Pakistan’s finance minister says refused IMF direction to impose Rs700 billion in new taxes

Pakistani Finance Minister Shaukat Tarin (L) speaks at the conclusion of the US-Pakistan Trade and Investment Council meeting in Washington on April 27, 2009. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 25 June 2021
Follow

Pakistan’s finance minister says refused IMF direction to impose Rs700 billion in new taxes

  • Shaukat Tarin told the Senate the government ruled out another increase in power tariffs to protect ordinary citizens during its talks with the IMF
  • Pakistani authorities have imposed a 75-paisa tax on calls exceeding five minutes, though they have exempted the internet and SMS from taxes

ISLAMABAD: Federal Minister for Finance and Revenue Shaukat Tarin said on Friday his government defied the International Monetary Fund (IMF) by refusing to levy new taxes of Rs700 billion while preparing the newly unveiled federal budget due to their regressive nature.
Tarin presented the budget for 2022 earlier this month with a total outlay of Rs8.4 trillion ($53.93 billion) and a revenue generation target of Rs5.829 trillion.
The finance bill also announced a growth rate of 4.8 percent for the next fiscal year.
The budget was unveiled at a time when Pakistan is in conversation with the IMF as part of the sixth review of a $6 billion bailout program that started in 2019.
The revenue target, which is 23 percent higher than the current fiscal year’s expected collection rate, has been a key sticking point between the two sides, with Pakistani authorities suggesting alternative means of achieving the goal.
“I took a stand and said this [imposition of new taxes] was coercive and not going to help our economy,” the finance minister said while delivering a wind-up budget speech in the Senate.
He said the IMF dictated Pakistan to impose Rs700 billion of new taxes in the budget, including Rs150 billion in additional income tax collection, which was plainly refused.
“This is not progressive,” Tarin claimed to have told the IMF. “We will widen the tax base to increase the revenue.”
Pakistan’s GDP growth declined in the outgoing fiscal year due to tough conditions imposed by the IMF, he said, adding that the international financial institution wanted Islamabad to keep the discount rate at 13.25 percent, currency exchange rate at Rs169, and increase in the electricity and gas tariffs.
“There will be no increase in the tariffs, and we have conveyed it to the IMF since it will burden the poor and the industry,” he continued.
To increase the revenue, the minister said, the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has received 15 million profiles including bank accounts of those who should pay their tax but have so far been evading it.
“We will use the power to arrest as a deterrent against willful and habitual defaulters after due process [of law],” he said, adding that a third party would help identify such individuals and entities.
The finance minister said Prime Minister Imran Khan had taken bold steps to spruce up the economy by offering incentives to the housing and construction industry along with the agriculture sector.
“Now our strategy is to depend on economic growth to create new jobs and boost income levels of people,” he said. “We believe in inclusive and sustainable growth.”
The finance minister said the government was introducing changes to the country’s tax collection system that will end harassment of people by FBR officials. “But we won’t spare those who are habitual defaulters,” he said. “A three-member committee will decide to arrest tax evaders after due process.”
Listing different incentives in the budget, he said the government had withdrawn 12 withholding taxes for being regressive, including withdrawal of taxes on vehicles up to 1000 cc, medical bills and provident funds of employees, and on all food items.
“We are not charging new taxes on internet and SMS, but we will collect 75 paisa on calls over five minutes,” he said, adding the government was also offering incentives to industrial and agricultural sector to boost the national economy.
“We are spreading a network of agricultural malls across the country to end the role of middlemen who are currently earning 400 to 500 percent,” he said. “The prime minister wants to introduce e-voting to ensure transparency and we have also allocated five billion rupees for that in the budget.”


Major Pakistan coalition partner opposes privatization of national airline ahead of IMF talks

Updated 06 May 2024
Follow

Major Pakistan coalition partner opposes privatization of national airline ahead of IMF talks

  • The government of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has stressed the need for a fresh, longer-term IMF program to support the economy
  • The IMF has recommended privatization of state entities, increasing tax revenue and reducing duplicated expenditures for a new program

KARACHI: The Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), one of the coalition partners in the Pakistani government, on Monday said it would resist privatization of the country’s national airline and other state entities regardless of its potential impact on the government’s talks with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) this month for a new bailout program.

Pakistan last month completed a short-term, $3 billion IMF program, which helped stave off a sovereign default, but the government of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has stressed the need for a fresh, longer-term program.

An IMF mission is expected to visit Pakistan in the mid of May to discuss the upcoming budget, policies and reforms under a potential new program. Pakistan’s financial year runs from July to June and its budget for fiscal year 2025, the first by Sharif’s new government, has to be presented before June 30.

Pakistan’s Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb on Monday said he was hopeful that the Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) and other privatization deals would get through the “finishing line” by early July.

“The IMF is not in our ten points, IMF is not part of our manifesto,” said Senator Taj Haider, a senior PPP figure, when asked if his party had assessed repercussions of its opposition to the government’s privatization move.

“Those who are the slaves of the IMF should be worried. We must stand on our own feet and not look toward the outsiders.”

The PPP, whose co-chairman Asif Ali Zardari is currently serving as the president of Pakistan, has formed a three-member committee to engage with the government on privatization issues. 

Haider said his party had already offered the government to hand over the Pakistan Steel Mills to the Sindh government which had the capacity to run it, while the PIA should be run through public-private partnership (PPP).

“Government entities, including the PIA and the Steel Mills, should not be privatized because they will sell their valuable properties and won’t make them sustainable like we have witnessed in the past,” he said. 

“No privatization has been successful, and no public-private partnership (PPP) has been unsuccessful.”

In the past, Haider said, privatization drives remained unsuccessful because the process had only been aimed at selling state properties.

“The PIA’s problem is an outcome of mismanagement,” he said. “If other airlines are making profit, then why PIA cannot do it.”

Speaking at a conference in Islamabad on Monday, Finance Minister Aurangzeb outlined reforms under a new IMF deal, saying the government had to broaden its tax base and increase the tax-to-GDP ratio.

“And the third one is the SOE [state-owned enterprises] reform,” Aurangzeb said. “Our prime minister has been very clear that the government has no business being in business … We need to and we will accelerate the privatization agenda.”

Hidayatullah Khan, president of a union of PIA employees, lamented that private airlines had been given several domestic routes of the PIA, while the aircraft of the national airline were left standing.

“If PIA is not making profit, it’s an issue of the management, whose policies have destroyed the airline,” Khan said, adding the airline employees would stage protests in Karachi and Islamabad to stop the privatization of the airline.

Ali Khizar, an Islamabad-based financial and development consultant, said the privatization of the PIA was not the “primary concern” of the IMF. 

“IMF has advocated for the privatization, including that of PIA, for quite some time, but its primary concerns are increasing taxation and reducing duplicated expenditures,” Khizar told Arab News.

“While privatization won’t greatly affect talks with the IMF, I believe PIA should indeed be privatized.”

Last week, Pakistan pushed back the deadline for companies to express interest in buying PIA to May 18, a day before the expressions had originally been due. The privatization commission says 10 companies have already expressed an interest.

Pakistan’s government has previously said it was putting on the block a stake of between 51 percent and 100 percent in the loss-making airline.

The disposal of the flag carrier is a step that past elected governments have steered away from as it is likely to be highly unpopular, but progress on privatization is key to helping cash-strapped Pakistan pursue further funding talks with the IMF.


US envoy meets parliamentary leader of Pakistan’s opposition, a key Imran Khan aide 

Updated 06 May 2024
Follow

US envoy meets parliamentary leader of Pakistan’s opposition, a key Imran Khan aide 

  • Khan, who leads the PTI party, has accused Washington of siding with generals and political rivals to orchestrate his 2022 ouster 
  • PTI has since sought Washington’s support in investigating alleged crackdown on its supporters, ‘rigging’ of Feb. 8 general elections 

ISLAMABAD: United States (US) Ambassador to Pakistan Donald Blome on Monday held his first meeting with Omar Ayub Khan, the parliamentary leader of the opposition in the National Assembly and a key aide to former prime minister Imran Khan, the US embassy said.

Khan is the founder of Pakistan’s main opposition party, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), which has accused Washington of siding with the powerful military and Khan’s political rivals to orchestrate his ouster from the PM’s office in April 2022. All three have denied the accusation.

The PTI has since sought support from US lawmakers in investigating alleged rights abuses and crackdown on its supporters in the wake of Khan’s unprecedented campaign of defiance against the country’s powerful military.

“US Ambassador Donald Blome met today with Leader of the Opposition in the National Assembly Omar Ayub Khan and other senior members of the opposition to discuss a broad range of issues important to the bilateral relationship, including US support for continued economic reforms, human rights, and regional security,” the US embassy said in a statement.

A spokesperson for Khan’s PTI told reporters Blome’s meeting with Omar Ayub had been requested by the US embassy through the Pakistani foreign ministry.

“Ambassador Blome underscored the United States’ support for Pakistan to engage constructively with the IMF on its reform program,” the US embassy said, adding that the envoy highlighted the importance of long-term reforms for sustainable economic growth of Pakistan.

Pakistan last month completed a short-term $3 billion program, which helped stave off a sovereign default, but the government of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has stressed the need for a fresh, longer-term program.

The PTI, in a letter written to the IMF earlier this year, had asked the global lender to factor in the country’s political stability in any further bailout talks with Pakistan, according to party members familiar with the matter.

Khan’s opponents previously accused him of scuttling an IMF deal under a $6 billion Extended Fund Facility days before leaving his office, a charge he denies.

Pakistan narrowly averted default last summer, and its $350 billion economy has stabilized after the completion of the last IMF program, with inflation coming down to around 17 percent in April from a record high 38 percent last May.

It is still dealing with a high fiscal shortfall and while it has controlled its external account deficit through import control mechanisms, it has come at the expense of stagnating growth, which is expected to be around 2 percent this year compared to negative growth last year.

Pakistan and the IMF are expected to begin formal talks for a fresh program after the arrival of an IMF team in Islamabad in the mid of May. Islamabad has said it expects a staff-level agreement by July.


Babar hoping paceman Rauf will regain full fitness and make an impact for Pakistan at T20 World Cup

Updated 06 May 2024
Follow

Babar hoping paceman Rauf will regain full fitness and make an impact for Pakistan at T20 World Cup

  • Fast bowler Rauf has been included in an 18-man squad for the upcoming tours of Ireland and England
  • Pakistan has done well in last two T20 World Cups, reaching semifinals in 2021, final at 2022 tournament 

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan captain Babar Azam is hoping Haris Rauf will regain full fitness after a shoulder injury and make an impact at next month’s T20 World Cup.

Fast bowler Rauf has been included in an 18-man squad for the upcoming tours of Ireland and England, with Pakistan delaying its 15-strong party for the World Cup in the United States and West Indies until May 22.

The fitness of Rauf, Mohammad Rizwan, Irfan Khan and Azam Khan will be assessed during the seven T20s against Ireland and England.

“I wasn’t expecting that he (Rauf) would recover so early and start bowling again,” Babar told reporters in Lahore on Monday as the team prepared to fly out to Ireland, where the first T20 will be played in Dublin on Friday.

“There’s pressure on him to make a comeback. There’s lot of talk going around on his injury and how he will respond to it. But I think he will make a good response because when you give yourself proper rest mentally and physically, you can make a different impact.”

Rauf has been out since dislocating his shoulder in late February during the Pakistan Super League. Since then he has gone through rehabilitation at the National Cricket Academy in Lahore.

The seven-member selection committee, which also includes Babar, have named fast bowler Hasan Ali, who last played a T20 international in 2022, as backup for Rauf.

Babar backed the inclusion of Hasan after pace bowlers Zaman Khan, Mohammad Wasim and the PSL’s top wicket-taker Mohammad Ali were omitted.

“There’s no injustice with anyone. We debated a lot on the World Cup combination and Hasan is there as backup for Rauf because of his experience,” Babar said. “Zaman and Ali are new-ball bowlers but we already have enough new-ball bowling options.”

Fast bowler Mohammad Amir, who played in two T20s against New Zealand after ending his retirement, Shaheen Shah Afridi, Naseem Shah and Abbas Afridi are Pakistan’s pace options.

Under Babar, Pakistan has done well in the last two T20 World Cups, reaching the semifinals in 2021 at the United Arab Emirates and losing to England in the final at the 2022 tournament in Australia.

The chairman of the Pakistan Cricket Board, Mohsin Naqvi, has promised a cash award of $100,000 to every player if the team wins the tournament.

“What happened in the past is in the past, unfortunately we couldn’t finish the way we wanted,” Babar said. “We’re doubly confident and believe we can bring the trophy home.”

Pakistan starts its campaign against host United States in Dallas on June 6 before taking on arch-rival India in New York three days later.

White-ball head coach Gary Kirsten will likely join the team in England after completing his Indian Premier League assignment with Gujarat Titans.


Pakistan stocks continue to rally on Saudi investment optimism, decline in inflation

Updated 06 May 2024
Follow

Pakistan stocks continue to rally on Saudi investment optimism, decline in inflation

  • A 50-member delegation led by Saudi Arabia’s Assistant Minister of Investment Ibrahim Al-Mubarak arrived in Pakistan on Sunday
  • Pakistan and Saudi Arabia have seen a flurry of bilateral visits in recent weeks that have fueled hopes of investment in South Asian country

KARACHI: Pakistan’s benchmark share index closed at another all-time high by registering a 1.2 percent gain as bulls celebrated the arrival of a high-level investment delegation from Saudi Arabia, analysts said on Monday.

The KSE-100 index witnessed a bullish trend, gaining an intraday high of 1,158.65 points that marked a 1.61 percent increase. It closed at 72,764.24 points, up by 1.20 percent.

Stock analysts said the major contributing factor behind the bullish close was the arrival of a 50-member Saudi business delegation in Pakistan for potential investments and a drop in inflation.

“Today’s all the bullish activity was because of the Saudi delegation visiting Pakistan to explore investment opportunities,” Sheheryar Butt, portfolio manager at Darson Securities, told Arab News. 

The delegation, led by Saudi Arabia’s Assistant Minister of Investment Ibrahim Al-Mubarak, arrived in Pakistan on Sunday. It comprises representatives of some 30 Saudi companies from the fields of IT, telecom, energy, aviation, construction, mining exploration, agriculture and human resource development.

Butt said the encouraging remarks by the visiting Saudi investment minister on Monday also played a key role in keeping the market in the green zone.

Addressing an investment summit in Islamabad, the Saudi minister said Pakistan was a “high priority” economic opportunity and the Kingdom believed in the potential of Pakistan’s economy, demographics and talent as well as location and natural resources.

Speaking at the summit, Pakistan Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb said foreign investment was vital to macroeconomic stability in Pakistan and the visit of Saudi investors was a link in this chain.

Auzrangzeb said Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif’s successful visit to Saudi Arabia opened the way for economic cooperation between the two countries.

“The visit of a delegation of Saudi investors to Pakistan is also a part of paving the way for this economic cooperation,” the minister said. “The government is now moving toward privatization and PIA [Pakistan International Airlines] will also be privatized.”

He said export-led growth, foreign direct investment (FDI) and excess to capital were top priorities of the government, and it was working on short, medium and long-term strategies as well as structural economic reforms.

Ali Nawaz, CEO of Chase Securities, attributed the bullish trend at the stock market to the arrival of the Saudi investment delegation.

“This news likely injected optimism into the market as it suggests potential for increased foreign investment, bolstering investor confidence,” Nawaz said.

Other factors, he said, included a decline in inflation that fueled a positive sentiment.

“Lower inflation rates typically indicate a healthier economic environment, fostering expectations of potential interest rate cuts in the future,” he added.
 


Pakistan’s deaf-staffed beauty salon provides economic opportunity, empowers hearing impaired

Updated 06 May 2024
Follow

Pakistan’s deaf-staffed beauty salon provides economic opportunity, empowers hearing impaired

  • There are seven deaf beauticians out of a total of 12 employed at Options Salon in Abbottabad 
  • According to the World Health Organization, deaf population in Pakistan is around 10 million people

ABBOTTABAD: Eight years ago, while offering a training class at her Options beauty salon in the northwestern Pakistani city of Abbottabad, Nighat Aftab received an unlikely application: that from a deaf girl who wanted to attend the training and join her salon. 

“I didn’t have much experience working with such women and at first, I hesitated a little that how could I hire such a person whose language I don’t understand?” Aftab told Arab News in an interview earlier this month. “But then I said, ‘Come, join me’.”

Today, there are seven deaf beauticians out of a total of 12 employed at Options, which has since become a sanctuary for women with hearing and speech impairments, providing them economic opportunity, a chance to be financially independent and earn for their families, and a place where they can be part of a supportive, inclusive community.

According to the World Health Organization, the deaf population in Pakistan is around 10 million people. Pakistan has one of the lowest percentages of female labor force participation in South Asia and women with disabilities face even more impediments to employment.

“Previously, I used to work at a parlor in Islamabad where my salary wasn’t great, and I used to miss home a lot,” beautician Saima Mir told Arab News in sign language as Aftab translated for her. 

“Now I am very happy. I like working here. There are many here who cannot hear and speak, it makes me happy.”

Others also said they felt a “sense of belonging” at the Options Salon.

“I have my mother and father. They are old. I feel frustrated at home as there is nobody with whom I can talk and share,” Isma Mushtaq told Arab News. “I come here and I spend time here happily.”

While many of the salon’s loyal customers are now used to communicating with the deaf staff members, that was not always the case, Aftab recalled, saying she faced criticism in the beginning by clients struggling to communicate with her workers. To bridge the gap, deaf workers were teamed up with those from the hearing community.

“The difficulties we faced [with communication] in the beginning got resolved over time,” said Sobia Khan, a beautician from the hearing community. 

And the troubles had been worth it, Aftab said.

“I might have closed down the salon by now because my daughters are now married and I want to enjoy my own life but I am committed because of these young women [deaf workers] and I am unable to quit because their employment is attached to me,” she said. 

“And because of them, Allah has blessed me with health. I am able to come to work daily, even though I am not that healthy, but I am happy here.”