‘Don’t let Pari Island sink’: Indonesian fishers seek climate reparations from Swiss cement giant

Indonesians from Pari island, Edi Mulyono and Asmania, hold placards as they stand by Holcim’s Eclepens plant in Switzerland on June 11, 2023. (HEKS)
Short Url
Updated 06 February 2026
Follow

‘Don’t let Pari Island sink’: Indonesian fishers seek climate reparations from Swiss cement giant

  • Holcim emitted more than 7bn tonnes of carbon dioxide between 1950 and 2021, research shows
  • With about 11 percent of Pari submerged, most of the island might be underwater by 2050

JAKARTA: When Asmania began aquafarming on Indonesia’s Pari Island more than 20 years ago, harvest time brought her abundant seaweed and grouper fish to sustain livelihood, at times yielding more than enough good quality produce to supply export markets.

But as oceans grew warmer and extreme weather became more common as a result of climate change, seaweed and fish farming on the island are increasingly unsustainable, forcing her and other women on the island to look elsewhere to make a living.

“The seaweed we plant is not as good as it used to be. I also used to harvest grouper every nine months, but in the face of the climate crisis, the fish die way earlier,” the 42-year-old mother of three told Arab News.

The low-lying island of Pari, part of the famed Thousand Islands that lie off Java’s northwestern coast just under two hours from the Indonesian capital of Jakarta, is on the forefront of the climate crisis.

With rising global temperatures driving up sea levels, the island of about 1,000 people has suffered more frequent coastal erosion and tidal flooding that is driving away tourists — a traditionally steady source of income — while chaotic weather devastated fishing hauls.

The direct impacts of climate change pushed Asmania and three other Pari islanders to sue Swiss-based Holcim, the world’s largest cement maker, joining a growing number of lawsuits aimed at holding corporations responsible for their contributions to climate change.

“We feel the shift caused by climate change and suffer from the subsequent environmental damage. This is why we were encouraged to file a lawsuit,” Asmania said.

“Large corporations responsible for emissions, like Holcim, must be held accountable. It’s not fair that people who live on the coast must bear all the burden, it’s not fair that small fishermen like us must live awaiting the risks of climate change.”

Research by the US-based Climate Accountability Institute shows that Holcim emitted more than 7 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide between 1950 and 2021, while the Global Cement and Concrete Association said cement production accounts for about 7 percent of global carbon dioxide emissions.

With support from the Indonesian Forum for the Environment, or Walhi, the Swiss Church Aid group HEKS and the European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights, the four Indonesians from Pari filed a complaint against Holcim in Zug, Switzerland — where Holcim has its headquarters — in 2023.

In December, the Swiss court agreed to hear the complaint, which accuses Holcim of failing to do enough to cut carbon emissions and demands the global manufacturer to reduce its carbon dioxide emissions by 43 percent by 2030, co-finance adaptation measures on Pari and pay “loss and damage” compensation.

It was the first time a Swiss court has admitted climate litigation brought against a big corporation, according to HEKS.

“I was so happy when I heard the news, after what has been a very long process,” Asmania said.

“Why am I fighting for this? Because it’s not just for me, it’s also for my kids and future grandkids, they deserve and need a good environment.”

Holcim did not immediately respond to Arab News’s request for comment but has reportedly appealed the Swiss court decision.

Eleven percent of Pari Island has been submerged over the past decade due to rising sea levels, and most of it will probably be underwater by 2050, according to Walhi.

“Pari Island was around 40 to 43 hectares, but this is no longer the case. There’s been so much more coastal abrasion so we’re losing more of our land,” Mustaghfirin, a Pari fisherman and one of the plaintiffs in the case, told Arab News.

The 54-year-old father of three has been fishing for three decades. While his catch could reach more than 100kg in the past, nowadays he considers himself lucky to return home with 30kg. Some species, such as tuna and lobster, are increasingly difficult to find.

“There have been about seven generations who lived on this island, and these days we are truly feeling the impacts of climate change, which is threatening our home, our livelihoods,” he said.

“Don’t wait until we sink to save us. Don’t let Pari Island sink.”


Myanmar expels East Timor envoy after rights group complaint against junta

Updated 2 sec ago
Follow

Myanmar expels East Timor envoy after rights group complaint against junta

  • Myanmar has been in turmoil since 2021, when the military ousted the elected government led by Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi
Myanmar has ordered the head ‌of East Timor’s diplomatic mission to leave the country within seven days, state media quoted the foreign ministry as saying on Monday, in an escalating row ​over a criminal complaint filed by a rights group against Myanmar’s armed forces.
Myanmar has been in turmoil since 2021, when the military ousted the elected government led by Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi, sparking a wave of anti-junta protests that have morphed into a nationwide civil war.
Myanmar’s Chin state Human Rights Organization (CHRO) last month filed a complaint with the justice ‌department of East Timor, ‌also known as Timor-Leste, alleging that ​the ‌Myanmar junta ⁠had ​carried out ⁠war crimes and crimes against humanity since the 2021 coup.
In January, CHRO officials also met East Timor President Jose Ramos-Horta, who last year led the tiny Catholic nation’s accession into the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), of which Myanmar is also a member.
CHRO filed the complaint in East Timor because it was seeking ⁠an ASEAN member with an independent judiciary ‌as well as a country that would ‌be sympathetic to the suffering of ​Chin State’s majority Christian population, ‌the group’s Executive Director Salai Za Uk said.
“Such unconstructive engagement by ‌a Head of State of one ASEAN Member State with an unlawful organization opposing another ASEAN Member State is totally unacceptable,” the state-run Global New Light of Myanmar quoted the foreign ministry as saying.
A spokesman for ‌the Myanmar junta did not respond to calls seeking comment.
In early February, CHRO said East Timor’s ⁠judicial authorities had ⁠opened legal proceedings against the Myanmar junta, including its chief Min Aung Hlaing, following the complaint filed by the rights group.
Myanmar’s foreign ministry said East Timor’s acceptance of the case and the country’s appointment of a prosecutor to look into it resulted in “setting an unprecedented practice, negative interpretation and escalation of (public) resentments.”
East Timor’s embassy in Myanmar did not immediately respond to a request for comment sent via email.
The diplomatic spat comes as the Myanmar military faces international scrutiny for its role in an ​alleged genocide against the minority ​Muslim Rohingya in a case being heard at the International Court of Justice.
Myanmar has denied the charge.