In letter to Facebook, Pakistan’s polio chief thankful for efforts against anti-vaccine content

Babar bin Atta, the Prime Minister’s Focal Person on Polio Eradication, speaks during an interview with Arab News at his home in Islamabad, Pakistan on June 22, 2019 (AN Photo)
Updated 22 June 2019
Follow

In letter to Facebook, Pakistan’s polio chief thankful for efforts against anti-vaccine content

  • Since April, Facebook has removed up to 700 pages, links and profiles spreading spurious polio content on its platform
  • With Facebook’s support almost 80% targeted children vaccinated in June without any violence against health workers, Atta says

ISLAMABAD: The chief of Pakistan’s polio eradication program has thanked social media giant Facebook for removing misinformation from its platforms that discourages vaccination against the virus and endangers the lives of Pakistan’s 270,000 polio vaccinators and other officials involved in the anti-polio campaign.
Complete eradication in Pakistan, one of only three countries in the world where polio still persists, has been hampered by misinformation online, with some Muslim clerics and propaganda videos on social media platforms peddling stories that the vaccines are part of a Western plot to make Muslims sterile and that campaign workers are Western spies. Militant groups have killed nearly 100 polio health workers and their guards since 2012.
Facebook Inc, which along with other social media companies, has faced growing pressure in recent months over spurious content spread on its platform.
In a letter shared exclusively with Arab News on Saturday, Babar bin Atta, the Prime Minister’s Focal Person on Polio Eradication, said the country’s anti-polio initiative “would like to extend its sincere appreciation to Facebook in helping effectively regulate anti-vaccine content.”
“With the upsurge of anti-vaccine content across online platforms worldwide, it has been incredibly reassuring and encouraging for the entire Pakistan Polio Eradication Initiative to see Facebook proactively ramp up its efforts and policies to combat vaccine misinformation and harmful content,” Atta said.




In a letter shared exclusively with Arab News on Saturday, June 22, 2019, Babar bin Atta, the Prime Minister’s Focal Person on Polio Eradication, said the country’s anti-polio initiative “would like to extend its sincere appreciation to Facebook in helping effectively regulate anti-vaccine content.”

In April, religious hard-liners in Pakistan’s northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province raised a scare on social media through false rumors that some children were being poisoned from contaminated polio vaccines. Word on a number of platforms said some children had died.
The rumors triggered mass panic in the province as mobs burned a village health center, blocked a highway and pelted cars with stones. Medical workers were harassed and threatened and panicked parents rushed their children to hospitals, overwhelming health authorities. In Peshawar alone, about 45,000 children were brought to hospitals complaining of nausea and dizziness.
As a result of the false reports, families of hundreds of thousands of children in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and elsewhere refused to participate in the May campaign to eradicate the virus that can cause paralysis and death.
Since then, Facebook has worked to remove up to 700 pages, links and profiles spreading spurious content on its platform, according to the office of the Prime Minister’s Focal Person on Polio Eradication.
“We are grateful for Facebook’s efforts to tackle misinformation through fact-checking … debunking several false claims that have been circulating around the polio vaccine,” Atta said in his letter to Facebook. “Your brilliant efforts in combating misinformation online have been indispensable in helping us reach out to concerned parents and caregivers and forge an enabling environment for vaccine against polio.”
Atta also said Facebook’s support had helped safeguard officials involved in the eradication campaign, saying that as of June 20, polio teams had been able to successfully vaccinate almost 80 percent targeted children in a sub-national campaign launched in June “without any incidence of violence toward our health workers.”
He said Pakistan could not achieve its goal of ending poliovirus transmission by 2020 without the support of partners like Facebook and hoped the “productive partnership” would continue.
In an exclusive statement to Arab News in May, Facebook Inc. had said it was “fully committed” to the safety of Pakistani users of its platforms and was taking steps to reduce misinformation about anti-polio campaigns as Pakistan makes a final push to eradicate the disease.
“We regularly review reports for vaccine misinformation, whether those reports come from our community or the government,” a Facebook spokeswoman told Arab News.
Outlining steps to combat misinformation, the representative said the company removed any content that violated Community Standards.
“If we find that the content does indeed contain misinformation about vaccinations, we reduce its distribution by reducing the News Feed and Search ranking of the Group/Page that shared it and by making sure we are not recommending this content on Facebook nor Instagram,” the spokeswoman said.
“We also rely on the work of leading global health organizations, such as the World Health Organization and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, who have publicly identified verifiable vaccine hoaxes. We will continue to work with Pakistan’s government and world health organizations on this important issue,” the spokeswoman added.
According to a Facebook official with knowledge of the campaign against vaccine misinformation, the company had recently been working to reduce organic distribution on vaccine misinformation content and to substantially lower the distribution of Groups or Pages on Facebook that propagate misinformation.
This includes working to remove offending Groups and Pages from recommendation surfaces on the platform (such as “Groups You Should Join”) and from predictions for when users type into search, the Facebook official who declined to be named said.
It also involves implementing changes so that Facebook doesn’t show or recommend content that contains misinformation about vaccinations on Instagram Explore or hashtag pages, she said. Content from the offending Groups and Pages is also demoted in News Feed, using ranking systems and the Groups and Pages themselves are also reduced in search results.
The Facebook source also said the company was taking taking additional steps to address hoaxes related to vaccines in advertising, investing in systems to better ensure that ads that include misinformation about vaccines are rejected. The company is also removing a number of ad targeting options, such as “vaccine controversies,” that might have been used to help spread misinformation, the official said.


Separated twice: An Afghan man’s life in Pakistan and the fear of losing home again

Updated 2 min 39 sec ago
Follow

Separated twice: An Afghan man’s life in Pakistan and the fear of losing home again

  • Lost as a child in Peshawar, Mohammad Rahim Khan built a life in Pakistan but remains undocumented
  • Deportation drive of ‘illegal’ foreigners exposes legal gaps around adoption, marriage, refugee status

ISLAMABAD: Mohammad Rahim Khan was five years old when he last saw his mother.

It was at the Hajji Camp bus stop in Pakistan’s northwestern city of Peshawar, more than four decades ago. His mother, an Afghan refugee fleeing war, had brought him across the Tari Mangal border in Kurram district and into Pakistan. While waiting at the crowded terminal, Khan wandered to a nearby toy shop. When he returned, she was gone.

He searched for her for two days. She never came back.

A local shopkeeper, Ali Muhammad, took pity on the child and brought him home, promising to help find his family. The temporary shelter became permanent. Khan grew up in Pakistan, adopted informally into the household, and never returned to Afghanistan.

Now 45, he lives on the outskirts of Islamabad in a modest two-room house, working as a daily wage laborer. But a nationwide deportation drive launched by Pakistan in 2023 has placed his entire life under threat.

Since November 2023, authorities have deported nearly 2 million Afghan nationals, targeting those without legal documentation. Khan, who has remained undocumented throughout his adult life, fears he may soon be among them.

“I spoke to my lawyer that I am very worried,” Khan told Arab News. “I love Pakistan.”

A FAMILY WITHOUT PAPERS

Ali Muhammad later married Khan to his daughter, Gul Mina. Together, they have six children, four daughters and two sons. Yet despite decades in Pakistan, Khan’s Afghan nationality continues to shadow the family.

Khan never held an Afghan refugee card, Afghan Citizen Card (ACC), Proof of Registration (POR), or any other formal documentation. His family assumed for decades that his informal adoption, marriage to a Pakistani citizen, and long residence would provide sufficient legal standing. They only sought legal advice when the deportation drive began threatening separation.

Without a Pakistani national identity card, his children cannot obtain Form-B, the birth registration document required for school enrolment.

“They [children] are told to get a Form-B,” Gul Mina told Arab News. “Otherwise, they will not go to school.”

Three of their daughters were forced to leave school after eighth grade.

Healthcare has also been affected. When Khan’s 13-year-old son, Ehsanullah, fractured his arm, a public hospital refused to issue a registration card without identity documents.

“Then I went to a [private clinic] in Chak Shahzad and got my treatment there,” Khan said.

The family has petitioned the Islamabad High Court to block his deportation. Lawyers say the case highlights how thousands of long-term residents fall through legal cracks created by Pakistan’s citizenship, refugee and documentation framework.

LEGAL GREY ZONE

Pakistan does not legally recognize Western-style adoption. Instead, it uses a guardianship system under the 1890 Guardians and Wards Act, aligning with Islamic principles that preserve lineage, so adopted children don’t inherit or change their family name but receive care, education and welfare through court-appointed guardianship.

“Because we don’t have a legal pathway for adoption per se, the adopted child does not get citizenship of the adopting parents automatically,” said Advocate Umer Ijaz Gillani, a legal expert on citizenship.

Years earlier, Khan’s father-in-law had offered to register him as his biological son to obtain identity documents, but Khan refused, calling the move fraudulent. Because Khan later married his father-in-law’s daughter, both he and his wife cannot legally list the same person as their father on official records, leaving them without a lawful workaround.

Marriage offers no certainty either. Pakistan’s Citizenship Act of 1951 grants citizenship to foreign women married to Pakistani men, but is silent on foreign husbands married to Pakistani women.

While higher courts have, at times, ruled in favor of such men, implementation has been inconsistent. In October 2025, the Supreme Court struck down a high court order that had directed authorities to grant citizenship to an Afghan man married to a Pakistani woman.

Even the Pakistan Origin Card (POC), a long-term residency document, remains difficult to secure.

“We have experienced that in the case of especially Afghan men who marry Pakistani women, the government authorities are often reluctant to recognize this right,” Gillani said.

According to submissions made by government officials in court, authorities have received at least 117 applications for nationality from Afghan men married to Pakistani women following directives issued by the Peshawar High Court, reflecting a broader pattern rather than isolated cases.

‘NO RELAXATION’

Officials say the deportation policy allows no exceptions.

“No relaxation has been granted by the government, including for those who’ve married to Pakistani citizens,” said Asmatullah Shah, the chief commissionerate for Afghan refugees.

“If they want to live here, they should go back and apply for a visa and then they can come here with valid documentation.”

Legal experts note that deportation would send Khan to Afghanistan despite having no known relatives there, and that returning legally would require obtaining an Afghan passport and a Pakistani visa, costs far beyond the means of a daily wage laborer.

For Khan’s mother-in-law, Husn Pari, who raised him for decades as her own son, the prospect is devastating.

“When I am not able to meet [Khan] for one day, my day does not pass,” she said. “His own mother, how much pain must she be in?”

For Khan, the fear of deportation echoes the trauma of his childhood.

“Before I was separated from my first mother,” he said. “The second time I will be separated from my second mother. This is very difficult for me.”