‘Debt traps’: Pakistan removes 120 illegal loan apps from Google, Apple stores

A Pakistani vendor counts currency notes at his roadside stall in Islamabad, Pakistan, on December 15, 2011. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 16 August 2023
Follow

‘Debt traps’: Pakistan removes 120 illegal loan apps from Google, Apple stores

  • Issue came to light in July when a Pakistani man took his life after receiving threats from illegal loan apps
  • SECP advises borrowers to obtain loans only from licensed Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCS)

ISLAMABAD: The Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) said on Wednesday it had removed 120 illegal personal loan apps from Google and Apple stores to safeguard people from falling into “debt traps.”

Pakistan has been cracking down on loan apps involved in extorting money through threats and blackmail since July when the death by suicide of a 40-year-old man from Rawalpindi made headlines in the country. The man was unable to return the money he borrowed from loan apps, with his wife telling police threats and blackmail compelled her husband to take his life.

While Pakistan has reported a surge in the number of people personal finance apps in the last two years, the boom has led to a surge in complaints about illegal lenders that routinely abuse customers’ data and use aggressive recovery tactics including threats and blackmail.

“In order to safeguard the public from falling into debt traps of illegal loan apps, the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP), in coordination with Google, Apple, and the PTA, has ensured the removal of 120 illegal Loan apps that were previously available at Google and Apple Stores,” the SECP said in a press release.

The finance regulator said illegal personal loan apps have recently raised concerns of mis-selling, data privacy violations, and coercive recovery tactics. The SECP said it had identified 120 “unlawfully running apps” through complaints and surveillance, adding that it had referred them to the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) for further action.

“As a result of SECP’s efforts and continuous engagement, Google has introduced Pakistan’s Personal Loan App Policy, according to which Google only allows SECP-approved Personal Loan Apps for placement on its Google Play Store,” it added.

The regulator advised borrowers to obtain loans only from licensed Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs).

Pakistan is seeing a rise in the number of users seeking loans from personal finance apps as the country continues to suffer from staggering inflation. Pakistan reported inflation at 28.3 percent in July while in May, the inflation rate jumped to a record high of 38 percent.

Reflecting a jump in smartphone use, the number of Pakistanis using personal finance apps more than doubled to 19 percent in 2022 from two years earlier, boosting low rates of financial inclusion, according to a survey earlier this year by Karandaaz Pakistan, a nonprofit.


IMF staff to visit Pakistan Feb. 25 for key loan reviews as reforms stabilize economy

Updated 6 sec ago
Follow

IMF staff to visit Pakistan Feb. 25 for key loan reviews as reforms stabilize economy

  • Talks to cover third review under $7 billion bailout and climate resilience program
  • Analysts warn tax shortfall, power tariff cuts could face scrutiny by lender 

KARACHI: An International Monetary Fund (IMF) staff team will visit Pakistan from Feb. 25 to begin discussions on key program reviews, the lender said on Thursday, as authorities seek to lock in recent economic stabilization after a prolonged financial crisis.

The talks will cover the third review under Pakistan’s $7 billion Extended Fund Facility (EFF) bailout and the second review under the Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF), which supports countries dealing with climate vulnerabilities.

Pakistan has spent the past year implementing tough fiscal and structural reforms — including tax increases, subsidy cuts and a tighter monetary policy — to stabilize a fragile economy that faced record inflation, dwindling foreign reserves and default fears in 2023.

“We do have a staff team that is expected to visit Pakistan starting February 25th for discussions on the third review under the EFF and the second review under the RSF,” IMF communications director Julie Kozack said at a regular press briefing.

The IMF says the program aims to restore macroeconomic stability, rebuild external buffers and make Pakistan more resilient to climate shocks following devastating floods in recent years.

Kozack said Pakistan’s policy implementation had already produced measurable improvements.

“Pakistan’s policy efforts under the EFF have helped stabilize the economy and rebuild confidence,” she said.

She noted fiscal indicators were improving in line with program targets.

“Pakistan currently has a primary fiscal surplus of 1.3 percent of GDP in FY25, which was in line with program targets. Headline inflation has been relatively contained. And Pakistan posted its first current account surplus in 14 years in FY2025.”

Pakistani authorities have also cited improving macroeconomic trends. 

Governor State Bank of Pakistan Jameel Ahmad has said growth could reach about 4.75 percent in the fiscal year ending June, while inflation, which peaked above 38 percent in May 2023, has fallen sharply over the past year following interest rate hikes and fiscal tightening.

The IMF official added that governance reforms remain a major component of the program.

“The governance and corruption diagnostic assessment report was recently published,” Kozack said.

“It includes proposals for reforms, including simplifying tax policy design, levelling the playing field for public procurement, and improving the asset declaration transparency.”

The upcoming review will determine whether Pakistan remains eligible for continued disbursements under the bailout program and help reinforce investor confidence.

Analysts say the review is likely to pass but may involve difficult negotiations on fiscal discipline and energy policy.

“This is expected to be a smooth sailing, however questions might arise,” Shankar Talreja, head of research at Karachi-based Topline Securities Limited, told Arab News.

Experts say the IMF could question whether Islamabad consulted the lender before reducing electricity tariffs by about Rs4 per unit for export-oriented industries, a move designed to support manufacturing but with fiscal implications.

He also flagged a revenue gap.

“Pakistan has missed” the IMF’s revenue target by Rs336 billion ($1.2 billion), he said.

“Tax revenue shortfall which is one of the indicative targets which Pakistan has missed.”

Muhammad Waqas Ghani, head of research at JS Global Capital Limited., said the next review may be “tough”:

“Although (Pakistan’s) macroeconomic indicators have improved since the start of the program, the IMF is still expected to press firmly on energy reforms and circular debt before clearing the next tranche, which the government is likely to secure after tough negotiations.”