Most G20 members condemn war in Ukraine at FMs’ meet in India 

Indian External Affairs Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar speaks during the G20 foreign ministers’ meeting in New Delhi on March 2, 2023. (Reuters)
Short Url
Updated 02 March 2023
Follow

Most G20 members condemn war in Ukraine at FMs’ meet in India 

  • Meeting did not produce a joint communique as members could not “reconcile positions”
  • Presence of Oman, UAE, Egypt as G20 guests shows India’s increasing engagement with the Middle East 

NEW DELHI: Most members of the Group of 20 condemned the war in Ukraine during a meeting in New Delhi on Thursday, with only Russia and China disagreeing. 

As foreign ministers from the world’s largest economies, which include the US, Saudi Arabia, Indonesia, Russia, China, Japan and the EU, arrived in India, which this year holds the G20 presidency, Prime Minister Narendra Modi called on them to find “common ground” on divisive issues.

But tensions over Russia’s ongoing invasion of Ukraine, which started in February last year, dominated Thursday’s talks.

The meeting did not produce a joint communique, as Indian Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar said G20 members could not “reconcile positions” on Ukraine and “there were divergences” on issues related to the conflict. 

The conference, however, produced an outcome document that reflected agreement on the bulk of issues related to the global south or developing countries. 

“Despite differences on Ukraine, we all were able to reach consensus on other issues,” Jaishankar told reporters. 

“There was a large number of issues where there was agreement: multilateralism, food and energy security, climate change, gender issues, global health, terrorism. There was a considerable meeting of minds. If we had a perfect meeting of minds, we could have had a collective statement, but divergences on Ukraine did come in the way of that.” 

He added that all G20 members condemned terrorism in all its forms and for the first time also discussed counternarcotics efforts. 

The outcome of the meeting came as no surprise, with experts saying that the same differences marred last year’s G20 meetings when the bloc’s presidency was held by Indonesia. 

“There was no joint statement after the foreign ministers’ meeting in Bali. This trend is not at all surprising given the way the G20 is strongly divided between G7 and other countries,” Rezaul H. Laskar, foreign affairs expert and editor of Hindustan Times, told Arab News.

“One important consequence of this lack of consensus is going to be that it puts pressure on India to build bridges between G7 on the one side and China and Russia on the other side…India already has its own challenges dealing with Western pressure because of the Ukrainian crisis. It has its own challenges at the border with China. So, there would be the need for more nimble and assured diplomacy from the Indian side.” 

What has been already visible in Indian efforts as it leads the G20 bloc is New Delhi’s increasing engagement with the Middle East. 

As the G20 president, India could invite special non-G20 guests to participate in the group’s meetings. Among them are the UAE, Oman and Egypt.

Anil Wadhwa, former Indian ambassador to Oman, told Arab News that the invitations signify growth in bilateral ties with these countries, especially Oman and Egypt. 

“Trust has grown with both countries, which are now active defense partners of India…The potential of economic ties and investments both ways is an added incentive. The burgeoning ties with these countries will allow India to reach out as a friend and confidante to Arabic-speaking countries in the Gulf Cooperation Council as well as North Africa,” Wadhwa said. 

The foreign ministers’ gathering was the second ministerial-level talk since India assumed the G20 presidency in December. Last week, the group’s finance ministers met in Bangalore, where the invasion of Ukraine was also a major theme. The meeting resulted in no communique being issued at the end of the session after Russia and China sought to water down language on the war. 

“The conference is taking place at a time when the US-led West and Russia-China on the other side have hardened their positions. We saw it last week in the finance ministers’ meeting. The same arguments are being played out in the G20 foreign ministers’ meeting,” said Shubhajit Roy, foreign affairs correspondent of Indian Express. 

“We just saw US Secretary of State Antony Blinken saying that Russia has been marred by its positions. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov has spoken on a similar line. It is a deadlock. There is no consensus.” 


Pressure builds for answers over Swiss bar fire after victims identified

Updated 1 min 16 sec ago
Follow

Pressure builds for answers over Swiss bar fire after victims identified

*
All 40 victims of New Year fire now identified

*
Prosecutors say ‘fountain candles’ likely cause of blaze

*
Most of victims of bar fire were teenagers, youngest 14

*
Couple who ran the bar under criminal investigation

CRANS-MONTANA, Switzerland: Pressure was building for answers on Monday from the investigation into a New Year bar fire in a Swiss ski resort that killed 40 people, after authorities said they had now identified all the victims, most of whom were teenagers.
The Alpine getaway of Crans-Montana in the canton of Valais united in mourning on Sunday with condolences coming in from leaders ranging from Pope Leo to Chinese President Xi Jinping.
Prosecutors said the fire that spread rapidly in the ‌early hours of January ‌1 was likely caused by sparkling candles igniting the ‌ceiling ⁠of ​the ‌bar’s basement.

CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION
Authorities are investigating the two people who ran the bar on suspicion of crimes including homicide by negligence. On Sunday, police said circumstances did not currently merit them being put under arrest and they did not see a flight risk.
On Monday morning, Swiss newspaper Blick said anger over the case was growing.
“Why are the couple running the bar free?” the paper said on its front page, pasted over ⁠a photo of mourners and media gathered around the huge pile of flowers left in front of the “Le ‌Constellation” bar.
The youngest victims of the blaze, which ‍also injured well over 100 people, ‍were only 14 years old, and the dead were from all around Europe, ‍including several from France and Italy. Swiss authorities have not named the victims.
Italian Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini said in a social media post that “in civilized Switzerland, the prison gates will have to open for quite a few people.”
Salvini said there had been a ​failure to ensure the bar’s basement was safe, questioning the emergency systems and whether there had been enough inspections.

SILENT PROCESSION
Aika Chappaz, a local ⁠resident who took part in a silent procession through the town on Sunday, said justice must be done for the sake of future generations.
“It’s crucial that such a tragedy never happens again. And the investigation must be thorough, because it’s so unbelievable,” she said.
Tages-Anzeiger, another leading Swiss newspaper, said questions must be answered about the age checks at the bar, the soundproofing material used in the basement and the standards governing use of the so-called fountain candles.
One of the bar’s two operators, Jacques Moretti, told Swiss media that Le Constellation had been checked three times in 10 years and that everything was done according to the rules.
Valais authorities say investigators were checking ‌if the bar had undergone its annual building inspections, but that the town had not raised concerns or reported defects to the canton.