‘Education apartheid’: schooling in crisis in Pakistan

This photo taken on November 13, 2024 shows students going back to their home from a community school in Abdullah Goth village on the outskirts of Karachi. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 11 January 2025
Follow

‘Education apartheid’: schooling in crisis in Pakistan

  • Pakistan is facing severe education crisis, with over 26 million children out of school, the majority in rural areas
  • Poverty is the biggest factor keeping children out of classrooms, but the problem is worsened by other factors too

ABDULLAH GOTH: Aneesa Haroon drops off her tattered school bag at her rural home in Pakistan and hurriedly grabs lunch before joining her father in the fields to pick vegetables.
The 11-year-old’s entry into school at the age of seven was a negotiation between teachers and her parents in her farming village on the outskirts of Karachi.
“Initially, many parents were not in favor of educating their children,” headteacher Rukhsar Amna told AFP.
“Some children were working in the fields, and their income was considered more valuable than education.”
Pakistan is facing a severe education crisis, with more than 26 million children out of school, the majority in rural areas, according to official government figures — one of the highest rates in the world.
This weekend, Pakistan will host a two-day international summit to advocate for girls’ education in Muslim countries, attended by Nobel Peace laureate and education activist Malala Yousafzai.
In Pakistan, poverty is the biggest factor keeping children out of classrooms, but the problem is worsened by inadequate infrastructure and underqualified teachers, cultural barriers and the impacts of climate change-fueled extreme weather.
In the village of Abdullah Goth on the outskirts of Karachi, the non-profit Roshan Pakistan Foundation school is the first in decades to cater to the population of over 2,500 people.
“There was no school here for generations. This is the first time parents, the community and children have realized the importance of a school,” said Humaira Bachal, a 36-year-old education advocate from the public and privately funded foundation.




This photo taken on November 13, 2024 shows Rukhsar Amna, a 27-year-old school principal, interacting with children at a community school in Abdullah Goth village on the outskirts of Karachi. (AFP)

Still, the presence of a school was just the first hurdle, she added.
Families only agreed to send their children in exchange for food rations, to compensate for the loss of household income that the children contributed.
In Abdullah Goth, most children attend school in the morning, leaving them free to work in the afternoon.
“Their regular support is essential for us,” said Aneesa’s father, Haroon Baloch, as he watched his daughter and niece pick okra to sell at the market.
“People in our village keep goats, and the children help graze them while we are at work. After finishing grazing, they also assist us with labor tasks.”




This photo taken on November 13, 2024 shows Aneesa Haroon, an 11-year-old schoolgirl, attending a class inside a community school in Abdullah Goth village on the outskirts of Karachi. (AFP)

Education in Pakistan is also increasingly impacted by climate change.
Frequent school closures are announced due to heavy smog, heatwaves and floods, and government schools are rarely equipped with heating or fans.
In the restive provinces of Balochistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, education faces significant setbacks due to ongoing militancy, while classes are routinely disrupted in the capital Islamabad due to political chaos.
Although the percentage of out-of-school children aged between five and 16 dropped from 44 percent in 2016 to 36 percent in 2023, according to census data, the absolute number rises each year as the population grows.
Girls all across the country are less likely to go to school, but in the poorest province of Balochistan, half of girls are out of school, according to the Pak Alliance for Maths and Science, which analyzed government data.
Cash-strapped Pakistan’s Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif declared an “education emergency” last year, and said he would increase the education budget from 1.7 percent of GDP to 4 percent over the next five years.
Public schools funded by the government offer free education but struggle with limited resources and overcrowding, creating a huge market for private schools whose costs can start from a few dollars a month.
In a parallel system, thousands of madrassas provide Islamic education to children from the poorest families, as well as free meals and housing, but often fail to prepare students for the modern world.




This photo taken on November 13, 2024 shows Aneesa Haroon (L) and Zulekha Mahmood working at a field after finishing school in Abdullah Goth village on the outskirts of Karachi. (AFP)

“In a way, we are experiencing an education apartheid,” said Adil Najam, an international relations professor at Boston University who has researched Pakistan’s education system.
“We have at least 10 different systems, and you can buy whatever quality of education you want, from absolutely abysmal to absolutely world-class.
“The private non-profit schools can prime the pump by putting (out) a good idea, but we are a country of a quarter billion, so these schools can’t change the system.”
Even young student Aneesa, who has set her mind on becoming a doctor after health professionals visited her school, recognizes the divide with city kids.
“They don’t work in field labor like we do.”




This photo taken on November 13, 2024 shows Kamran Imran (L), a 10-year-old schoolboy (L), working at a motorcycle workshop after finishing school in Abdullah Goth village on the outskirts of Karachi. (AFP)

In the small market of Abdullah Goth, dozens of children can be seen ducking in and out of street-side cafes serving truck drivers or stacking fruit in market stalls.
Ten-year-old Kamran Imran supports his father in raising his three younger siblings by working at a motorcycle workshop in the afternoons, earning 250 rupees ($0.90) a day.
Muhammad Hanif, the 24-year-old owner of the workshop, does not support the idea of education and has not sent his own children to school.
“What’s the point of studying if after 10 to 12 years, we still end up struggling for basic needs, wasting time and finding no way out?” he told AFP.
Najam, the professor, said that low-quality education was contributing to the rise in out-of-school children.
Parents, realizing their children cannot compete for jobs with those who attended better schools, instead prefer to teach them labor skills.
“As big a crisis as children being out of school is the quality of the education in schools,” said Najam.


Pakistan likely to import around 7 million cotton bales this year as local production nearly halves

Updated 5 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan likely to import around 7 million cotton bales this year as local production nearly halves

  • Pakistan produced 5.3 million cotton bales by mid-December against 10 million targeted, government data shows
  • While the imports may ensure smooth supply of raw material, they may put pressure on foreign exchange reserves

KARACHI: Pakistan is likely to import around 7 million cotton bales this year owing to a decline of nearly half the annual target set by the Federal Committee on Agriculture (FCA), industry stakeholders said on Tuesday.

Pakistan’s cotton production stood at 5.3 million bales each weighing 170 kilograms as of Dec. 15, according to state-run Pakistan Central Cotton Committee (PCCC) data. The FCA had set a target of 10.2 million bales in April.

Karachi Cotton Brokers Forum (KCBF) Chairman Naseem Usman Osawala sees the country’s cotton production declining by 46 percent this season, compared to the FCA target.

“The country is expected to produce about 5.5 million bales this year,” he told Arab News, adding Pakistan would have to import around 7 million bales to meet requirement of its textile industry which consumes about 12 million bales a year.

The country had sown cotton over 2.002 million hectares, which was down by 11 percent from the targeted 2.26 million hectares.

Muhammad Waqas Ghani, head of research at Karachi-based JS Global Capital brokerage firm, said the South Asian country is likely to miss its cotton output target of 10 million bales.

“At the current rate of arrival, the output can reach 7 million bales at its best,” he added.

Cotton is a raw material for Pakistan’s largest textile industry and was the worst hit crop by climate-induced floods earlier this year.

Osawala said Pakistan’s cotton production has been falling because of an increasing number of sugar mills being established in the country’s cotton-producing regions.

Courts in Pakistan have been issuing significant rulings to bar the establishment of sugar mills in the designated cotton belt areas of the Punjab province. In 2018, the Supreme Court ordered relocation of three sugar mills from cotton-producing districts in southern Punjab to protect the crop.

Since cotton prices are low in the international market, textile millers would go for more imports, according to the KCBF chairman.

On Dec. 22, the price of cotton in the New York market stood at as much as 65.85 cents per pound, 1.64 cents lower than last year, according to the PCCC data.

Osawala said Pakistan’s increasing textile imports are also “hurting local cotton production.”

According to the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics’ (PBS) July-November data, the country had imported raw cotton, synthetic fiber, synthetic and artificial silk yarn and worn clothing worth $2.82 billion, 5 percent more than the imports during the same period last year.

Speaking of the impact of Pakistan’s falling cotton production, Kamran Arshad, chairman of All Pakistan Textile Mills Association (APTMA), said the millers would have to import “a lot of cotton” this year.

“I think approximately 7-7.5 million bales will have to be imported this year,” he said.

The textile and apparel sector is Pakistan’s largest exporter, accounting for more than half of the country’s overall exports and contributing around 8.5 percent of the gross domestic product (GDP) by employing nearly 40 percent of the industrial labor force. But high energy costs and outdated infrastructure among other factors continue to slow growth and leave the country trailing regional peers.

In the last fiscal year, Pakistan imported as much as 6.2 million cotton bales each weighing 220 kilograms, mostly from Brazil and the United States, according to KCBF Chairman Arshad.

Shankar Talreja, head of research at Karachi-based Topline Securities, said Pakistan is likely to import cotton worth $1.2 billion this year “considering the requirement.”

“The full-year import of cotton is likely to remain over $1 billion,” Talreja said.

Economic experts say while importing more cotton would ensure smooth supply of raw material to Pakistan’s textile sector, it may put pressure on the country’s foreign exchange reserves that rose to $15.9 billion last week after the International Monetary Fund (IMF) released a $1.2 billion tranche under Pakistan’s $7 billion loan program.