A huge hit but how original is PTI anthem ‘Tabdeeli Aayi Re?’

A supporter of Imran Khan, chairman of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), political party, wears a mask and dance on party songs during a campaign rally ahead in Karachi last month. An anthem prepared by Khan's party is being criticized S being copied from India. (REUTERS/Akhtar Soomro/File Photo)
Updated 28 August 2018
Follow

A huge hit but how original is PTI anthem ‘Tabdeeli Aayi Re?’

  • Az Records released ‘Rok Sako To Rok Lo Tabdeeli Aayi Re’ by Shahzaman and Jawad Kahlown, featuring Imran Ismail, on YouTube on August 28, 2017. It has more than 27 million views and 16,000 comments.
  • Some people say the song bears a striking resemblance to a remix of a Rajasthani folk song which was posted a few months earlier, titled ‘Bankya Maa Re Nache.’

ISLAMABAD: Few people in Pakistan can be unaware of the song “Rok Sako To Rok Lo Tabdeeli Aayi Re” (Stop Us If You Can Change Has Come). Performed by Shahzaman and Jawad Kahlown, featuring Imran Ismail, it currently has more than 27 million views on YouTube and was adopted as an anthem by political party Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf.
However, some people have pointed out that the incredibly popular song is suspiciously similar to a remixed version of the Indian Rajasthani bHajjan, or religious song, “Bankya Maa Re Nache,” performed by Yuvraj Mewari, with music by the Mewari Brothers. It was released on YouTube by RDC Rajasthani on April 6, 2017, more than four months before Az Records released “Rok Sako To Rok Lo Tabdeeli Aayi Re” on the video-sharing site on August 28.

When Arab News played both songs for a handful of people there was instant recognition of the similarities. The responses included: “undeniable,” “this is crazy,” and “OMG yes.” However, many of the listeners added that it is well known that the bHajjan music industry often borrows from other places, notably naats (Islamic poetry) and Pakistani music.
When we contacted Shahzaman and Jawad Kahlown through their official Facebook page, Jawad acknowledged the similarities between the songs but, like our small sample audience, pointed out that songs in this genre tend to borrow from others. He also confirmed that they were familiar with “Bankya Maa Re Nache.”
“We did hear this song,” he said. “Indeed, there is a resemblance but this specific kind of music resembles many songs. But it goes without saying that our composition is way catchier, stronger and popular. The song is an original, written and composed by Jawad Kahlon. The line ‘Rok Sako To Rok Lo’ was written by Imran Ismail.”
Arab News has contacted PTI for a comment.


Cuba says a 5th person died after people on a Florida-flagged speedboat opened fire on soldiers

Updated 9 sec ago
Follow

Cuba says a 5th person died after people on a Florida-flagged speedboat opened fire on soldiers

  • Authorities in Cuba said that on Feb. 26 Cuban soldiers confronted a speedboat carrying 10 people as the vessel approached the island and opened fire on the troops
  • The shooting threatened to increase tensions between US President Donald Trump and Cuban authorities

HAVANA: Cuba said a fifth person has died as a consequence of a fatal shootout last month involving a Florida-flagged speedboat that allegedly opened fire on soldiers in waters off the island nation’s north coast.
The island’s interior ministry said late Thursday in a statement that Roberto Álvarez Ávila died on March 4 as a result of his injuries. It added that the remaining injured detainees “continue to receive specialized medical care according to their health status.”
Authorities in Cuba said that on Feb. 26 Cuban soldiers confronted a speedboat carrying 10 people as the vessel approached the island and opened fire on the troops. They said the passengers were armed Cubans living in the US who were trying to infiltrate the island and “unleash terrorism”. Cuba said its soldiers killed four people and wounded six others.
“The statements made by the detainees themselves, together with a series of investigative procedures, reinforce the evidence against them,” the Cuban interior ministry said in its statement, adding that “new elements are being obtained that establish the involvement of other individuals based in the US”
Earlier this week, Cuba said it had filed terrorism charges against six suspects that were on the speedboat. The government unveiled items said to have been found on the boat, including a dozen high-powered weapons, more than 12,800 pieces of ammunition and 11 pistols.
Cuban authorities have provided few details about the shooting, but said the boat was roughly 1.6 kilometers (1 mile) northeast of Cayo Falcones, off the country’s north coast. They also provided the boat’s registration number, but The Associated Press was unable to readily verify the details because boat registrations are not public in the state of Florida.
The shooting threatened to increase tensions between US President Donald Trump and Cuban authorities. The island’s economy was until recently largely kept economically afloat by Venezuela’s oil, which is now in doubt after a US military operation deposed then-Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro.