Pakistan degrades Wikipedia's services for 48 hours over content 'blasphemous' to Islam

The "Wikipedia" logo is seen on a tablet screen on December 4, 2012 in Paris. (Photo courtesy: AFP/FILE)
Short Url
Updated 01 February 2023

Pakistan degrades Wikipedia's services for 48 hours over content 'blasphemous' to Islam

  • PTA says it had degraded Wikipedia's services "on account of not blocking/removing sacrilegious contents"
  • Digital rights activists question government’s move, say depriving million from information ‘unfortunate’

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s telecommunication regulator on Wednesday announced it had degraded online encyclopedia Wikipedia’s services for 48 hours across the country, accusing it of failing to block or remove “blasphemous content” from its platform.

Pakistan, the second-largest Muslim-majority country in the world, has banned video streaming platforms and dating apps in the past on charges of spreading “immorality” or promoting blasphemous content. Degradation of services means disruption in the service speed and the response time of a website or any network.

In September 2020, Pakistan blocked Tinder, Grindr and three other dating apps for not adhering to local laws, with the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) saying it had taken the decision to curb the “negative effects of immoral/indecent content streaming.”

In November 2021, a Pakistan court reversed a ban on short-form video hosting service TikTok after the government assured it would monitor “immoral” content on the app with the company. Similarly in 2012, the South Asian country banned YouTube after a 2012 anti-Islam film was uploaded to the site. The ban was finally lifted in 2016 after remaining in place for three years.

In a press release, the PTA said it had degraded Wikipedia’s services “on account of not blocking/removing sacrilegious contents.”

It added that the platform was approached for blocking/removal of the said contents by issuing a notice under applicable law and court order and was also provided an opportunity to appear before a PTA hearing.

“They (Wikipedia) have been asked to remove the content but they have not responded at all,” PTA spokesperson Malahat Obaid told Arab News.

In its press release, the PTA said the reported blasphemous contents have been blocked across the country while Wikipedia’s services have been degraded for 48 hours. “In case of non-compliance by Wikipedia the platform will be blocked within Pakistan,” it added.

The regulator said it remains committed to ensuring a safe online experience for all Pakistani citizens according to local laws. “The restoration of the services of Wikipedia will be reconsidered subject to blocking/removal of the reported unlawful contents,” it added.

Usama Khilji a director at Bolo Bhi, an advocacy forum for digital rights, said the PTA needs to understand how crowdsourced platforms work where any user was free to upload content.

“Blocking an entire encyclopedia with millions of valuable pieces of information is counterproductive and will only impact Pakistani citizens’ right to information and access to knowledge and education,” he told Arab News.

Such short-sighted policies of the PTA contribute to making Pakistan a more regressive and backward country, he added.

“Abuse of laws and censorship of this massive scale needs to stop and we need to enable our citizens to progress in modern age rather than create roadblocks that do not address the root cause of the issue which PTA is trying to solve,” Khilji said.

Nighat Dad, a digital rights activist, said the authority had not mentioned in its statement under which laws it took action against the platform.

“If they are using social media laws, then the authority is violating Islamabad High Court’s order in which the court asked for more discussion before implementing these laws,” she told Arab News.

Such platforms feature diverse information on various topics, she said, adding that it should be the user’s prerogative to access whatever information he wanted to access and what not to.

“The government or regulator should not deprive everyone of access to free information by blocking such platforms,” she added.

Another digital rights activist, Asad Baig, said instead of taking extreme measures to degrade or block such platforms’ services, the regulator should block the specific pages only.

“If PTA wants to remove sacrilegious content, they should block only those URLs or pages that contain such material instead of blocking the complete platform as this facility is available internationally,” he told Arab News.

“Wikipedia services are used by millions of people for different purposes and depriving them all is unfortunate,” he added.


Pakistan's Imran Khan formally named in 'abetting' lawyer's drive-by murder

Updated 07 June 2023

Pakistan's Imran Khan formally named in 'abetting' lawyer's drive-by murder

  • Murdered lawyer Abdur Razaq filed court petition seeking sedition proceedings against Khan
  • Last week, Khan was released on bail on terrorism charges of abetting violence against military

QUETTA, Pakistan: Pakistani police on Wednesday formally named former Prime Minister Imran Khan in connection with the murder by unknown gunmen of a lawyer seeking sedition proceedings against him.

Police registered an "abetment to murder" case against former cricket hero Khan, 70, who faces dozens of charges since his ouster in a parliamentary vote of confidence in April last year.

Khan, who has not been charged in connection with the lawyer's murder, has dismissed all the cases against him as concocted by his opponents.

In a live online broadcast, Khan denied the allegations adding that he would appear in court on Thursday to seek bail for 16 other cases.

Provincial government spokesman Babar Khan said Khan could face formal charges if and when the murder case goes to trial.

Abdur Razaq, the murdered lawyer, had filed a court petition seeking sedition proceedings against Khan for dissolving his government after the no-confidence motion.

Razaq was on his way to court on Tuesday when gunmen on a motorcycle shot and killed him, police said.

Razaq's son, Siraj Ahmad, also a lawyer, told police that his father had been killed by unknown men with the "abetment of the former prime minister", according to a police report filed by him and seen by Reuters.

It was not immediately clear how the link between unknown gunmen and Khan was made.

Last week, Khan was released on bail on terrorism charges of abetting violence against the military by his protesting supporters after he was arrested and detained on May 9 in a corruption case.

The embattled Khan is embroiled in a confrontation with the powerful military, which has ruled Pakistan directly or overseen civilian governments throughout its history.

His May 9 arrest sparked widespread protests by his supporters who ransacked military facilities, raising new worries about the stability of the nuclear-armed South Asian nation as it struggles with its worst economic crisis in decades.

Khan has appealed for talks to end the standoff with the military. The government has rejected his call and the military has said enactors and masterminds of the May 9 violence would be tried under army laws. 

Khan has accused the military and its intelligence agency of openly trying to destroy his party, saying he has "no doubt" he will be tried in a military court and thrown into jail. The military has said it is not behind a crackdown on political activities. 


China, Pakistan, Iran hold counter-terrorism talks in Beijing

Updated 07 June 2023

China, Pakistan, Iran hold counter-terrorism talks in Beijing

  • Delegations discuss regional security situation, particularly threat of terrorism faced by region
  • Teams decide to institutionalize trilateral consultations on counter terrorism and security

ISLAMABAD: China, Pakistan and Iran held their first trilateral meeting on counter-terrorism in Beijing on Wednesday, the Pakistani foreign ministry said in a statement.

The delegations held detailed discussions on the regional security situation, particularly the threat of terrorism faced by the region.

“Based on the outcome of these consultations, they decided to institutionalize the Trilateral Consultations on counter terrorism and security for which further details will be worked out,” the Pakistani FO said.

A statement by the Chinese foreign ministry said the three countries had "in-depth" exchanges on the regional counter-terrorism situation, and decided to hold the meeting on a regular basis.

Abdul Hameed, director general of counter terrorism at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, led Pakistan’s delegation while the Chinese delegation was headed by Bai Tian, director general of the Department of External Security Affairs at the Chinese foreign ministry. The Iranian delegation was led by assistant to the Iranian foreign minister, Seyed Rasoul Mosavi.

The FO said Hameed and Mosavi also called on Assistant Foreign Minister of China Nong Rong.

Last month, Pakistan had also held trilateral talks with China and Afghanistan in Islamabad.


Pakistan appoints high-level official to resolve issues related to TAPI gas pipeline

Updated 07 June 2023

Pakistan appoints high-level official to resolve issues related to TAPI gas pipeline

  • Construction of Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India project stalled for years
  • Reasons for the delay relate to differences over price review and delivery points

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan has decided to appoint a senior official to resolve issues related to the Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India (TAPI) gas pipeline project, whose construction has remained stalled for years, the petroleum ministry said on Wednesday.

The pipeline will link the energy-rich Central Asian country of Turkmenistan through Afghanistan to Pakistan and India, and is expected to carry 33 billion cubic meters (bcm) of natural gas each year along a route stretching 1,800 km (1,125 miles) from Galkynysh, the world's second-biggest gas field, to the Indian city of Fazilka near the Pakistan border.

The Afghan stretch of the pipeline will run from the northwestern border with Turkmenistan, south through the western city of Herat to Kandahar near the border with Pakistan.

“TAPI is a transformation agenda for the region, not just a pipeline,” state minister for petroleum Dr Musadik Malik was quoted as saying in a statement released by the Pakistani ministry of petroleum after Malik held a meeting with a delegation from Turkmenistan led by State Minister and Chairman of Turkmengas, Maksat Babayev.

“Meeting agreed to appoint a high-level official from Pakistan to resolve open issues. Technical working group on TAPI will hold extensive meeting today,” the statement added.

Work on the project has been stalled due to differences over price review and delivery points.

As per the original deal, Pakistan, Afghanistan and India would have 15% share of gas, while Turkmenistan would get 85%. Under the existing gas sale-purchase agreement, the gas delivery point is the Afghanistan-Turkmenistan border, which Pakistan wants moved to the Pakistan-Afghanistan border.


Pakistan army says time to ‘tighten noose’ around masterminds of attacks on military properties

Updated 07 June 2023

Pakistan army says time to ‘tighten noose’ around masterminds of attacks on military properties

  • Strongly-worded statement by army being widely seen as veiled reference to ex-PM Imran Khan
  • Khan’s arrest on corruption charges in May led to attacks by his supporters on military buildings 

ISLAMABAD: The Pakistan army said on Wednesday it was time to tighten the “noose of law” against those who had masterminded attacks on military buildings last month, in what is being widely seen as a reference to former Prime Minister Imran Khan.

Khan’s arrest on corruption charges on May 9, which he says was at the behest of top generals in cahoots with the civilian government of PM Shehbaz Sharif — both deny involvement — led to violent nationwide protests, with rioters attacking an air base, military properties, including the army’s headquarters, and burning a top general’s home. Demonstrators also attacked government and private buildings and vehicles.

Since the protests, dozens of members of Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party and hundreds of his supporters have been arrested in what local and international rights bodies have widely called a state crackdown. The army and government have both publicly said the instigators and enactors of the violence would be punished and those who attacked army properties would be tried by military courts. Dozens of arrested suspects have since been handed over to the army for trials.

In a strongly-worded statement released on Wednesday after a meeting of top Pakistani military commanders, the army reiterated that it would punish those who had attacked its properties as well as go after the masterminds of the violence.

“While the legal trials of perpetrators and instigators have commenced, it is time that noose of law is also tightened around the planners and masterminds who mounted the hate ripened and politically driven rebellion against the state and state institutions to achieve their nefarious design of creating chaos in the country,” the army’s media wing, ISPR, said.

“Forum also resolved that endeavours by any quarter to create obstructions and stymie the conclusive defeat of ill design of inimical forces will be dealt with iron hands.”

Responding for the first time to widespread accusations that the army was behind a crackdown against Khan, his party and its supporters and carrying out human rights violations, the army called this “fake news and propaganda” that it would defeat with the support of the Pakistani public:

“Unfounded and baseless allegations on Law Enforcement Agencies and Security Forces for custodial torture, human rights abuses and stifling of political activities are meant to mislead the people and malign Armed Forces in order to achieve trivial vested political interests.”

The army reiterated that those who had damaged military properties would be brought to justice “speedily under the Pakistan Army Act and Official Secret Act which are the derivatives of the Constitution of Pakistan.”

“In this regard, efforts to create distortions and attempts to take refuge behind imaginary and mirage Human Rights Violations to create smoke screen for hiding the ugly faces of all involved, are absolutely futile and do not stand the abundantly collected irrefutable evidences,” ISPR said.

The military’s statement comes as mention of Khan has blacked out on local television, following a directive last week by the national media regulator not to give airtime to “hate mongers, rioters, their facilitators and perpetrators.” The directive did not name Khan.

Most newspapers, in which Khan was for years front page news, have also stopped covering him.

Since being ousted from the PM’s office in a no-trust vote in April last year, Khan has launched an unprecedented campaign of defiance against the military, which independent analysts say helped him rise and fall from power.

The military has ruled Pakistan directly or indirectly for most of its 75-year history but says it no longer interferes in political affairs. 


Pakistan to save $1 billion annually through new energy conservation plan — government document

Updated 07 June 2023

Pakistan to save $1 billion annually through new energy conservation plan — government document

  • Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal this week announced all markets in Pakistan would close at 8pm from July 1
  • The move is part of a larger plan by the government to spur economic growth through the SE4ALL action plan

KARACHI: Cash-strapped Pakistan plans to save $1 billion per year through a new energy conservation plan that calls for, among other measures, closing markets across the country earlier than normal business hours, according to a government document, though Pakistani business leaders have rejected the proposal as “unrealistic” and “illogical.”  

Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal this week announced that the National Economic Council (NEC) had approved a proposal to close all markets across the country at 8pm from July 1.

The move is part of a larger scheme by the government to spur economic growth through an action plan called Export, E-Pakistan, Environment and Climate change, Energy and infrastructure and Equity and Empowerment or 5Es framework and Sustainable Energy for All (SE4ALL), a brain child of the planning ministry.  

The energy conservation plan and associated implementation roadmap was approved by the federal cabinet in January 2023 while the National Energy Efficiency and Conservation Policy 2023, prepared by the National Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority (NEECA), was approved by the federal cabinet on May 10, 2023.

“The easy to deploy short- and medium-term administrative measures proposed under this conservation plan could save estimated outflow of USD ($) One billion per annum in terms of energy saving,” a government document seen by Arab News said.

Listing measures under the plan, the document said:

“The closure of commercial markets at 8 pm which will result in annual energy saving of 2.85 billion electricity units and will offer a financial saving of 282 million USD, Ban on the incandescent bulbs which will result in a saving of 1 billion electricity units in a year with a financial benefit of 103 million USD, Mandatory installation of the conical baffles in the water geysers which will save 419 million USD.”

Overall, the long-term implementation of the NEECA policy measures will result in financial savings of $6.4 billion from 2030 onwards, according to official estimates.    

The South Asian nation last attempted to enforce early market closures in June and December 2022 but was met with resistance from traders. This time too, Pakistani traders have rejected the government’s plan, saying it will cause revenue and job losses at a time that the country is grappling with record inflation, fiscal imbalances, and low reserves.

“We strongly reject the government's plan to shut down markets at 8pm,” Kashif Chaudhry, the president of the Markazi Tanzeem-e-Tajran Pakistan, a central body of traders, said in a statement. “The decision has been taken in haste without consulting traders. It is an unrealistic plan.”  

Chaudhry called the plan an “enemy of traders and the public,” and said such “illogical energy conservation plans” had also failed in the past.
 
Atiq Mir, the chairman of the All Karachi Tajir Ittehad, the main business association in the city, concurred with Chaudhry.

“The decision is not practicable,” he told Arab News. “Such decisions were taken in the past and could not be implemented.”  

Retail sector stakeholders said the government’s decision would impact both revenue generation and employment rates.

“I think the decision taken is not realistic under the current economic downturn and would put the livelihood of around three million people at stake,” Rana Tariq Mehboob, the chairman of the Chainstore Association of Pakistan (CAP), told Arab News.

“This decision will hit the economy with around Rs3.6 trillion losses while it is already reeling under the impact of slowdown.”  

Experts also said there was little hope the new plan would be implemented.

“They will not be able to implement this time too,” Ammar Habib Khan, an economist and energy expert, told Arab News. “Due to weak administration and weak enforcement mechanisms, you can’t implement this energy saving action plan … In fact, there is no will to enforce it.”    

Ahsan Iqbal and other planning ministry officials did not respond to Arab News queries about expected measures to enforce the energy saving plan.