Israel's Netanyahu on the rack over ‘judicial power grab’

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu addresses a joint press conference with the German Chancellor following talks at the Chancellery in Berlin on March 16, 2023. (AFP/FILE)
Short Url
Updated 18 March 2023
Follow

Israel's Netanyahu on the rack over ‘judicial power grab’

  • The controversial legal overhaul has sparked weeks of mass protests by hundreds of thousands of people across Israel
  • Hundreds of Israeli military officers will refuse to report for duty on Sunday, US calls for a compromise on the plans

JEDDAH: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faced a barrage of criticism from all sides on Friday amid growing unrest over proposed reforms to the Supreme Court that opponents say is a judicial power grab.

Hundreds of elite Israeli military reserve officers will refuse to report for duty on Sunday in protest at the reforms, the US called on the Israeli government to seek a compromise on the plans, and a former Israeli prime minister urged world leaders to shun Netanyahu.

The controversial legal overhaul has sparked weeks of mass protests by hundreds of thousands of people across Israel amid a deteriorating security situation in the occupied West Bank and rising tensions with Palestinians.

The reforms would give Netanyahu’s parliamentary coalition control over the appointment of judges to the Supreme Court and power to overturn its rulings. Critics say the overhaul will upend the country’s system of checks and balances and give the prime minister too much power. They also say Netanyahu, who is on trial on corruption charges, could escape justice once the court system is revamped.

In an unprecedented protest by the security services, about 750 elite reserve officers from the air force, special forces and Mossad signed two open letters saying they would not report for duty on Sunday.

In one letter, 100 air force officers including two former chiefs said Netanyahu’s government was subverting Israel’s security and democracy. “We fear that following military orders would be a violation of our oath, our conscience and our mission,” they said.

In the other letter, about 650 officers from the reserves’ special forces and cyber units said: “We will not serve a dictatorship. The contract was broken. We are ready to give our life and soul, and the government should give responsibility and sanity. You want a dictatorship — you will pay the full price.”

Israel’s military chief of staff Herzi Halevi met protesting officers and warned Netanyahu about rising discontent in the ranks.

Ehud Olmert, who was prime minister from 2006-2009, said world leaders should refuse to meet Netanyahu. He appealed specifically to British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, who is expected to host Netanyahu in the next few weeks.

“I urge the leaders of friendly countries … to refrain from meeting the Israeli prime minister,” Olmert said. “I think that the present government of Israel is simply anti-Israeli.”

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken said the US would not take sides in the dispute, but called for compromise. “Consensus is the best way forward,” he said.


A ceasefire holds in Syria but civilians live with fear and resentment

Updated 3 sec ago
Follow

A ceasefire holds in Syria but civilians live with fear and resentment

QAMISHLI: Fighting this month between Syria’s government and Kurdish-led forces left civilians on either side of the frontline fearing for their future or harboring resentment as the country’s new leaders push forward with transition after years of civil war.
The fighting ended with government forces capturing most of the territory previously held by the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces in the country’s northeast, and a fragile ceasefire is holding. SDF fighters will be absorbed into Syria’s army and police, ending months of disputes.
The Arab-majority population in the areas that changed hands, Raqqa and Deir Ezzor, have celebrated the SDF’s withdrawal after largely resenting its rule.
But thousands of Kurdish residents of those areas fled, and non-Kurdish residents remain in Kurdish-majority enclaves still controlled by the SDF. The International Organization for Migration has registered more than 173,000 people displaced.
Fleeing again and again
Subhi Hannan is among them, sleeping in a chilly schoolroom in the SDF-controlled city of Qamishli with his wife, three children and his mother after fleeing Raqqa.
The family is familiar with displacement after the years of civil war under former President Bashar Assad. They were first displaced from their hometown of Afrin in 2018, in an offensive by Turkish-backed rebels. Five years later, Hannan stepped on a land mine and lost his legs.
During the insurgent offensive that ousted Assad in December 2024, the family fled again, landing in Raqqa.
In the family’s latest flight this month, Hannan said their convoy was stopped by government fighters, who arrested most of their escort of SDF fighters and killed one. Hannan said fighters also took his money and cell phone and confiscated the car the family was riding in.
“I’m 42 years old and I’ve never seen something like this,” Hannan said. “I have two amputated legs, and they were hitting me.”
Now, he said, “I just want security and stability, whether it’s here or somewhere else.”
The father of another family in the convoy, Khalil Ebo, confirmed the confrontation and thefts by government forces, and said two of his sons were wounded in the crossfire.
Syria’s defense ministry in a statement acknowledged “a number of violations of established laws and disciplinary regulations” by its forces during this month’s offensive and said it is taking legal action against perpetrators.
A change from previous violence
The level of reported violence against civilians in the clashes between government and SDF fighters has been far lower than in fighting last year on Syria’s coast and in the southern province of Sweida. Hundreds of civilians from the Alawite and Druze religious minorities were killed in revenge attacks, many of them carried out by government-affiliated fighters.
This time, government forces opened “humanitarian corridors” in several areas for Kurdish and other civilians to flee. Areas captured by government forces, meanwhile, were largely Arab-majority with populations that welcomed their advance.
One term of the ceasefire says government forces should not enter Kurdish-majority cities and towns. But residents of Kurdish enclaves remain fearful.
The city of Kobani, surrounded by government-controlled territory, has been effectively besieged, with residents reporting cuts to electricity and water and shortages of essential supplies. A UN aid convoy entered the enclave for the first time Sunday.
On the streets of SDF-controlled Qamishli, armed civilians volunteered for overnight patrols to watch for any attack.
“We left and closed our businesses to defend our people and city,” said one volunteer, Suheil Ali. “Because we saw what happened in the coast and in Sweida and we don’t want that to be repeated here.”
Resentment remains
On the other side of the frontline in Raqqa, dozens of Arab families waited outside Al-Aqtan prison and the local courthouse over the weekend to see if loved ones would be released after SDF fighters evacuated the facilities.
Many residents of the region believe Arabs were unfairly targeted by the SDF and often imprisoned on trumped-up charges.
At least 126 boys under the age of 18 were released from the prison Saturday after government forces took it over.
Issa Mayouf from the village of Al-Hamrat, was waiting with his wife outside the courthouse Sunday for word about their 18-year-old son, who was arrested four months ago. Mayouf said he was accused of supporting a terrorist organization after SDF forces found Islamic chants as well as images on his phone mocking SDF commander Mazloum Abdi.
“SDF was a failure as a government,” Mayouf said “And there were no services. Look at the streets, the infrastructure, the education. It was all zero.”
Northeast Syria has oil and gas reserves and some of the country’s most fertile agricultural land. The SDF “had all the wealth of the country and they did nothing with it for the country,” Mayouf said.
Mona Yacoubian, director of the Middle East Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said Kurdish civilians in besieged areas are terrified of “an onslaught and even atrocities” by government forces or allied groups.
But Arabs living in formerly SDF-controlled areas “also harbor deep fears and resentment toward the Kurds based on accusations of discrimination, intimidation, forced recruitment and even torture while imprisoned,” she said.
“The experience of both sides underscores the deep distrust and resentment across Syria’s diverse society that threatens to derail the country’s transition,” Yacoubian said.
She added it’s now on the government of interim Syrian President Ahmad Al-Sharaa to strike a balance between demonstrating its power and creating space for the country’s anxious minorities to have a say in their destiny.