Pharma giant Sanofi charged with manslaughter in birth defects case

French laboratory Sanofi is indicted for “involuntary homicides” over the devastating effects of the anti-epileptic drug valproate (Depakine). (FIle/AFP)
Short Url
Updated 03 August 2020
Follow

Pharma giant Sanofi charged with manslaughter in birth defects case

  • Studies say a Sanofi drug has caused disabilities in about 15,000-30,000 children whose mothers took the medicine while pregnant
  • On the market since 1967, the drug is used to treat epilepsy, migraines and bipolar disorder

PARIS: French prosecutors have indicted pharma giant Sanofi for manslaughter over birth defects linked to an epilepsy drug, the company said Monday, in a long-running case that has also seen it charged with fraud.
The charges relate to the drug valproate, marketed as Depakine among other trade names, which studies say has caused disabilities in about 15,000-30,000 children whose mothers took the medicine while pregnant.
On the market since 1967, the drug is used to treat epilepsy, migraines and bipolar disorder.
But research found that when pregnant women took the drug, their children had an elevated risk — between 10 to 40 percent — of congenital malformations, autism and learning difficulties.
Sanofi is facing separate charges of aggravated fraud and unintentionally causing injury in 42 cases filed by families, but insists it had warned health authorities of the drug’s risks already in the 1980s.
On Monday, the company confirmed a report in Le Monde newspaper that prosecutors have now also charged it with manslaughter.
But in a statement sent to AFP it insisted it had “fulfilled its obligation” of providing information on the drug and its side-effects, and said it “contests the validity of these proceedings.”
Sanofi said it has filed a legal challenge to the indictment.
Under the French legal system, charges do not automatically result in a trial as prosecutors can decide not to proceed based on a lack of evidence.
Last month, a French court ordered the state to pay thousands of euros in damages over the scandal, saying officials should have ensured the drug was not taken by pregnant women.
The court found that health officials knew about the risk of birth defects from Depakine already in 1983, and of learning disabilities and autism from 2004.
Another 500 complaints have been lodged with France’s national compensation agency for medical accidents, which has already proposed a 6.5-million-euro ($7.6-million) package for Depakine victims.
Sanofi, a France-based multinational, is working on a candidate vaccine against the novel coronavirus with Britain’s GSK, for which it will receive up to $2.1 billion from the US government.


Immigration raids in Minnesota fuel grassroots Somali activism

Updated 5 sec ago
Follow

Immigration raids in Minnesota fuel grassroots Somali activism

  • “You would never fathom that people would just pluck you off the streets ... and say, ‘Prove to me that you’re a citizen,’” Mohamed said
  • Trump, who ‌has described Somalis as “garbage” who should be thrown out of the country, has said the operations are necessary to combat crime

MINNEAPOLIS: When immigration agents began aggressive operations in Minneapolis last month, Kowsar Mohamed started knocking on doors, fielding late-night calls and mobilizing other Somali Americans into an ad-hoc response team.
Many feared they were being singled out, a worry that revived memories of the state surveillance and arbitrary authority they thought they had left behind when they resettled in the United States.
More than 100 volunteers now patrol south Minneapolis, distribute “Know Your Rights” guides and escort frightened elders — part of a sweeping grassroots effort to counter what many describe as constitutionally suspect raids that are destabilizing Minnesota’s roughly 80,000-strong Somali community, one of the country’s largest refugee populations.
“You would never fathom that people would just pluck you off the streets ... and say, ‘Prove to me that you’re a citizen,’” Mohamed said, referring to reports of aggressive tactics by the agents. “It’s not that we never thought it was impossible. We just believed the Constitution was going to protect us from this level of interrogation.”

TRUMP’S 3,000-AGENT PUSH SPARKS VOTER-INTIMIDATION FEARS
The deployment of 3,000 federal agents — ordered by Republican President Donald Trump — has intensified accusations from Democrats and local leaders that he is targeting ‌a politically influential community ‌ahead of the 2026 midterm elections, deepening fears that the operations amount to intimidation aimed at suppressing ‌Somali ⁠voter turnout.
Trump, who ‌has described Somalis as “garbage” who should be thrown out of the country, has said the operations are necessary to combat crime, though many of those arrested have no criminal charges or convictions. He has also cited a fraud scandal around the theft of federal funds for social-welfare programs in Minnesota to justify sending agents into the state, many of them from US Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
Democrats and community leaders accuse the agents of harassing peaceful protesters, racial profiling and searching houses without warrants. Minneapolis has been on edge since the fatal shooting of 37-year-old Renee Good by an immigration agent on January 7.
“A lot of community members escaped war and this administration is triggering another war zone,” said Abdulahi Farah, co-chair of the Somali American Leadership Table, an advocacy group formed in response ⁠to hate crimes and political attacks on Somalis. He said Trump’s history of racist rhetoric against Black and other immigrants of color has emboldened far-right activists and had a destabilizing effect on ‌small businesses and citizens’ general sense of safety.
Department of Homeland Security spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said in ‍a statement to Reuters that immigrants who are served administrative warrants or ‍I-205 removal orders “have had full due process and a final order of removal from an immigration judge.”

PUSHING BACK AGAINST IMMIGRATION RAIDS
In Cedar-Riverside, a ‍normally bustling Somali neighborhood lined with restaurants, boutique shops and convenience stores, business owners say activity is noticeably quieter since immigration agents arrived there last month.
“It’s been really slow,” said Rashid Jama, a grocery store manager in the neighborhood, also known as the West Bank. “A lot of our suppliers are Latino and they’re scared to come to work.”
The efforts of Mohamed, a third-year doctoral student at the University of Minnesota, are part of a broader wave of grassroots initiatives to push back by filming arrests, planning peaceful protests and accelerating voter outreach.
Some Somali Americans fear the raids are a bid to suppress voter turnout before midterm elections in November, according to over a dozen grassroots organizers, local officials and residents interviewed by ⁠Reuters.
“It’s signaling that if we get rid of them, if we scare them, they’re not going to come out to vote in the 2026 midterm election. We know that’s the target,” said Farah, whose group is partnering with other grassroots organizations to train people on priorities like opposing ICE raids as well as broader issues like affordability.
Mosques and neighboring community centers are now turning into political education hubs in Minnesota, local leaders said.
Civil rights advocates and scholars say the Minneapolis immigration operations echo past crackdowns in Black and Latino neighborhoods, fueling fears of political scapegoating, said political science professor Christina Greer at Fordham University.
Somali American voters have largely supported Democrats since refugees began resettling in the US in the 1990s, before becoming more politically active in the 2000s. US Representative Ilhan Omar is the community’s most high-profile member and a frequent target of racist attacks from Trump.
Asked about that and tactics of agents decried by residents, White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson said in a statement to Reuters that immigrants “who fail to contribute to our economy, rip off Americans and refuse to assimilate into our society should not be here.”
Minnesota Republican Party Chairman Alex Plechash denied the raids were politically driven, calling the charge “categorically false” but said complaints about aggressive tactics ‌warrant review.
Some Somali community leaders say mobilizing voters will be a priority in the months ahead.
“The power we have is to vote,” said Abdullahi Kahiye, 37, who said he became a naturalized US citizen in 2024. “ICE and whoever is trying to terrorize the Somali community will not succeed.”