Pakistan mulls tit-for-tat action after two officials expelled over ‘espionage’

A vehicle carrying an Indian diplomat leaves the foreign ministry following a meeting with Kulbhushan Jadhav, an imprisoned Indian convicted of spying, in Islamabad, Pakistan, Monday, Sept. 2, 2019. (AP Photo)
Short Url
Updated 02 June 2020
Follow

Pakistan mulls tit-for-tat action after two officials expelled over ‘espionage’

  • New Delhi’s act of detaining and torturing personnel unacceptable, High Commission official says 
  • Pakistan and India downgraded their diplomatic relations in August last year

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan said on Monday it is working on reciprocatory measures a day after India expelled two diplomats on “espionage” charges, with the two on their way to Islamabad from New Delhi this morning, senior officials told Arab News.

“Both our officials are on the way to Pakistan, as they are coming by road from New Delhi, so they will reach Wagah border by evening. Reciprocity in such acts is a normal procedure, and it is in the process,” Khawaja Maaz, spokesperson of Pakistan’s High Commission to India, told Arab News on the phone from New Delhi.

It follows a statement by India’s Foreign Ministry on Sunday which said that the officials had been apprehended and asked to leave the country within 24 hours for “indulging in activities incompatible with their status as members of a diplomatic mission.”

Pakistan slammed New Delhi’s statement and said that the charges were “false and unsubstantiated.”

“Pakistan has always followed the diplomatic norms and conventions that govern diplomatic relations between any two countries. We are a law-abiding country. We will take whatever step required to reciprocate and ensure the safety of our officers and diplomates in India,” Aisha Farooqui, Pakistan’s Foreign Office spokeswoman, told Arab News.

She added that the atmosphere of bilateral relations with India was already taut and that “this step of expelling Pakistani diplomats on false allegations will add to it.”

“There are a series of actions India has taken unilaterally like sending spy drones, maligning Pakistan on fake accusations and harassing high commission officials,” she said, adding that the latest move was “unacceptable.”

“Now they (India) went to a new low by detaining officials of our high commission, torturing them and pressurizing them to own up to false allegations. It is completely unacceptable,” Farooqui said.

Detailing the procedural steps that would follow, she said that India’s action was in clear violation of the Vienna Convention on diplomatic relations and norms.

“In this regard, the Indian Charge d’Affaires was summoned to the Foreign Office last night for a strong demarche, conveying Pakistan’s condemnation of the Indian decision to declare two officials of the High Commission for Pakistan in New Delhi persona non grata and rejection of all baseless Indian allegations against the High Commission officials,” Farooqui said.

Pakistan and India downgraded their diplomatic relations in August last year when New Delhi revoked the special legal status of Indian-administered Kashmir. 

The countries have fought two wars over the region and their forces regularly trade fire across the de facto border between the two countries, which is the 740-km long Line of Control.


Evictees of slum near Islamabad’s diplomatic quarter claim abandonment as city cites security, illegal settlement

Updated 4 sec ago
Follow

Evictees of slum near Islamabad’s diplomatic quarter claim abandonment as city cites security, illegal settlement

  • Authorities say evictees were compensated in the early 2000s, settlement built later illegally
  • Evictees, for whom historical and emotional costs outweigh legal arguments, say they feel abandoned

ISLAMABAD: Muzaffar Hussain Shah bends down, picks up a brick from the rubble and cleans it with a hammer. Until a few weeks ago, the brick had been part of a home where Shah had lived for nearly five decades, since his birth.

The house in an informal settlement in Islamabad, which came to be known as Muslim Colony, was demolished in an anti-encroachment drive. Shah said he has spent past three weeks sleeping under the open sky and has been collecting the last remaining bricks to get by for a few more days.

Shah, 48, is one of nearly 15,000 people evicted by the Capital Development Authority (CDA) from the settlement, which was established in the 1960s to house laborers who built Pakistan’s capital of Islamabad, during a drive that began in November.

The decades-old settlement, located near the prime minister’s official residence and the Diplomatic Enclave, a specially designated area within the city that houses foreign embassies, high commissions and international missions, has now been reduced to a 712-kanal (89-acre) stretch of dust and debris.

“It feels as if there is neither a sky over our heads nor anyone behind our backs,” Shah told Arab News on Tuesday, surrounded by the rubble of his demolished home. “Nor is there anything ahead of us. We cannot see anything at all.”

Man collecting rubble from a demolished colony in Islamabad, Pakistan, on December 30, 2025. (AN photo)

While evacuated residents recount a tale of what they described as broken political promises and affiliation with the place, authorities say there were “obviously security concerns”, and that claims to the land were settled two decades ago. 

During an interview with Arab News, Dr. Anam Fatima, director of municipal administration at the Islamabad Metropolitan Corporation, showed satellite images of the “informal settlement” from 2002.

The images showed significant population growth over the years, which she said indicated that most current residents arrived after 2002, when the government negotiated the resettlement of original residents in return for compensation.

“In 2002, it was decided that these people will be compensated, and they were accordingly compensated,” Fatima said.

“Seven hundred and fifty [residents] were found eligible. They were given plots in Farash Town,” she said about a neighborhood on Islamabad’s outskirts. “Some of them moved, some of them did not, but the original settlement was not removed, unfortunately.”

Man cutting tree trunk in Islamabad, Pakistan, on December 30, 2025. (AN photo)

The official attributed the survival of the settlement and its subsequent growth to “enforcement failure” and “changing policies” over the years, insisting that all legal formalities were met before the latest operation.

“Notices were given first to vacate and then after the evacuations had been done... people had completely moved their belongings, only then bulldozers were sent into the area,” Fatima said.

For the evacuated residents, the historical and emotional costs outweigh the legal arguments, they say. Many claim their families moved there more than six decades ago and were promised permanent housing in exchange for their labor.

Muhammad Hafeez, whose father arrived in 1972, lamented that the ones who had helped built Islamabad were being rewarded in the form of eviction from the same city.

“Allah will definitely question you about this,” he said.

Man collecting rubble from a demolished colony in Islamabad, Pakistan, on December 30, 2025. (AN photo)

Muhammad Khalil, 62, another evictee, blamed CDA officials for allowing the settlement not just to exist but also to grow over the years.

“We did not bring these houses down from space and place them here. CDA officials were present here, they were aware of the developments taking place every single minute, every moment,” he said.

“Their vehicles would come daily. We built these houses right in front of them.”

As bulldozers cleared the land this month, many residents of Muslim Colony said they felt abandoned by the city they once helped build.

“All of this Islamabad that has been built was built by our elders,” Shah said. “Laborers used to live here. And today, after having built Islamabad, today, we have become illegal.”

Authorities, however, say the evictees had been residing illegally and had been compensated, maintaining that they had to be relocated.

“It was entirely illegal because whatever right that they had, it was already compensated in 2003 by the authority,” Dr. Fatima said.