ISLAMABAD: Over a week after a catastrophic fire killed at least 73 people at Karachi’s Gul Plaza shopping complex, authorities are grappling with a grim reality: many victims are so badly burned that identifying them has become a forensic ordeal, leaving dozens of families trapped in agonizing uncertainty.
Officials say around 73 sets of human remains have been recovered from the site of the January 17 blaze, but only 23 victims have been formally identified. In many cases, intense heat inside the enclosed commercial building destroyed soft tissue and degraded DNA, reducing bodies to fragments that complicate both recovery and forensic confirmation.
“Unfortunately, in some cases only body remains were recovered, and those remains were in such a condition that when touched they were turning into powder,” said Daniyal Siyal, a spokesperson for the Karachi Metropolitan Corporation.
Globally, fires in densely packed, multi-story commercial buildings are among the most difficult disasters to investigate. Prolonged exposure to extreme temperatures can destroy DNA, collapse reinforced concrete floors and fuse human remains with debris. Even in countries with advanced disaster victim identification systems, such conditions often delay confirmation for weeks or months.
In Pakistan, where urban fires are frequent but forensic disaster response capacity remains limited, those challenges are compounded.
Gul Plaza housed more than 1,200 shops stacked vertically, with narrow stairwells, limited ventilation and heavy electrical loads. Rescue officials say the structure acted like a furnace, trapping heat and toxic gases long after flames were brought under control.
As a result, recovery operations quickly shifted from rescue to retrieval, and from retrieval to painstaking forensic work.
SCIENCE AS THE LAST HOPE
All recovered remains have been transferred to medico-legal facilities, where Karachi Police Surgeon Dr. Summaiya Syed is overseeing the identification process.
Only seven victims have been identified through facial recognition or identity documents recovered from pockets. For most families, science is now the only path to closure.
“The challenges that we are facing here are because of the heat damage that has been done to the body, to the remains,” Dr. Syed told Arab News. “In this instance, it is particularly challenging because the bodies are burnt to the extent that most of the DNA is unsalvageable.”
Forensic teams have collected samples from 45 deceased individuals and 54 reference samples from family members. But when DNA testing fails, a common outcome in prolonged high-temperature fires, investigators must rely on secondary methods.
“We hope that they are identifiable but if they aren’t by DNA, we have the anthropological measurements, anthropological data, CDR records and proof of presence to fall back on,” Dr. Syed said.
Those methods include bone analysis to estimate age and height, mobile phone call detail records placing individuals inside the building, and personal effects recovered from specific locations within the debris.
Earlier this week, a senior official involved in recovery efforts, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the process itself had further complicated identification.
According to the official, heavy excavators operated by untrained workers were used to clear debris, resulting in bags of remains that sometimes contained mismatched limbs. In some instances, the official said, remains counted as a single body weighed only three kilograms.
FAMILIES WAITING WITHOUT CLOSURE
Outside the destroyed plaza and at Karachi’s medico-legal facilities, families of the missing continue to wait after submitting DNA samples.
Rehman Khan, the uncle of 22-year-old victim Muhammad Arif, spent four days at the site of the inferno. He eventually joined rescue teams himself, helping pull nearly 30 sets of remains from the rubble.
He believed one of them was his nephew, but all were beyond recognition.
“Now for the past two or three days, we have been coming here in the morning and sitting here until evening,” Khan said.
“Now if we even get a body, that would be a very big thing. The chances of life itself have ended.”
Among those still unaccounted for is 18-year-old salesman Ibrar Akram, whose family says he died trying to help others escape.
“He was showing them the way,” his cousin Farhan Hafeez told Arab News.
Hafeez, who survived the blaze after escaping from his own shop in the building’s basement, said Akram helped at least four people find an exit before turning back inside.
“He went back inside and did not come back,” he said. “Today, it has been seven days since he went missing. What is the government doing?”
For Akram’s mother, Afsari Begum, the technical explanations offer no relief.
“I don’t want anything. I just want my Ibrar,” she said, her voice breaking down.
Indeed, for families still waiting, the plea has narrowed to one request: dignity.
“Do not give us a body in pieces,” Hafeez said. “Give us our loved one whole, so that we at least know it is ours.”
A fact-finding committee appointed by the Sindh chief minister is investigating the cause of the fire, though its report has not yet been released. Authorities say facilities and resources are available to complete identification.
“We have facilities available here in Karachi, and we also have a DNA laboratory in Hyderabad. There is no issue regarding resources. All necessary resources are available to us,” Siyal said.
