IMF bailout should advance economic rights of Pakistanis – Human Rights Watch

A labourer stands beside sacks of potatoes at a market in Lahore, Pakistan, on January 30, 2023. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 08 February 2023
Follow

IMF bailout should advance economic rights of Pakistanis – Human Rights Watch

  • Human Rights Watch says the economic reforms recommended by the international lender will burden low-income segments
  • HRW maintains the IMF and Pakistan must deal with the economic crisis in a way that protects financially vulnerable people

ISLAMABAD: A global rights organization has called for the protection of economically disadvantaged people in Pakistan by broadening social protection systems in the country as officials in Islamabad discuss structural reforms with an International Monetary Fund (IMF) delegation to unlock a stalled bailout program amid a severe dollar liquidity crunch.

The negotiations between the two sides began on February 1 and are expected to conclude during the ongoing week. A successful outcome of the talks will help the government secure $1.1 billion from the international lender under a loan agreement signed in 2019.

The financial assistance from the IMF is likely to ease the crippling shortage of foreign exchange in Pakistan and make other sources of funding accessible to the country. However, the economic reforms currently under discussion are likely to put significant burden on low-income segments, making the government concerned about a likely political backlash in an election year while forcing rights organizations to ring alarm bells.

“Millions of Pakistanis have been pushed into poverty and denied their fundamental social and economic rights,” said Patricia Gossman, associate Asia director at Human Rights Watch (HRW). “The IMF and the Pakistani government have a responsibility to address this crisis in a way that prioritizes and protects low-income people.”

In a statement issued earlier this week, HRW noted the IMF was asking Pakistan to remove energy and fuel subsidies, move to a market-based exchange rate and increase its general sales tax rate. It maintained this was likely to make it harder for many people to meet their basic needs amid the rapid depreciation of local currency and soaring inflation.

“The IMF program should conduct a thorough assessment of the direct and indirect impact these adjustments would have on low-income people and adequately mitigate them,” it added. “New tax measures should be progressive in nature and should not exacerbate inequality and increase the cost of living in ways that undermine rights.”

HRW said the IMF recommendations should encourage government spending on social services, such as education, health care, and poverty-reduction programs while shoring up government revenues by improving the tax collection infrastructure and adopting stringent and transparent accountability measures.

It asked the international lender to make needed funds available as soon as possible, putting into place safeguards to protect people’s economic and social rights while pointing out they were still reeling from the devastating floods last year.

“Pakistan’s government should use the influx of funds to expand support for those worst affected by the economic crisis,” Gossman said. “The IMF should provide Pakistan the time and flexibility to achieve a sustainable, inclusive, and rights-based recovery.”


IMF hails Pakistan privatization drive, calls PIA sale a ‘milestone’

Updated 10 January 2026
Follow

IMF hails Pakistan privatization drive, calls PIA sale a ‘milestone’

  • Fund backs sale of national airline as key step in divesting loss-making state firms
  • IMF has long urged Islamabad to reduce fiscal burden posed by state-owned entities

KARACHI: The International Monetary Fund (IMF) on Saturday welcomed Pakistan’s privatization efforts, describing the sale of the country’s national airline to a private consortium last month as a milestone that could help advance the divestment of loss-making state-owned enterprises (SOEs).

The comments follow the government’s sale of a 75 percent stake in Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) to a consortium led by the Arif Habib Group for Rs 135 billion ($486 million) after several rounds of bidding in a competitive process, marking Islamabad’s second attempt to privatize the carrier after a failed effort a year earlier.

Between the two privatization attempts, PIA resumed flight operations to several international destinations after aviation authorities in the European Union and Britain lifted restrictions nearly five years after the airline was grounded following a deadly Airbus A320 crash in Karachi in 2020 that killed 97 people.

“We welcome the authorities’ privatization efforts and the completion of the PIA privatization process, which was a commitment under the EFF,” Mahir Binici, the IMF’s resident representative in Pakistan, said in response to an Arab News query, referring to the $7 billion Extended Fund Facility.

“This privatization represents a milestone within the authorities’ reform agenda, aimed at decreasing governmental involvement in commercial sectors and attracting investments to promote economic growth in Pakistan,” he added.

The IMF has long urged Islamabad to reduce the fiscal burden posed by loss-making state firms, which have weighed public finances for years and required repeated government bailouts. Beyond PIA, the government has signaled plans to restructure or sell stakes in additional SOEs as part of broader reforms under the IMF program.

Privatization also remains politically sensitive in Pakistan, with critics warning of job losses and concerns over national assets, while supporters argue private sector management could improve efficiency and service delivery in chronically underperforming entities.

Pakistan’s Cabinet Committee on State-Owned Enterprises said on Friday that SOEs recorded a net loss of Rs 122.9 billion ($442 million) in the 2024–25 fiscal year, compared with a net loss of Rs 30.6 billion ($110 million) in the previous year.