Israeli claims of Gaza safe zones ‘farcical’, UN says they’re ‘places of death’

The United Nations on Friday insisted there was no safe place for Palestinians ordered to leave Gaza City and that Israel-designated zones in the south were “places of death”.(AP)
Short Url
Updated 03 October 2025
Follow

Israeli claims of Gaza safe zones ‘farcical’, UN says they’re ‘places of death’

  • The United Nations on Friday insisted there was no safe place for Palestinians ordered to leave Gaza City and that Israel-designated zones in the south were “places of death“

GENEVA: The United Nations insisted on Friday there was no safe place for Palestinians ordered to leave Gaza City,and that Israeli-designated zones in the southern Gaza Strip were “places of death.”
Since launching its air assault on Gaza City in August ahead of its ground offensive there, the Israeli military has repeatedly told Palestinians to head south.
“The notion of a safe zone in the south is farcical,” James Elder, a spokesman for the UN children’s agency UNICEF, told journalists in Geneva.
Speaking from Deir Al-Balah in central Gaza, Elder pointed to how “bombs are dropped from the sky with chilling predictability; schools, which had been designated as temporary shelters are regularly reduced to rubble, (and) tents... are regularly engulfed in fire from air attacks.”
The Israeli military has urged Palestinians to relocate to a “humanitarian area” in Al-Mawasi on the coast, where it says aid, medical care and humanitarian infrastructure will be provided.
Israel first declared the area a safe zone early in the two-year war but has carried out repeated strikes on it since, saying it is targeting Hamas.

Nutrition, shelter, sanitation

Elder insisted that “the issuance of a general or a blanket evacuation order to civilians does not mean that those who remain behind lose their protection as civilians.”
At the same time, he warned, the “so-called safe zones ... are also places of death.”
Al-Mawasi, he pointed out, “is now one of the most densely populated places on Earth.
“It’s grotesquely overcrowded and has been stripped of the most basic essentials of survival.”
The UN had begun in late 2023 “debunking this concept of a unilaterally-declared safe zone,” Elder said.
“The law is very clear,” he stressed.
“It is the responsibility of the occupying power — Israel — to ensure that a safe zone has all the essentials for survival: that is nutrition, shelter and sanitation.
“None of those are present in a level that is fitting of a population,” Elder said, adding that the UN at the start had “at least assumed that these places would not be bombed.”
But over the past 18 months, the Israeli-designated safe-zones had been hit “dozens of time,” and “people in tents have suffered from airstrikes.”

Makeshift crutches

Humanitarian agencies regularly warn that the amount of urgent supplies being allowed into the Gaza Strip are grossly insufficient to meet the immense needs of the population in the Israeli-besieged Palestinian territory.
“To cope with that situation, our colleagues, particularly in our hospital in Rafah, have decided to build our own materials,” such as “home-made, wooden crutches,” said Christian Cardon, spokesman for the International Committee of the Red Cross.
The ICRC announced on Wednesday that had been “forced” to suspend its activities in Gaza City due to Israel’s intensified military operations.
“There are no longer any international staff in Gaza City. We had between two and five expatriates before,” Cardon told AFP, adding that the ICRC has 350 staff, including 50 international staff, throughout the Gaza Strip.
The World Health Organization is calling for humanitarian corridors to allow access to hospitals, its representative in the Palestinian territories, Rik Peeperkorn, told reporters.


Israel fires mortar into Gaza residential area, wounding at least 10

Updated 56 min 24 sec ago
Follow

Israel fires mortar into Gaza residential area, wounding at least 10

  • The attack is the latest Israeli attack since the Oct. 10 ceasefire took effect
  • Palestinian health officials have reported over 370 deaths from Israeli fire since the truce

JERUSALEM: Israeli troops fired a mortar shell over the ceasefire line into a Palestinian residential area in the Gaza Strip, in the latest incident to rock the tenuous ceasefire with Hamas. Health officials said at least 10 people were wounded, and the army said it was investigating.
The military said the mortar was fired during an operation in the area of the “Yellow Line,” which was drawn in the ceasefire agreement and divides the Israeli-held majority of Gaza from the rest of the territory.
The military did not say what troops were doing or whether they had crossed the line. It said the mortar had veered from its intended target, which it did not specify.
Fadel Naeem, director of Al-Ahli Hospital, said the hospital received 10 people wounded in the strike on central Gaza City, some critically.
It was not the first time since the ceasefire took effect on Oct. 10 that Israeli fire has caused Palestinian casualties outside the Yellow Line. Palestinian health officials have reported over 370 deaths from Israeli fire since the truce.
Israel has said it has opened fire in response to Hamas violations, and says most of those killed have been Hamas militants. But an Israeli military official, speaking on condition of anonymity in line with military protocol, said the army is aware of a number of incidents where civilians were killed, including young children and a family traveling in a van.
Palestinians say civilians have been killed in some cases because the line is poorly marked. Israeli troops have been laying down yellow blocks to delineate it, but in some areas the blocks have not yet been placed.
Ceasefire’s next phase
The Israel-Hamas ceasefire is struggling to reach its next phase, with both sides accusing each other of violations. The first phase involved the exchange of hostages for Palestinian prisoners. The second is supposed to involve the deployment of an international stabilization force, a technocratic governing body for Gaza, the disarmament of Hamas and further Israeli troop withdrawals from the territory.
The remains of one hostage, Ran Gvili, are still in Gaza, and the militants appear to be struggling to find it. Israel is demanding the return of Gvili’s remains before moving to the second phase.
Hamas is calling for more international pressure on Israel to open key border crossings, cease deadly strikes and allow more aid into the strip. Recently released Israeli military figures suggest it hasn’t met the ceasefire stipulation of allowing 600 trucks of aid into Gaza a day, though Israel disputes that finding.
Humanitarian groups say the lack of aid has had harsh effects on most of Gaza’s residents. Food remains scarce as the territory struggles to bounce back from famine, which affected parts of Gaza during the war.
The toll of war
The vast majority of Gaza’s 2 million people have been displaced. Most live in vast tent camps or among the shells of damaged buildings.
The initial Hamas-led Oct. 7, 2023, attack on southern Israel killed around 1,200 people and took 251 hostages. Almost all hostages or their remains have been returned in ceasefires or other deals.
Israel’s two-year campaign in Gaza has killed more than 70,660 Palestinians, roughly half of them women and children, according to the territory’s Health Ministry, which does not distinguish between militants and civilians in its count. The ministry, which operates under the Hamas-run government, is staffed by medical professionals and maintains detailed records viewed as generally reliable by the international community.