Repeated arrests, filthy cells: Inside Pakistan’s crackdown 

Police detain Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party activists and supporters of Pakistan's former Prime Minister Imran Khan, while they protest against his arrest in Karachi on May 11, 2023. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 06 June 2023
Follow

Repeated arrests, filthy cells: Inside Pakistan’s crackdown 

  • Pakistan has been unsettled since Khan was ousted from office as prime minister in 2022 and launched street protests for fresh polls 
  • A full-blown economic crisis, with runaway inflation, plunge in currency and the possibility of debt default, has added to the turmoil 

ISLAMABAD: Hammad Azhar, who has served as Pakistan’s finance and energy minister, says police and plain-clothed officials have burst into his home six times in recent weeks, smashed his belongings, and threatened his 82-year-old father, warning that his daughter would be abducted. 

Last weekend, he said police and “unknown people” took his father to a police station and released him after they went through his phone for an hour. 

Azhar, who is in hiding, says he is under pressure from a “fascist regime” to leave the political party of former Prime Minister Imran Khan, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI). 

“All this is being done because I continue to stand with my party and Imran Khan,” he told Reuters by telephone. 

Like other senior members of the PTI who have been arrested in recent weeks, in some cases several times, Azhar avoided directly naming the powerful army as being responsible. 

Khan however has done so, throwing down the gauntlet to an institution that has ruled the country directly for three decades or exerted considerable influence on the civilian government. 

“It is completely the establishment,” the former cricket hero said in an interview. “Establishment obviously means the military establishment, because they are really now openly — I mean, it’s not even hidden now — they’re just out in the open.” 

The government and police deny any coercion of Khan’s supporters. An army spokesman did not respond to repeated requests for comment. 

Azhar is wanted on terrorism charges for violent nationwide protests in May and no warrants were needed to raid his home, said Punjab police chief Usman Anwar. Azhar denies the charges. 

Nuclear-armed Pakistan has been unsettled since Khan was ousted from office as prime minister in 2022 and launched street protests for fresh elections. A full-blown economic crisis, with runaway inflation, a plunge in the currency, and the possibility of a debt default, has added to the turmoil. 

Khan’s arrest on corruption charges in May, which he says was at the behest of the generals, led to violent nationwide protests, attacks on an air base, military buildings, including its army’s headquarters, and the burning of a top general’s home, allegedly by the former prime minister’s supporters. 

There has never been that kind of challenge to Pakistan’s military, which has held sway over the country since independence in 1947 with a mixture of fear and respect. 

Full-blown campaign 

Nearly 5,000 of Khan’s aides and supporters have been arrested since May 9, according to Interior Minister Rana Sanaullah. Rights groups have raised concerns over arbitrary arrests and forced disappearances. 

Of the many pro-Khan parliamentarians arrested in the weeks-long crackdown, several have been re-arrested after securing bail from the courts. 

All the leaders who have been set free have publicly distanced themselves from Khan, denounced the protests, and praised the military. 

“The entire senior leadership is in jail,” Khan said in the interview. “And the only ones who can now get out of jail are the ones who then say that we renounce being part of PTI.” 

His spokesman Iftikhar Durrani added: “It is a full-blown campaign to dismantle the party.” 

“(Party members’) families are being threatened with consequences — physical, mental and financial... to force a leader to quit,” Durrani said. 

When Reuters reached out to four of the released politicians for comment on their departures from the party, a former government minister replied in a WhatsApp message: “Situation doesn’t allow.” 

One said he didn’t want to talk about it, and the other two did not respond. 

The first of the key aides to quit Khan’s party was former Human Rights Minister Shireen Mazari, who was a close confidant of Khan. 

She was arrested on May 11 in a police raid on her home, and a court ordered her release five days later. However, she was re-arrested just as she stepped out of jail and taken to another premises. This happened three more times. 

Finally, on May 23, shortly after being released for a fifth time, she held a press conference announcing she was quitting politics. She was not re-arrested after that. 

'Parting ways' 

Fawad Chaudhry, a former information minister, and a close Khan aide, was arrested on May 10 outside the Supreme Court despite having protective bail. He was surrounded by police again after a court ordered his release a few days later. 

“I have decided to take a break from politics, therefore, I have resigned from party position and parting ways from Imran Khan,” Chaudhry said in a post on Twitter after he was finally released. 

Other top aides who have been re-arrested despite release orders from courts include former Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi and former ministers Ali Muhammad Khan, Shehryar Afridi, and Yasmin Rashid, who walked out of jail only to be redirected to a waiting police vehicle, which took them to another detention site. 

“Yes, there is a lot of pressure, but I’m not ditching the party,” another senior leader, Mehmood-ur-Rasheed, 69, told reporters in handcuffs as he appeared for a court appearance. He remains in custody. 

He told a court last week that he had been tortured in custody, his lawyer Masood Gujjar said. Police deny torturing Rasheed. 

Malaika Bukhari, a staunch Khan loyalist who exited the party in late May, cited the ordeal of being incarcerated in a “c-class” cell, where she spent about two weeks, in the summer heat. 

C-class cells are small rooms usually crammed with multiple inmates without proper ventilation and a hole in the corner without a door to use as a toilet. 

“I announce that I’m resigning from PTI and ending all association with the party,” she said in a press conference, condemning the attacks on military property. She said she was doing so of her own volition. 

People from Khan’s party have said, like her, many of the others arrested in the crackdown were held in similar, if not worse, conditions. 

Lawyers say political prisoners are usually entitled to B-class cells, which come with a clean toilet and other facilities such as newspapers and the availability of books. 

Ali Zaidi, a former minister for maritime affairs, left the PTI late last month after spending over a week in a prison in the city of Jacobabad — often the hottest place on earth — where he was transferred after being re-arrested. 

“I’ve decided, and it was a tough decision, that I will quit politics,” he said, adding: “The armed forces are our pride.” 

Past campaigns 

There has been no mention of Khan on local television since the government issued a directive last week not to give air time to “hate mongers, rioters, their facilitators, and perpetrators.” It did not name Khan. 

Most newspapers have also stopped covering him. 

“Media has completely been muzzled,” Khan said. “My name cannot be mentioned on media now. My PTI representatives cannot appear on the media anymore.” 

Critics and analysts say the crackdown replicates past military-led campaigns used to break other political parties in a country where no elected prime minister has ever completed a full term since independence. 

Ahead of the 2018 elections which brought Khan to power, the outgoing party of former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif had also alleged that the army was forcing its parliamentarians to switch sides to tip the scale in favor of the former cricket hero. 

But the threats were veiled then, analysts said. Now the magnitude is higher and more open, largely because the military is outraged by the attacks on its assets, the analysts say. 

Spokespersons for the military did not respond to requests for comment on this. 

“The military is striking back with a vengeance,” said Aqil Shah, an academic and author of the book “The Army and Democracy in Pakistan.” 

Outgoing army chief General Qamar Javed Bajwa said during his last days in office last year that the army had meddled in the country’s politics for decades but had decided that it will no longer do so. 

Khan has accused current army chief General Asim Munir of continuing Bajwa’s campaign against him. The army has said the attacks on military installations on May 9 were “pre-planned” by Khan’s party leaders and had resolved to bring to book everyone involved. 

Khan is facing abetment charges, according to a police report seen by Reuters. 

“The military is in command of operation ‘get PTI’,” said Shah, the author. 

“I think we’re seeing the PTI’s controlled demolition,” he said. 


Pakistan working to issue domestic green sukuk bonds by December — finance minister

Updated 1 min 17 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan working to issue domestic green sukuk bonds by December — finance minister

  • Proceeds of green bonds used to finance climate change mitigation, adaptation and environmental projects
  • According to recent World Bank study, Pakistan faces potential annual GDP losses of up to 1 percent due to climate-related risks

KARACHI: Federal Minister for Finance and Revenue Muhammad Aurangzeb said on Friday the Pakistan government was working to issue domestic green sukuk bonds by December 2024 to fund environmentally sustainable infrastructure projects. 

The green sukuk is a Shariah-compliant interest-free bond in which instead of interest, investors receive an agreed share of the profits generated by the pool of underlying assets, which are partially owned by investors. Proceeds of green bonds are used to finance climate change mitigation and adaptation, and environmental projects. 

“The government is working on issuing domestic green sukuk bonds by December 2024 to finance sustainable development projects,” Aurangzeb said as he delivered an online keynote speech at the UK-Pakistan Green Investment Forum, organized by the British High Commission in Pakistan. 

In his address, the finance minister emphasized Pakistan’s commitment to addressing climate change and promoting green investment opportunities, and highlighted Pakistan’s vulnerability to the adverse effects of climate change, despite its low contribution to global greenhouse gas emissions. 

According to a recent World Bank study, Pakistan faces potential annual GDP losses of up to 1 percent due to climate-related risks.

Acknowledging a significant funding gap in adaptation, resilience, and mitigation projects and the need for a better portfolio of green investment projects, the minister emphasized Pakistan’s reliance on the private sector for support in this regard and highlighted the government’s efforts to enhance investor confidence in bankable green opportunities. 

He also outlined Pakistan’s plans to utilize innovative financing instruments like green sukuk to raise international climate finance. 

Pakistan ranks among the top 10 countries worldwide most affected by climate change and natural disasters.


Pakistani satellite relays first images of moon from lunar orbit

Updated 10 May 2024
Follow

Pakistani satellite relays first images of moon from lunar orbit

  • ICUBE-Qamar was launched aboard China’s Chang’e-6 probe on May 3
  • The Chinese probe is tasked with landing on the far side of the moon

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s first satellite, ICUBE-Qamar (ICUBE-Q), has successfully beamed back first images of the moon, the Institute of Space Technology (IST) in Islamabad said on Friday, days after it entered the lunar orbit.
The ICUBE-Qamar satellite carries two optical cameras to image the lunar surface and weighs around 7kg. Cubesats are tiny box-shaped satellites that are mainly launched into low Earth orbit to observe the Earth, test new communications technology, or perform miniature experiments.
The satellite was launched aboard China’s Chang’e-6 probe on May 3. The Chinese probe is tasked with landing on the far side of the moon, which perpetually faces away from the Earth, after which it will retrieve and return samples. China is the first country to make such an ambitious attempt.
“Exciting news from ICUBE-Q! Our satellite has captured its first images, and they’re stunning,” IST, which contributed to the satellite’s development, wrote on X.
“Check out these shots where you can see both the moon and the sun in some of the images. Stay tuned for more updates from ICUBE-Q!“

Soon after the satellite entered the lunar orbit at 1:14pm Pakistan time on Wednesday, Dr. Khurram Khurshid, the head of the electrical engineering and computer science department at the IST and a co-lead on the project, said initial tests revealed there were no complications with the cubesat’s system.
The development meant Pakistan was officially in an exclusive club of countries that had conducted deep space missions, the official added.
Around 100 students from the IST contributed to developing the satellite. Pakistan’s proposal to build the satellite was accepted by the China National Space Agency (CNSA) from plans submitted by eight member states of the Asia-Pacific Space Cooperation Organization (APSCO).
The design, development, and qualification of the ICUBE-Q satellite were spearheaded by faculty members and students of the IST in collaboration with China’s Shanghai Jiao Tong University (SJTU), with support from Pakistan’s National Space Agency, SUPARCO.

 


Pakistan, Gulf states in final stages of talks on Free Trade Agreement — PM Sharif

Updated 10 May 2024
Follow

Pakistan, Gulf states in final stages of talks on Free Trade Agreement — PM Sharif

  • Pakistan and the Gulf Cooperation Council signed a ‘preliminary’ FTA in September last year
  • The development comes amid Pakistan efforts to boost trade to stabilize dwindling economy

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan and the Gulf states are in final stages of discussions regarding a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between the two sides, Pakistani state media reported on Friday.
Pakistan and the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) signed a “preliminary” FTA in September last year, with the country’s commerce ministry calling it a “milestone in both sides’ economic cooperation.” The GCC also said the agreement represented “an important turning point in cooperation.”
In 2022, both sides held technical-level talks to examine the possibility of an FTA that could help Pakistan boost exports to the six-nation bloc, which includes Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Oman, Qatar, and Kuwait.
Presiding over a meeting on the trade sector, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif asked the authorities to formulate trade policies with the core objective of facilitating the country’s business sector, the state-run APP news agency reported.
“In the meeting, the prime minister was told that the discussion on the Free Trade Agreement between Pakistan and the Gulf states was in the final stage and transit trade agreements with Uzbekistan and Tajikistan had already been materialized,” the report read.
During a recent Pakistan-Saudi Business Conference, according to the report, around 450 business-to-business meetings were held and the volume of e-commerce trade was witnessing a constant increase, with the enlisting of over 3,000 firms on the Pakistan Trade Portal.
Pakistan has welcomed numerous foreign officials and business delegations in recent weeks, encouraging local partnerships and asking them to explore investment opportunities across various economic sectors.
A Saudi business delegation, consisting of senior representatives from nearly 35 companies, recently concluded its visit to Pakistan, during which the delegates held several business-to-business meetings. Additionally, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif met with a group of Japanese industrialists, urging them to invest in Pakistan’s nascent electric car industry.
The country is also expecting the visit of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman later this month, hoping it would bring several billion dollars in investment.
During the meeting on the trade sector, the prime minister called for steps to promote exports of non-traditional goods and instructed authorities for immediate payment of certified duty drawbacks to exporters, according to the APP report.
He instructed officials to ensure consultation with them during the policy-making and implement the deletion policy to uplift the auto sector.
“Prime Minister Shehbaz directed the relevant ministry to devise a comprehensive strategy to scrutinize the performance of trade and investment officers posted in Pakistan’s missions abroad by rewarding the good performers and removing the incompetent ones,” the report read further.
The development comes as Pakistan seeks a fresh bailout from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to stabilize its dwindling economy after completing its $3 billion IMF bailout deal that helped avert a default last year.
The South Asian country currently has Free Trade Agreements with China, Malaysia, and Sri Lanka, but it still needs to increase exports to other trade destinations.


Historic cuts in Pakistan car prices a ‘marketing stunt’ amid slow demand — experts

Updated 57 min 23 sec ago
Follow

Historic cuts in Pakistan car prices a ‘marketing stunt’ amid slow demand — experts

  • Lucky Motor Company, which assembles KIA cars in Pakistan, and Pak Suzuki Motors recently reduced Stonic, Swift prices by up to Rs1.5 million
  • Experts say the automakers wanted to “test” the market through the stunt and the benefit would not end customers as it was opened for few days

KARACHI: The recent historic cuts in prices of multiple car models were a “marketing stunt” by automakers in Pakistan, experts and dealers said on Friday, attributing it to slow demand in the South Asian country.
Lucky Motor Company, which assembles KIA cars in Pakistan, reduced the price of KIA Stonic by as much as Rs1,500,000, followed by a cut in Swift price by up to Rs710,000.
The rate cuts by Kia and Pak Suzuki Motors came on the heels of a reduction in prices of Toyota Yaris by Rs133,000 and Honda City by Rs140,000 respectively in March.
While KIA and Pak Suzuki Motors have said they received an “overwhelming” to the price drops, experts believe it to be a marketing stunt to help struggling models fare better in the Pakistani market.
“They (LMC) played a game because they had about 300-350 (KIA Stonic) cars lying dead which were not sold,” Hajji Muhammad Shahzad, chairman of All Pakistan Motor Dealers Association (APMDA), told Arab News.
“They threw [them] in the market and stopped the booking.”
Shahzad said the price cut by the LMC generated interest among investors who booked the car instead of “genuine buyers,” noting that the car would come with around Rs500,000 own money as well.
Mashood Ali Khan, an auto industry expert, believed that price plays a key role in the auto sector, because of the current economic situation and prevailing high inflation. He said the LMC wanted to “test” the market.
“The people who have booked, maybe I am wrong, but I think they are mostly the investors,” Khan told Arab News. “It could not reach the end consumers as it was opened for two days.”
Reached for comment, LMC Chief Executive Officer Muhammad Faisal said they corrected the KIA Stonic price to help it compete with sedan cars available in Pakistan and “took the hit” themselves, though the automaker didn’t anticipate the overwhelming response to the price cut.
“We tried to bring it to the price point at which competing sedans are available,” Faisal told Arab News. “When we brought it to this price point, the response from the market was unbelievable and better than our expectations.”
Though a Pak Suzuki Motor official did not respond to Arab News query about the cut in Swift price, the company said in a circular it had received an “overwhelming” response and was now introducing “stylish combinations” of a two-tone exterior.
Shahzad, however, said Swift did not get a “good response” despite the price cut. 
A decrease in car prices was already expected as the Pakistani government notified in March it would charge 25 percent sales tax on locally assembled cars, if their invoice price exceeded Rs4 million.
Car sales declined in Pakistan by 38 percent during nine months of the current fiscal year, which began on July 1, amid a declining trend in auto financing, historic high interest rate, soaring prices and shrinking purchasing power of consumers, according to a research report by the Karachi-based Darson Securities.
Asked about the delivery of vehicles to customers, LMC CEO Faisal said the company had not delivered the newly booked Stonic cars and was still filtering buyers.
“We have just made a commitment that we will deliver it now,” he told Arab News. “We have ensured that we will book one car per CNIC (computerized national identity card), we are filtering the investors, we are giving preference to genuine customers, so that we can deliver it soon.”
Faisal said the automaker was evaluating its stock position after the current response and it would resume bookings, however, the company would be giving delivery commitments for October onwards.
Car prices have increased in Pakistan by around 40 percent in the last two years and the costs of vehicles remain high despite the recent cuts, according to car dealers.
Khan, the auto sector expert, called for localization of auto parts and a 10-year policy to promote auto industrialization to make affordable cars in Pakistan.


Pakistan seeks Beijing’s support for completion of 1,800MW hydropower projects

Updated 10 May 2024
Follow

Pakistan seeks Beijing’s support for completion of 1,800MW hydropower projects

  • The Kohala and Azad Pattan hydropower projects have reportedly been delayed for past several months
  • Beijing is investing more than $65 billion in energy and infrastructure projects in Pakistan as part of CPEC

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has sought Chinese support for early completion of two hydropower projects, Pakistani state media reported on Thursday, amid the minister’s visit to China.
The 1,124 megawatts (MW) Kohala and 700MW Azad Pattan hydropower projects have been delayed for the past several months, according to media reports.
In his meeting with National Energy Administration of China’s Chairman Zhang Jianghua, Iqbal said his government intended to diversify energy mix toward clean and renewable energy.
“In that context, Minister for Planning sought Chinese continued cooperation for the early implementation of the Azad Pattan and Kohala Hydro Power Projects,” the state-run Radio Pakistan broadcaster reported.
Beijing is investing over $65 billion in energy and infrastructure projects in Pakistan as part of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a major segment of Beijing’s Belt and Road infrastructure initiative, which will connect China to the Arabian Sea and help Islamabad expand and modernize its economy through a network of roads, railways, pipelines and ports in Pakistan.
During the meeting, the two sides also discussed new initiatives to improve energy management system, aimed at reducing theft and line losses, according to the report.
“We intend to reform energy sector to be efficient and affordable in order to provide electricity to consumers and businesses at cheaper rates by cutting line losses and power theft,” Iqbal was quoted as saying.
The meeting was part of Iqbal’s engagements in Beijing to prepare for the next round of Joint Coordination Committee meeting as well as for the preparation of an upcoming visit of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to China.
Earlier, the minister met officials of top Chinese companies, including Power China, TBEA Co. Ltd., and Electric Power Planning and Engineering Institute, that specialize in power transmission and distribution.