Muslim prisoners in England ‘disproportionately targeted’ with pepper spray, data shows

Over recent years, the use of the pepper spray against Muslim prisoners has risen, the ministry data shows. (Shutterstock)
Short Url
Updated 17 March 2024
Follow

Muslim prisoners in England ‘disproportionately targeted’ with pepper spray, data shows

  • Prayer, Qur’an study viewed as ‘extremist’ activities by some prison officers
  • ‘Muslim prisoners at risk of unfair and harmful treatment,’ says advocacy organization chief

LONDON: Muslim prisoners across England and Wales were disproportionately targeted by a pepper spray first introduced to prison officers in 2018, The Guardian reported.

Maslaha, an advocacy organization, gathered statistics through a freedom of information request to the Ministry of Justice that also showed a sharp rise in the use of Pava in prisons.

The synthetic pepper spray can cause injury to the eyes, respiratory tract and skin, and can even lead to permanent disability or death. It has been introduced to 89 prisons in England and Wales.

Ministry of Justice data shows that in 2022, 34 percent of prisoners targeted by Pava were Muslim, despite members of the faith making up only 18 percent of the prison population.

In total, Pava was drawn and used 188 times against Muslim prisoners in that year, and drawn but not used 54 times.

In the England and Wales prison system, however, Christian prisoners, making up 46 percent of the population, were targeted by Pava 43 percent of the time in 2022.

Over recent years, the use of the pepper spray against Muslim prisoners has also risen, the ministry data shows.

Some Muslim prisoners told Maslaha that they now hide their religious identity for fear of being viewed as an “extremist.”

Even basic elements of Islam such as prayer and Qur’an study are often seen as suspicious by prison offers, they said.

Raheel Mohammed, the organization’s director, said: “The figures we’ve uncovered show that Muslims in prison are being unfairly targeted by the use of Pava spray, a harmful weapon which can cause severe injury, disability and even death.

“Not only are Muslims more likely to be targeted, but this disproportionality is rising.

“Whatever we believe in, however we practice our religion, we all have the right to be treated with dignity and respect. But our work with Muslims in prison makes it clear that harmful stereotypes about Muslims are rife in prisons and are putting Muslim prisoners at risk of unfair and harmful treatment.”

A Prison Service spokesperson said: “Pava is only used as a last resort by specially trained prison officers and we monitor its use carefully including for any disparities in the way it’s deployed.”


India fines IndiGo record $2.45 million over mass flight cancellations

Updated 9 sec ago
Follow

India fines IndiGo record $2.45 million over mass flight cancellations

  • India’s largest airline scrapped about 4,500 flights in the first weeks of December
  • India’s largest airline scrapped about 4,500 flights in the first weeks of December

NEW DELHI: India’s aviation regulator on Saturday fined IndiGo a record $2.45 million, issued warnings to senior executives and directed the airline to remove the head of its operations control from his duties after mass flight cancelations last month.

India’s largest airline scrapped about 4,500 flights in the first weeks of December, stranding tens of thousands of passengers nationwide and highlighting concerns over limited competition in the world’s fastest-growing ‌aviation market.

The airline ‌has acknowledged that poor pilot roster ‌planning was ⁠the ​main cause ‌of the disruption. A probe by the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) found several deficiencies at the airline after stricter pilot rest and duty rules came into effect last year, the regulator said in a statement.

IndiGo, which holds 65 percent of India’s domestic market, failed to properly identify planning gaps or maintain adequate operational buffers, the DGCA said, adding that the airline had ⁠an “overriding focus” on maximizing the use of crew, aircraft, and network resources.

“(IndiGo’s) approach compromised roster ‌integrity and adversely impacted operational resilience,” the ‍DGCA said.

A government source said ‍that the fine was the largest imposed by the authority to date, ‍though it amounted to just 0.31 percent of IndiGo’s annual profit for fiscal 2024/25.

IndiGo said in a statement that its board and management were “committed to taking full cognizance of the orders and will, in a thoughtful and timely manner, ​take appropriate measures.”

The DGCA issued warnings to several senior executives, including Chief Operating Officer Isidre Porqueras and Jason Herter, senior vice ⁠president of the operations control center. It directed IndiGo to relieve Herter of his operational duties.

CEO Pieter Elbers received a “caution” for “inadequate overall oversight of flight operations and crisis management,” the regulator said.

IndiGo was also ordered to provide a bank guarantee of $5.51 million in favor of the DGCA to ensure “compliance with the directives and long-term systemic correction.”

The DGCA said the aviation ministry had also ordered an internal inquiry into the regulator’s own functioning. The cancelations prompted the government to temporarily relax some rules on night duties for pilots to help stabilize IndiGo’s operations, a move criticized by pilot unions ‌and safety advocates. India’s competition regulator is reviewing allegations of antitrust violations by the two-decade-old airline.