Israel’s Gaza evacuation order could breach international law – UN

A Palestinian woman reacts as others rush to look for victims in the rubble of a building following an Israeli strike in Khan Yunis in the southern Gaza Strip on October 17, 2023. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 17 October 2023
Follow

Israel’s Gaza evacuation order could breach international law – UN

  • Term ‘forcible transfer’ describes the forced relocation of civilian populations 
  • Palestinians report heavy shelling in south Gaza towns where civilians seeking refuge 

GENEVA: The United Nations human rights office said on Tuesday that Israel’s siege of Gaza and its evacuation order for the north of the enclave could amount to a forcible transfer of civilians and be in breach of international law.
Speaking to reporters in Geneva, Ravina Shamdasani, spokesperson for the UN human rights office, said Israel seemed to have made no effort to ensure the civilians temporarily evacuated in Gaza were provided with proper accommodation, as well as satisfactory conditions of hygiene, health, safety and nutrition.
“We are concerned that this order, combined with the imposition of a complete siege of Gaza, may not be considered as lawful temporary evacuation and would therefore amount to a forcible transfer of civilians in breach of international law,” she said.
“Those who managed to comply with the Israeli authorities’ order to evacuate are now trapped in the south of the Gaza Strip, with scant shelter, fast-depleting food supplies, little or no access to clean water, sanitation, medicine and other basic needs.”
The term “forcible transfer” describes the forced relocation of civilian populations and it is a crime against humanity punishable by the International Criminal Court (ICC).
In separate comments, the World Food Programme said its food supplies in Gaza were running low but that it was stockpiling supplies in the Egyptian city of Al-Arish nearby.
Abeer Etefa, WFP Regional Communications Lead for the Middle East and North Africa, said they hoped “to cross as soon as the border access is granted.”
“We call for unimpeded access, safe passage to desperately needed humanitarian supplies to Gaza,” she said.
Trucks carrying supplies headed toward the Rafah crossing in Egypt, the only access point to the enclave outside of Israel’s control, though it was not certain whether they would be able to cross.
In addition to dwindling food and water supplies, Gaza’s health sector finds itself at a “breaking point,” said UN Special Rapporteur Tlaleng Mofokeng.
“Gaza’s medical infrastructure has been irreparably damaged and health care providers are working in a dire situation with limited access to medical supplies and conditions that do not allow them to provide timely and quality health care,” said Mofokeng, who focuses on the right to health.
Fuel reserves at all hospitals across Gaza are expected to last for an additional 24 hours only, according to the UN Palestinian agency UNRWA.
“The shutdown of backup generators would place the lives of thousands of patients at serious risk,” it said.

The World Health Organization (WHO) said on Tuesday it needs urgent access to Gaza to deliver aid and medical supplies, as the UN agency warned of a long-term humanitarian crisis in the Palestinian enclave.

Dr. Richard Brennan, regional emergency director of the WHO’s Eastern Mediterranean regional office, said the agency was meeting with “decision-makers” on Tuesday to open access to Gaza as soon as possible.

“We have aid south of Rafah and are waiting for the go ahead to get entry to Gaza,” he said, referring to the Rafah crossing with Egypt, which was a vital artery before the fighting and is now a key route for desperately needed supplies into Gaza.

WHO said its supplies had been ready to go for three days, but teams had been unable to deliver it.

“Even if you think this madness and horror stop and we think about recovery, this will be a long-term humanitarian exercise,” said Dr. Richard Peeperkorn, WHO representative for the West Bank and Gaza.

PALESTINIANS REPORT HEAVY SHELLING IN SOUTHERN GAZA

Palestinians in Gaza reported intense bombardments early Tuesday near the southern towns of Khan Younis and Rafah, where Israel ordered civilians to seek refuge.
Israeli bombs hit areas west and southeast of Khan Younis and west of Rafah, according to local reports. Thousands of people trying to escape Gaza are gathered in Rafah, which contains the territory’s only border crossing to Egypt, as international mediators press for a deal to allow aid in and refugees with foreign passports out.
Details of casualties were not immediately available.


How the Palestinian Circus sustains hope and resistance under Israeli occupation

Updated 6 sec ago
Follow

How the Palestinian Circus sustains hope and resistance under Israeli occupation

  • Under mounting Israeli raids and restrictions, a West Bank circus troupe turns art into political expression
  • For displaced and traumatized Palestinian youth, joy, balance and teamwork help build mental resilience

DUBAI: On any given morning in the village of Birzeit, just 10 kilometers north of the West Bank city of Ramallah, the sound of juggling balls hitting the floor mixes with laughter, music, and the occasional gasp.

Inside a modest rehearsal space, young performers rehearse feats of balance and acrobatics at the Palestinian Circus, which has become a small outlet for resistance and joy among young people across the occupied West Bank.

However, the circus is under more pressure than ever. Mohamad Rabah, its executive director, told Arab News that Israeli raids had seen one of their colleagues detained and the troupe’s activities become more difficult to sustain.

“The military forces were in Birzeit one month ago. They were here in front of our building. But we are not a special case,” Rabah said.

“We are the same as any Palestinian suffering from this occupation, and we try to find ways to resist, to stay resilient and to find creative ways to work.”

Founded in 2006 in the aftermath of the Second Intifada, the Palestinian Circus was born from an urgency to reestablish hope and provide creative outlets for young Palestinians.

The circus offers children and young adults the chance to train in a range of arts and take part in professional productions around the world.

Given the physical demands and collective discipline required, Rabah says circus skills have become a language through which children and young people can express fear, anger, hope and resistance.

The group’s first production, launched amid intense Israeli restrictions, was bluntly political.

“The first show was called Circus Behind the Wall, and it was using circus disciplines to connect with acts like juggling over the wall,” Rabah said.

“The wall, built by Israel around major Palestinian cities, had cut families, friends and livelihoods apart. The circus answered symbolically.”

The show toured locally and internationally for several years. By 2008, those early performers had become teachers.

“The same young people who gained the skill at that time as circus performers started to teach other youth and kids,” Rabah said.

Since those early days, its programs have expanded into refugee camps in Hebron, Nablus, Jenin, Farah, Ramallah, and Jerusalem — areas where trauma was not abstract but a daily reality.

Nearly two decades later, the organization has grown into a prominent cultural institution. This year alone, Rabah said, the circus completed 90 performances — 55 in Palestine and 35 abroad.

It has appeared at festivals in France, Italy, Ireland and Belgium and even at the UK’s Glastonbury.

The occupied West Bank faces its gravest crisis in years, with escalating Israeli military raids, record settler attacks and accelerating displacement.

Raids in areas like Jenin and Nablus have killed hundreds and damaged vital infrastructure, while settler violence and demolitions have pushed many rural and herding communities off their land.

Settlement expansion continues, aimed at entrenching permanent control and foreclosing Palestinian statehood.

The Palestinian Authority is weakened by fiscal collapse, sanctions and loss of legitimacy, undermining services and governance, while humanitarian agencies warn of worsening protection risks and de facto forcible transfer.

Some Palestinian Circus productions confront politics head on, like “Sarah,” created in 2017, which tells the story of displacement. “It’s a performance … about the journey and the suffering of refugees,” Rabah said.

“We also have happy and uplifting performances … like Wonderland, which is like a children and family show inspired by the Alice in Wonderland theme.”

In a society saturated with loss, Rabah says joy itself becomes an act of resistance. However, performance is only one part of the work. The larger mission lies in training and psychosocial support.

“This year, we worked with 4,000 children, women and people with disabilities — 2,000 in Gaza and 2,000 in the West Bank and Jerusalem,” Rabah said.

“There are 16 disciplines in circus, so we use the term ‘circus for all,’ and with circus for all that’s inclusivity. Everyone can find their space under the circus.”

Unlike theater, Rabah says there are no singular stars in circus, which makes the whole endeavor a lesson in team building, with young people learning to rely on each other for balance during daring acrobatics.

That reliance has become more urgent as violence has escalated across the West Bank and Gaza. With mobility increasingly restricted, Rabah says freedom has been incrementally squeezed out of Palestinian life, especially for young people.

Relying on each other’s support is the only way to survive.

“From one city to another… it requires a lot of work to meet another young person,” Rabah said. “What the Israeli occupation is trying to do is to take from us every meaning of living.”

Still, the show goes on. This year, despite visa obstacles and excessive costs, the circus managed to send more than 40 children abroad for cultural exchanges — an achievement that Rabah admits came at a high price.

“This year alone, we spent more than half a million shekels ($157,350) … on flight tickets,” he said. “Looking at the demand, you wish to do more. It’s a drop in the ocean.”

In Gaza, the stakes are even higher. Rabah visited the enclave in 2022 to meet with circus artists, many of whom continued training amid the devastation wrought by the conflict that began in October 2023.

“They are inspiring,” he said. “They worked during the genocide with nothing, starving. Their schools were destroyed, but they continued to perform and to train. There are, I think, four to five artists who were lost, killed by the Israeli bombing.”

Rabah himself joined the organization in 2018, after the founding artists moved to Europe. He was not a performer but could see the social impact that the project could have. He said art was essential in a society where political participation is constrained.

“I didn’t have any circus background. My background is community and youth work and management,” he said.

“There are limited ways in which young people can express their voice … so art becomes not only a way of entertainment… it’s a way that you participate in the community.”

The circus does not impose any narrative, with most of the shows being produced by the performers themselves without a given script. “Most of our shows, the ideas come from the artists,” Rabah said. “They do it with their bodies and their circus tricks.”

As the organization approaches its 20th anniversary, it plans to expand with a mobile circus tent, bringing performances to the most isolated communities. This is something Rabah says will require further sponsorship, which he hopes will continue regardless of the political situation.

“Put yourself in the shoes of a 15-year-old Palestinian living in a refugee camp in Gaza … it’s a struggle for identity and existence,” he said.

“We need every bit of support to allow us to exist and keep existing with our identity and culture and every meaning of life.”