Little hope of Ukraine breakthrough during Xi France visit: observers

Chinese President Xi Jinping welcomes French President Emmanuel Macron at the Great Hall of the People, in Beijing on Apr. 6, 2023. (Reuters/File)
Short Url
Updated 03 May 2024
Follow

Little hope of Ukraine breakthrough during Xi France visit: observers

  • “France and the European Union expect him to use his influence on Russia, but Xi Jinping has nothing to offer on Ukraine,” said a former European diplomat
  • Xi is due to make a state visit to France on Monday and Tuesday

PARIS: French President Emmanuel Macron will next week make a new push to try and dissuade China’s Xi Jinping from supporting Russian President Vladimir Putin’s war against Ukraine but is unlikely to make a breakthrough on ending the conflict during the visit, observers say.
President Xi’s visit is set to be rich on symbolism — with a sumptuous dinner at the Elysee Palace and a trip to the Pyrenees mountains planned — but risks being short on diplomatic success for the French leader.
“France and the European Union expect him to use his influence on Russia, but Xi Jinping has nothing to offer on Ukraine,” said a former European diplomat, asking not to be named.
Xi is due to make a state visit to France on Monday and Tuesday, followed by visits to Serbia and Hungary, two European countries retaining warm ties with Russia.
While Xi and Macron will discuss international crises, trade, climate change and cultural exchanges, the key aim will be to “point out that for Europe, the first issue with China is its position on Ukraine,” said a source close to the French government.
On a visit to China in 2023, Macron had already called on Xi to “bring Russia to its senses” over Ukraine and urged him not to deliver weapons to Moscow.
Little has changed, however. Xi will host Putin for talks in China later this month.
Macron, 46, indicated he had not given up on the idea of trying to get Xi, 70, on his side.
“It’s not in China’s interest today to have a Russia that destabilizes the international order,” the French president said in an interview with The Economist published on Thursday. “We need to work with China to build peace.”
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, who has urged Beijing to play a greater role in ending the Ukraine war, will join Macron and Xi for talks on Monday.
Macron has said he will ask the Chinese president to help him achieve that aim when he visits Paris, which is preparing to host the Olympic Games this summer.
There is a historic tradition that peace should reign during the Olympics — although the opening of the Games in Beijing in August 2008 did not halt Russia’s invasion of Georgia.
“On Ukraine, China has done nothing,” said Marc Julienne, director of the Center for Asian Studies at the French Institute of International Relations (IFRI).
In February 2023, China published a 12-point position paper on Ukraine, but it was rejected by Kyiv and its Western allies.
Beijing, which says it is a neutral party in the Ukraine conflict, has been criticized for refusing to condemn Moscow for its offensive.
The United States had accused China of helping Russia carry out its biggest militarization since Soviet times.
US officials say China has provided dual-use supplies that have let Russia regroup in the face of a long delay in US aid to Ukraine.
In April, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken said this included “machine tools, semiconductors, other dual-use items that have helped Russia rebuild the defense industrial base that sanctions and export controls had done so much to degrade.”
China has rejected the US claims as “groundless accusations.”
Macron, too, is expected to raise “concerns” about “the activity of certain Wuhan companies that could be directly involved in or contribute significantly to the Russian war effort,” according to a member of his team.
Beijing is a major supporter of the Russian economy.
China-Russia trade in 2023 reached a record $240 billion, according to customs data, overshooting a goal of $200 billion set by the neighbors.
Experts say Beijing is unlikely to renounce support for Moscow, which it sees as a priority partner in its opposition to the United States.
“Xi Jinping’s priority is the Global South,” said Emmanuel Lincot, a China expert at the Catholic University of Paris.
“There is a congruence in the Sino-Russian bilateral relationship, particularly in the desire to counter the West. Which is not to say that there is no rivalry.”


British group Bob Vylan sue Irish broadcaster RTE for defamation

Updated 15 sec ago
Follow

British group Bob Vylan sue Irish broadcaster RTE for defamation

  • Punk-rap duo launch proceedings at Irish High Court over TV news report that accused them of ‘antisemitic’ chants during Glastonbury Festival performance
  • Solicitors say ‘death to the IDF’ chant had been ‘criticizing military actions’ by the Israeli army and at no point targeted Jewish people

LONDON: British rap duo Bob Vylan are suing Ireland’s national broadcaster, RTE, for defamation over its reporting of their chants from the stage at the Glastonbury Festival in opposition to the actions of the Israeli military during the war in Gaza.

Following the group’s performance in June, RTE News reported that lead singer Pascal Robinson-Foster had led antisemitic chanting.

“These allegations are categorically denied by our clients and are entirely untrue,” Phoenix Law Solicitors, acting for the group, said on Tuesday. The firm confirmed that legal proceedings had been launched at the High Court in Dublin on Monday on behalf of Robinson-Foster and drummer Wade Laurence George.

During the performance, Robinson-Foster led chants of “Death, death, to the IDF,” a reference to the Israel Defense Forces, and “Free, free, Palestine.”

The performance sparked an outcry in the UK, including accusations that the group were guilty of hate speech, as well as criticism of the BBC for allowing the chants to go out on a live stream.

The group maintain that their actions were not antisemitic but merely a show of support for Palestinians suffering in Gaza.

“At their Glastonbury performance, Bob Vylan made statements expressing support for Palestinian self-determination and criticizing military actions by the Israel Defence Forces,” Phoenix Law Solicitors said.

“At no point did their comments target Jewish people or express hatred towards any group.

“In fact, our client has stated: ‘We are not for the death of Jews, Arabs or any other race or group of people.’ The comments made were politically charged but not antisemitic in nature.”

The group had requested an apology and retraction from RTE, the law firm added, but the broadcaster “failed to address the harm caused.” The aim of the legal proceedings is to “seek redress for the significant reputational and emotional damage suffered by our clients.”

Since the start of the war in Gaza in 2023, following the Oct. 7 attacks on Israel led by Hamas, the Israeli government and its supporters have increasingly accused those critical of the state’s actions during the conflict of antisemitism.

More than 70,000 Palestinians have been killed during the war, according to health officials in Gaza, and Israel’s actions been widely condemned by human rights groups, academics and many governments as amounting to genocide.

Bob Vylan’s festival performance took place at a time when scores of Palestinians were being killed each day, including many gunned down as they tried to obtain food from humanitarian aid hubs.

“Our clients are no stranger to utilizing their freedom of expression to speak out against the genocide in Gaza,” said Darragh Mackin, a Phoenix Law solicitor.

“There is however a fundamental distinction between speaking critically about the role of the Israeli state forces, and being antisemitic.”

RTE has said it does not comment on legal proceedings.

After the Glastonbury performance, Bob Vylan faced a backlash in the UK and abroad. Organizers of several music festivals canceled scheduled performances by the group, and US authorities revoked their visas. Robinson-Foster was interviewed by police last month but has not been charged with any crime.

British Prime Minister Keir Starmer described the incident as “appalling hate speech.” The BBC issued an apology for broadcasting the performance, saying it regretted not taking dawn the live stream.

During a podcast appearance in October, Robinson-Foster defended his actions and said the criticism his group had faced was “minimal compared to what people in Palestine are going through.”