Exile in Sinai not an option, hapless Gazan residents say

A Palestinian boy carries pillows as a tractor clears debris of destroyed buildings in the southern Gaza Strip on Friday amid continuing battles between Israel and Hamas. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 15 December 2023
Follow

Exile in Sinai not an option, hapless Gazan residents say

  • Israel has told Gaza residents wishing to avoid being caught up in their assault against Hamas that they should head south. Its military bombs southern areas where people have fled

CAIRO: With Israeli bombs pounding the length of the Gaza Strip, Gazans have been squeezed up against the border with Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula at the town of Rafah and say they have practically nowhere left to flee.
Hundreds of thousands have been displaced from their homes, and as the bombardment comes closer again, many fear the only option to keep them alive is exile to Sinai. But they don’t want that. They say if that happened, they might never come back.
“There’s no safe place anymore. Now the Israeli ground offensive might expand to here,” said Umm Osama, a 55-year-old woman from Gaza City in the north who has sought shelter in Rafah.
“Where should we go after Rafah?”
Umm Osama and many other displaced Gazans rejected the idea of fleeing across the border, should it become possible.

BACKGROUND

Palestinians and officials in neighboring Arab countries alike are nervous at the prospect of a mass, long-term displacement of Gazans.

“We refuse displacement to Sinai, and we want to return to our homes, even if they are in ruins,” she said.
The traumatic exile of their forebears haunts her and other Gazans: Many of Gaza’s residents are descendants of Palestinians forced to flee their homes after the creation of Israel in 1948.
“If they make me choose between living under bombardment or leaving, I’ll stay. I’ll go back even if tanks are there. I’ll go back to Gaza City and will endure anything,” said Umm Imad, a 73-year-old woman also sheltering in Rafah.
Facing weeks of Israeli aerial assault, close-range tank fire, and the guns of troops on the ground, which Israel said is aimed at hunting down Hamas fighters, some 85 percent of 2.3 million Palestinians living in Gaza have been forced toward the south of the besieged enclave.
Israel has told Gaza residents wishing to avoid being caught up in their assault against Hamas that they should head south. Its military bombs southern areas where people have fled.
Northern Gaza was the initial focus of Israel’s assault on the Hamas-controlled territory.
Southern Rafah, strategically important because it holds the only currently functioning crossing into Gaza — one not controlled by Israel and where aid is being delivered — is the latest area to come under intense bombardment.
Strikes in the Al-Shaboura neighborhood of Rafah leveled an entire street late on Thursday.
On Friday, men and boys picked through the rubble and stared blankly at caved-in houses and their ruined possessions that could not be retrieved.
The strikes left a heap of rubble and twisted metal dotted with blankets and bags, gouged mattresses and sofas spilling out tufts of cotton and polyester, children’s bicycles, and kitchenware.

“Nowhere in Gaza is safe,” said Jehad Al-Eid, a resident of the area.
Palestinians and officials in neighboring Arab countries alike are nervous at the prospect of a mass, long-term displacement of Gazans.
A mass influx into Egypt is currently unlikely.
The exit of Gaza residents has been slow with the choked border crossing struggling to cope with the entry even of aid trucks, which the UN says are not nearly enough to cope with a population that has lacked enough medical supplies for weeks and is beginning to go hungry.
Violence continues to kill people in the south of the strip.
In Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, a father mourned his two sons, aged 17 and 18, whom he said were killed in Israeli shelling yesterday.
The tearful father followed their bodies until they were wrapped in shrouds and sent to the morgue.
“They were outside the door when a shell hit the neighbor’s house. They went to help, and a second shell hit them,” the father, Majdi Shurrab, said.
Shurrab said the bodies were left on the ground because it was difficult for ambulances to reach them to take them to the hospital. The destruction from air strikes has made travel along roads difficult, and there are severe fuel shortages across Gaza.
Rescue workers had to carry Shurrab’s sons to hospital by donkey-drawn cart.

 


Israel confirms ban on 37 NGOs in Gaza

A Palestinian woman carries wood for fire in the Nuseirat refugee camp in the central Gaza Strip on December 31, 2025. (AFP)
Updated 3 sec ago
Follow

Israel confirms ban on 37 NGOs in Gaza

JERUSALEM: Israel on Thursday said 37 humanitarian agencies supplying aid in Gaza had not met a deadline to meet “security and transparency standards,” and would be banned from the territory, despite an international outcry.
The international NGOs, which had been ordered to disclose detailed information on their Palestinian staff, will now be required to cease operations by March 1.
The United Nations has warned that this will exacerbate the humanitarian crisis in the war-ravaged Palestinian territory.
“Organizations that have failed to meet required security and transparency standards will have their licenses suspended,” Israel’s Ministry of Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism said in a statement.
Several NGOS have said the requirements contravene international humanitarian law or endanger their independence.
Israel says the new regulation aims to prevent bodies it accuses of supporting terrorism from operating in the Palestinian territories.
Prominent humanitarian organizations hit by the ban include Doctors Without Borders (MSF), the Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC), World Vision International and Oxfam, according to a ministry list.
In MSF’s case, Israel accused it of having two employees who were members of Palestinian militant groups Islamic Jihad and Hamas.
MSF said this week the request to share a list of its staff “may be in violation of Israel’s obligations under international humanitarian law” and said it “would never knowingly employ people engaging in military activity.”
‘Critical requirement’ 
NRC spokesperson Shaina Low told AFP its local staff are “exhausted” and international staff “bring them an extra layer of help and security. Their presence is a protection.”
Submitting the names of local staff is “not negotiable,” she said. “We offered alternatives, they refused,” hse said, of the Israeli regulators.
The ministry said Thursday: “The primary failure identified was the refusal to provide complete and verifiable information regarding their employees, a critical requirement designed to prevent the infiltration of terrorist operatives into humanitarian structures.”
In March, Israel gave NGOs 10 months to comply with the new rules, which demand the “full disclosure of personnel, funding sources, and operational structures.”
The deadline expired on Wednesday.
The 37 NGOs “were formally notified that their licenses would be revoked as of January 1, 2026, and that they must complete the cessation of their activities by March 1, 2026,” the ministry said Thursday.
A ministry spokesperson told AFP that following the revocation of their licenses, aid groups could no longer bring assistance into Gaza from Thursday.
However, they could have their licenses reinstated if they submitted the required documents before March 1.
Minister of Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism Amichai Chikli said “the message is clear: humanitarian assistance is welcome — the exploitation of humanitarian frameworks for terrorism is not.”
‘Weaponization of bureaucracy’
On Thursday, 18 Israel-based left-wing NGOs denounced the decision to ban their international peers, saying “the new registration framework violates core humanitarian principles of independence and neutrality.”
“This weaponization of bureaucracy institutionalizes barriers to aid and forces vital organizations to suspend operations,” they said.
UN Palestinian refugee agency chief Philippe Lazzarini had said the move sets a “dangerous precedent.”
“Failing to push back against attempts to control the work of aid organizations will further undermine the basic humanitarian principles of neutrality, independence, impartiality and humanity underpinning aid work across the world,” he said on X.
On Tuesday, the foreign ministers of 10 countries, including France and Britain, urged Israel to “guarantee access” to aid in the Gaza Strip, where they said the humanitarian situation remains “catastrophic.”
A fragile ceasefire has been in place since October, following a deadly war waged by Israel in response to Hamas’s unprecedented October 7, 2023 attack on Israel.
Nearly 80 percent of buildings in Gaza have been destroyed or damaged by the war, according to UN data.
About 1.5 million of Gaza’s more than two million residents have lost their homes, said Amjad Al-Shawa, director of the Palestinian NGO Network in Gaza.