefing in Islamabad. “And for that, if we have to offend some people, we are ready to do it.”

Listing the major sectors from which the government expected to collect more revenue, he said businesses would be taxed on products sold in the domestic market but continue to avail the zero-rated tax facility on exports.

Shaikh said the government also planned to collect sales tax from the industrial sector on different goods at the manufacturing stage to put an end to tax evasion.

“The government is also abolishing the distinction between tax filers and non-tax filers,” he said, adding that if a person failed to become a tax filer while purchasing property or a car, he would receive a tax liability after a 45-day limit lapsed.

“All these measures will have a far-reaching impact and help increase the tax base,” he said, adding that a sectorial analysis was also being carried out to collect more taxes from the businesses. “This is an ambitious revenue target, but we are hopeful to achieve it with our collective efforts.”

Pakistani stocks rose on Wednesday and the business community gave mixed reviews of Prime Minister Imran Khan’s first budget aimed at securing a $6 billion bailout from the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

The government had been forecasting growth of 4% for the next financial year, but after Revenue Minister Hammad Azhar delivered his budget speech, the government released a budget document showing it trimmed its growth estimate for the coming year to 2.4%.

The government has already slashed its year to June 2019 growth forecast to 3.3% from the 6.2% predicted at the time of the last budget. The IMF’s estimates growth of around 2.9%.

Inflation, which hit 9% in May, is seen at 11-13% during fiscal year 2019/2020.

Talking about the priorities of the Khan-led government in the coming fiscal year, Shaikh said it had allocated Rs407 billion for social safety programmes and given subsidies to the poor on utility bills. The government had increased the annual development budget from Rs550 billion to Rs950 billion to create jobs and build infrastructure like road networks and dams, he said.

Shaikh also announced that the government had allocated Rs152 billion for the development of the tribal districts and to incentivize the private sector.

“Despite fiscal constraints, we are committed to protect our poor and try to eliminate the difference between rich and poor through our just economic policies,” he added.


Power minister defends solar net-metering overhaul after Pakistan PM orders review

Updated 6 sec ago
Follow

Power minister defends solar net-metering overhaul after Pakistan PM orders review

  • Leghari says 466,000 net-meter users earn up to 50% returns while 35.5 million consumers bear higher costs
  • NEPRA’s new rules require full grid tariffs for usage and lower, market-linked rates for excess solar exports

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s power minister on Thursday defended controversial changes to rooftop solar net-metering rules, arguing that generous returns for a small number of users were unfairly burdening millions of other electricity consumers, as Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif ordered a review a day earlier.

The dispute centers on changes to the net-metering regime, under which households and businesses with rooftop solar panels can sell excess electricity to the national grid. The National Electric Power Regulatory Authority's (NEPRA) new compensation rules require consumers to pay full tariffs for electricity drawn from the grid while receiving a lower, market-linked rate for excess power they export.

Critics have called the revisions “anti-solar” and warned they would undermine renewable energy adoption and hurt household finances.

Power Minister Sardar Owais Ahmed Khan Leghari told the National Assembly that only 6,000-7,000 megawatts of Pakistan’s estimated 22,000 megawatts of installed solar capacity fall under net-metering, covering around 466,000 consumers out of 35.5 million nationwide electricity users.

“If a net-metering consumer earns a 50% return on his investment because of the savings he gets as a meter user, while IPPs [independent power producers] get 17% and bank deposits earn 8%, isn’t a 50% return a good rate,” he asked.

“I generate electricity at Rs. 5 and send it to the grid at Rs. 27,” he continued. “The average price at which we buy electricity from the rest of the grid is Rs. 8.31. Is buying at Rs. 27 justified?”

Leghari said under the revised framework, returns for net-meter users would fall to around 37%, adding that even at that level, rooftop solar power generation remains financially attractive.

He said the changes were aimed at ensuring “fair pricing” and reducing cross-subsidies borne by the broader consumer base.

“Besides them, there are 35.5 million other consumers who do not even use net-metering,” he said, adding that if electricity costs for the wider public fell by up to Rs. 1.50 per unit, the adjustment would be justified.

Leghari's statement follows the prime minister's instructions to file a review in response to the new NEPRA rules, as he directed his administration to protect existing consumer contracts while ensuring the policy does not shift the financial burden onto non-solar electricity users.