ISLAMABAD: A sessions court in Islamabad on Tuesday reserved its verdict in the Noor Mukadam murder case after all sides concluded their arguments, bringing to a close hearings that have gripped the nation and a trial that is one of the most-closely watched in recent Pakistani history.
The trial for the case formally started at Islamabad’s district court in October last year, with additional sessions judge Atta Rabbani conducting hearings. The judge reserved his verdict on Tuesday after the completion of arguments by both the defense and prosecution attorneys, saying he would announce it on February 24, Thursday.
Mukadam, the daughter of a former Pakistani diplomat, was found beheaded in Islamabad’s upscale F-7/4 neighborhood in July last year. The murder sparked public outrage and grabbed media attention unlike any other recent crime against women. The key suspect in the murder, Zahir Jaffer, was arrested from the crime scene, his residence, on the day of the murder. He was indicted last October.
Others charged in the case include Jaffer’s parents, Zakir Jaffer and Asmat Adamjee, their three household staff, Iftikhar, Jan Muhammad and Jameel, and six employees of Therapy Works, a counseling center from where Jaffer had received certification to become a therapist and where he had been receiving treatment in the weeks leading up to the murder. The charges range from abetment to concealment of evidence.
At Tuesday’s hearing, Public Prosecutor Hassan Abbas said Jaffer’s arrest from the crime scene was enough for his conviction.
“This is a clear case,” he told the court. “[Noor’s] Bloodstains were found on the suspect’s clothes and body.”
The prosecutor said forensic reports also proved Mukadam was tortured before the murder and she could be seen in CCTV footage being dragged by Jaffer back into the house as she tried to escape.
Abbas said Zahir called his father on 7:29pm to inform him about the murder, and after that the suspects established contact with Therapy Works.
The prosecutor also raised questions over the presence of Therapy Works staffers at the crime scene, saying police reached the spot while the counselling team was trying to move Zahir after tying him up with rope.
“No drug or poison was detected in the lungs of Noor Mukadam,” he told the court while referring to a forensic report.
At an earlier hearing, Jaffer, who initially confessed to the crime before police and the court, pleaded not guilty to the killing, saying he was innocent and wrongly implicated in the case. His lawyers also told the court that Mukadam had arranged a “drug party” at Jaffer’s residence on July 20 as his parents were away in Karachi, saying Jaffer fell unconscious from “overuse” of drugs and Mukadam was killed by someone else who had attended the party. At another hearing, the defense also asked the court to consider the possibility that Mukadam had been “honor killed” by her brother.
The Mukadam family’s counsel, advocate Shah Khawar, said all evidence including DNA, call data record (CDR), digital video record (DVR) and forensics was collected using scientific methods and pointed toward Jaffer’s guilt.
“The court should grant maximum punishment to all the accused,” he prayed before the court.
Talking to reporters after the conclusion of the trial, Noor Mukadam’s father Shaukat Mukadam, expressed satisfaction over the court proceedings, saying the family had sought “maximum punishment” for all accused in the case.
“We have complete trust in the judge,” he said as he appreciated the court for holding a fair trial. He also expressed satisfaction over the police investigation, saying “the police did a good job within their limitations.”
“It was a difficult time, but I trust my daughter fully,” Shaukat said. “It stands proven now from the CCTV footage and others that she was held hostage and in detention [in Jaffer house].”