Individuals could be ‘wrongly’ criminalized after Palestine Action ban, UK Home Office official warns

Supporters of alleged Palestine Action activists accused of breaking into Israeli-based defence firm Elbit Systems’ site in Bristol in August 2024, hold placards and wave Palestinian flags outside Woolwich Crown Court in south east London, where the activists are due to stand trial, Nov. 17, 2025. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 23 November 2025
Follow

Individuals could be ‘wrongly’ criminalized after Palestine Action ban, UK Home Office official warns

  • Co-founder of Palestine Action Huda Ammori is suing former Home Secretary Yvette Cooper this week for her decision to designate the group under anti-terror laws in July
  • Individuals supporting Palestine advocacy, but not Palestine Action, are wrongly labeled as extremists, and supporters of Palestine Action are referred to Prevent despite posing no threat, an official says

LONDON: The ban on Palestine Action has led to people in the UK being wrongly labeled as extremists, and the anti-terrorism Prevent program risks being overwhelmed, a member of the Home Office’s homeland security group has warned.

Prevent duty, established in 2015, mandates certain British authorities, such as education and health, to report concerns about individuals who are vulnerable to radicalization.

The official, who works closely with Prevent, told The Guardian that the proscription of Palestine Action has confused counterterrorism police, officials, schools, and hospitals. They expressed concern that individuals supporting Palestine advocacy, but not Palestine Action, are wrongly labeled as extremists, and that supporters of Palestine Action are referred to Prevent despite posing no threat.

Co-founder of Palestine Action Huda Ammori is suing former Home Secretary Yvette Cooper this week for her decision to designate the group under anti-terror laws in July.

“I’m concerned about a surge in referrals to the Prevent system that might have a link to Palestine advocacy in light of the fact that this very high-profile group is now proscribed, and the confusion there might be on the frontline in schools and healthcare settings and all the other places that are expected to make Prevent referrals.

“I’ve heard senior counterterrorism police people say that they are already seeing on the frontline concerns about this come up and I’m aware of testimonies from Prevent leads at local authorities where they are also concerned about the impact of this on their area and confusion about whether certain cases should be referred to Prevent or not.”

Referrals to the anti-terrorism program rose by 27 percent in the year to March 2025, marking the highest number since records began. The official also expressed concerns that Prevent could be “overwhelmed” by referrals related to Palestine Action.

“We have already seen police officers, let alone frontline Prevent practitioners, mistakenly arrest or interfere with people for supporting Palestine, not supporting Palestine Action.

“There is a risk that what’s now the crime of support for Palestine Action might lead to the Prevent system becoming an unwitting sort of gateway for people to mistakenly be criminalized, especially young people who don’t know the law and they don’t know the consequences of expressing what might sound like — or may actually be — support for a group that, overnight, has become proscribed.”

The official who spoke to The Guardian expressed concern that the ban had undermined the credibility of essential counterterrorism efforts.

“The proscription has damaged trust in the government more widely and Prevent specifically — so potentially eroding Prevent’s effectiveness to tackle the real issues even further,” they said.

A spokesperson for the Home Office said: “We do not comment on anonymous briefings.

“Supporting Palestine is not the same as supporting a proscribed terrorist organization. There are many lawful ways to express support for Palestinian rights and sovereignty without being a member of, or associated with, this harmful group.”

Palestine Action was banned after an alleged attack on two planes at RAF Brize Norton in June, causing £7 million ($9.3 million) in damage, for which five members face vandalism charges. Moreover, 24 individuals face charges over a break-in at the UK site of the Israel-based defense firm Elbit Systems in Bristol that occurred in August.

Supporting Palestine Action is now a criminal offense in the UK, punishable by up to 14 years in prison.


New deadly clashes break out on Afghanistan-Pakistan border despite truce

Updated 7 sec ago
Follow

New deadly clashes break out on Afghanistan-Pakistan border despite truce

  • At least 5 people were killed, 5 injured on the Afghan side, Taliban authorities say
  • Latest clash comes amid reports of back-channel negotiations between the two countries

KABUL: Overnight border clashes have broken out between Afghan and Pakistani forces, authorities in Afghanistan said on Saturday, as tensions between the neighbors escalated following a fragile ceasefire. 

The latest exchange of fire that spanned Spin Boldak and Chaman, a key crossing between southeastern Afghanistan’s Kandahar province and Pakistan’s Balochistan, marked violations of a ceasefire that has been in place since October. 

The truce brokered by Qatar and Turkey has mostly held for the past two months, after dozens were killed on both sides in what was the deadliest confrontation in years between Afghanistan and Pakistan. 

But heavy gunfire and shelling erupted again late on Friday, with each side blaming the other for sparking the deadly violence. 

“Unfortunately, last night the Pakistani side once again attacked Spin Boldak in Kandahar. The forces of the Islamic Emirate had to respond,” Hamdullah Fitrat, deputy spokesperson of Afghanistan’s Taliban government, told Arab News on Saturday. 

He said five people on the Afghan side — including four civilians — were killed in the violence, while five others were injured. 

Mosharraf Zaidi, spokesman for Pakistan’s prime minister, said that the Taliban “resorted to unprovoked firing” along their shared border. 

“An immediate, befitting & intense response has been given by our armed forces. Pakistan remains fully alert & committed to ensuring its territorial integrity & the safety of our citizens,” he wrote on X. 

Local residents in Spin Boldak told Arab News that Friday’s clashes forced families to flee their homes. 

“Mortars and bullets smashed into houses and public places,” Samiullah Malang said. “It was difficult … (to) watch women and children flee on motorbikes, tractors and on foot in the cold night.” 

Although the fighting largely subsided around midnight, sporadic gunfire continued into the morning, he added. 

The overnight violence also reached the Friendship Gate, an official crossing point between Spin Boldak and Chaman, which was closed by Pakistan authorities after the fighting. 

Clashes at the border have led to repeated closures of the key border crossing, devastating commerce and disrupting the movement of thousands. 

“Every time Pakistan shuts the gate, our fruits rot inside the trucks,” said Afghan businessman Haji Rahmatullah. “Hotels are filled with patients waiting to cross for treatment.”

After the ceasefire agreement in October, subsequent talks for a long-term truce have so far yielded little progress. The latest deadly exchange of fire comes amid reports of back-channel negotiations between Afghan and Pakistani officials, which neither governments have openly confirmed. 

Both sides remain deeply divided on core security issues and repeated clashes highlight the absence of an effective de-escalation mechanism, according to Asad Waheedi, a political analyst based in Kabul. 

“The talks are not bearing fruit because the demands are unrealistic,” he said. “Pakistan asks the Taliban to guarantee the security of their country. This is impossible. Even when America had all its troops here, it could not guarantee Afghanistan’s security. The Taliban have no presence there (in Pakistan). It is an impractical demand.”

Clashes between Afghan and Pakistani forces along the Durand Line — their 2,640-km border — have occurred for decades but intensified after the Taliban took control of Afghanistan in 2021, following the withdrawal of US-led troops.

Pakistan accuses the Afghan Taliban of sheltering fighters from the banned Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan and allowing them to stage cross-border attacks — a charge Afghanistan denies, saying it does not allow its territory to be used against other countries.

The deadly violence in October was triggered by an unclaimed explosion in Kabul and another in the southeastern province of Paktika, for which the Afghan government blamed the Pakistani military. 

“The facts show that the distance between them is huge,” Waheedi said. “Until the demands become practical, these talks will go nowhere, and the fighting will continue.”