Pakistan announces death sentence for two men convicted in motorway gang-rape case

Policemen escort Shafqat Ali (face covered), one of two suspects in the gang-rape case, as they leave from a local court in Lahore on September 15, 2020. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 21 March 2021
Follow

Pakistan announces death sentence for two men convicted in motorway gang-rape case

  • The assault took place last September along a major highway in front of the survivor's children
  • Fewer than 3 percent of sexual assault or rape cases result in a conviction in Pakistan, rights groups say

ISLAMABAD: An anti-terrorism court in Lahore awarded the death sentence to two men convicted of gang-raping a woman in front of her children along a major highway last September in a case that led to protests across the country, officials confirmed while talking to Arab News on Saturday.

The assault took place while the woman, a French national of Pakistani origin, was traveling on the Lahore-Sialkot Motorway on September 9 and her car ran out of fuel, after which she was accosted by Abid Malhi and Shafqat Ali.

Ali was arrested in September, and Malhi in October after Punjab police launched a weeks-long manhunt.

Saturday’s verdict was announced by the anti-terrorism court of Judge Arshad Hussain Bhatta who also gave the two men life imprisonment and imposed a fine of Rs.50,000 each on them.

“It was a blind case and a big challenge for police,” Raja Basharat, Punjab’s provincial law minister, told Arab News. “However, they investigated it professionally and managed to solve the case.”

The minister said prosecuting the case was yet another challenge, adding that the government had proved its ability to provide justice to people in a short span.

“I think such quick decisions by the judiciary will also restore people’s confidence in state institutions,” he noted. “It’s a healthy sign, and everyone is appreciating this decision for which the credit goes to the provincial administration.” 

Punjab Governor Chaudhry Mohammad Sarwar also welcomed the anti-terrorism court’s ruling in an official statement, saying that “those who abuse women and children are also terrorists.” 

“The rule of law and the provision of justice is the first priority of the government,” he continued. “At any level, oppression and injustice will not be tolerated.”

However, a prominent human rights activist Tahira Abdullah described the verdict as “a populist judgment.”

“It does nothing to end violence against women or the crime of rape against women,” she said. “We have a minimum of seven anti-rape laws in Pakistan that date back to 1929. Have these deaths ended rape against women?” 

Criticizing the idea of “retributive justice,” Abdullah said everyone should be clear about the fundamental objective that should be achieved while dealing with such cases.

“For me it is deterrence to end crimes of violence and rape in Pakistan,” she maintained while adding that the court should have given “life sentence until death, not life sentence until 14 or 20 years” while deciding the case. 

According to the Karachi-based group War Against Rape, fewer than three percent of sexual assault or rape cases result in a conviction in Pakistan. 

Faisal Javed Khan, a senator belonging to the ruling Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf party and a close aide to Prime Minister Imran Khan, applauded the verdict on Twitter, saying: “This is a very welcome decision. Such monsters should be made an example of.”


Pakistan showcases fiscal turnaround, reform agenda at Saudi-hosted AlUla forum

Updated 6 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan showcases fiscal turnaround, reform agenda at Saudi-hosted AlUla forum

  • Pakistan has delivered successive primary surpluses and reduced its fiscal deficit from around 8 percent of GDP to approximately 5.4 percent
  • Muhammad Aurangzeb says fiscal space created through consolidation, reforms is being directed toward priority growth-enabling sectors

KARACHI: Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb on Monday highlighted Pakistan’s recent fiscal progress, ongoing reforms and strategy to build buffers while sustaining growth at the AlUla Conference for Emerging Market Economies, underscoring the importance of institutional strengthening in navigating economic and climate-related shocks.

The second edition of the annual AlUla conference was launched by the Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Finance and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) on Sunday. The conference brings together economic decision-makers, finance ministers, central bank governors, leaders of international financial institutions and a select group of experts and specialists from around the world.

Pakistan, which nearly defaulted on its foreign debt obligations in 2023, is currently making efforts to stabilize its economy under a $7 billion International Monetary Fund (IMF) program. The program, agreed in Sept. 2024, accompanied reforms such as privatization of loss-making, state-owned enterprises (SOEs), tax regime overhaul and ending various subsidies for fiscal consolidation.

Attending a high-level panel discussion “Fiscal Policy in a Shock‑Prone World” on the 2nd day of the AlUla Conference, Aurangzeb shared Pakistan’s experience in managing structural constraints, strengthening revenue mobilization, reducing debt vulnerabilities, and responding to shocks while protecting priority development spending.

“Pakistan’s fiscal strategy has been shaped by a history of boom-and-bust cycles, persistent structural deficits, high debt levels, and limited fiscal space,” he said, stressing that it has been critical to carefully safeguard the fiscal progress achieved over the past two to three years.

“Pakistan has delivered successive primary surpluses and reduced its fiscal deficit from around 8 percent of GDP (gross domestic product) to approximately 5.4 percent, with the current trajectory pointing toward a further reduction below five percent.”

This year’s conference highlighted the rapid transformations in the global economy and challenges and the opportunities they presented for emerging market economies, particularly in international trade, monetary and financial systems.

Aurangzeb stressed the discussion around fiscal buffers is not academic for Pakistan but rooted in lived experience as a climate-vulnerable country.

Recalling the catastrophic floods of 2022, he noted that Pakistan was forced to make an immediate international appeal even for rescue and relief operations. In contrast, he said, the country was able to mobilize its own resources despite limited fiscal space during the large-scale floods affecting multiple provinces and river systems this year, demonstrating the practical value of rebuilding fiscal buffers to absorb exogenous shocks.

On the revenue side, he outlined sustained efforts to expand the tax base and strengthen compliance.

“Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio has risen from below 10 percent to close to 12 percent,” the minister said, highlighting the transformation of the tax authority through reforms in people, processes and technology, including the use of AI-led production monitoring systems across various sectors to improve enforcement, curb leakages and reduce corruption by minimizing human intervention.

“The tax policy function has been separated from tax collection and placed within the Ministry of Finance to ensure that budgetary decisions are guided by economic value and policy considerations rather than purely arithmetic targets, while maintaining overall fiscal discipline.”

About expenditure management, the finance minister noted that Pakistan’s federal structure adds complexity, requiring close coordination between the federation and provinces. He shared that a national fiscal framework has been agreed upon and that work is ongoing to strengthen fiscal coordination and discipline across all tiers of government.

“Pakistan’s debt-to-GDP ratio, which had reached around 74 percent, has been reduced to approximately 70 percent,” he said, underscoring ongoing domestic liability management operations aimed at lowering debt servicing costs, which remain the single largest expenditure item in the budget.

“Continued fiscal discipline would further ease debt pressures and help create additional fiscal space.”

Pakistan faced a prolonged economic crisis in recent years, marked by fiscal pressure, high debt levels and balance-of-payments difficulties. Officials now say that decreasing levels of inflation and higher foreign exchange reserves reflect the government’s prudent fiscal policies and debt management.

“The fiscal space created through consolidation and reforms is being directed toward priority growth-enabling sectors, including human capital development, agriculture, information technology, and other areas with strong growth potential,” Aurangzeb said, adding that rebuilding buffers, dampening pro-cyclicality, and sustaining growth require persistence, institutional reform and disciplined policymaking, particularly for countries facing repeated structural and climate-related shocks.