US cuts may close UN schools in Lebanon

The US threatens to cut funding at a time when the UN agency is struggling to cope with crises across the region. (AP)
Updated 31 May 2018
Follow

US cuts may close UN schools in Lebanon

  • The Trump administration announced in January it was slashing its aid to UNRWA
  • Israel accuses UNRWA of perpetuating the conflict by promoting Palestinian claims to a right of return

When the teacher asked the English class how to change a sentence from the active to the passive voice, Sarah’s hand shot up from the front row, and as soon as she was called upon she answered correctly.

The 10-year-old Palestinian girl has come a long way since she arrived in Lebanon after fleeing Syria’s civil war five years ago, and is now a star student at an elementary school run by the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, which also provides trauma counseling.

But those services, and the thousands of children who rely on them, now face an uncertain future, as the US threatens to cut funding at a time when the UN agency is struggling to cope with crises across the region.

Sarah’s family is descended from some of the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians who fled or were expelled from what is now Israel during the 1948 war surrounding its creation. The refugees and their descendants now number more than 5 million, and mostly reside in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria.

Sarah’s family, who asked that their last name not be published because of safety concerns, became refugees a second time when they fled their Damascus home after it was hit by a rocket in 2013.

In Lebanon, they enrolled Sarah at Jafna Elementary School, which is operated by United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA), the oldest and largest UN relief program in the Middle East. The agency provides health care, education and social services to millions of refugees, including those displaced a second time by the Syrian civil war and other regional unrest.

The Trump administration announced in January it was slashing its aid to UNRWA, withholding $65 million of a planned $125 million funding installment. It released $60 million so the agency would not shut down, but made clear that additional US support would be contingent on major reforms at the agency.

Israel accuses UNRWA of perpetuating the conflict by promoting Palestinian claims to a right of return, while US President Donald Trump has blamed the Palestinians for the lack of progress in Mideast peace efforts.

Other countries responded by pledging $100 million in new funding this year, but UNRWA still faces a $350 million shortfall.

“If the financial crisis continues, there are no guarantees that we will be able to start next year’s school year,” said Salem Dib, UNRWA’s chief education program officer in Lebanon. “There are dangers regarding continuity of education for all Palestinian refugees, whether they are from Lebanon or from Syria.”

Some 36,000 students, including nearly 5,500 who were displaced from Syria, are studying at 66 UNRWA schools in Lebanon. Dib said it is difficult for Palestinians to enroll in public schools, which are already overcrowded with Syrian refugees.

Last month, international donors pledged an estimated $4.4 billion in humanitarian aid for Syria and neighboring countries in 2018, falling significantly short of the more than $7 billion the UN is seeking.

At the same time, refugees in Lebanon face growing hostility from political parties that support the Syrian government, which made gains in Lebanese parliamentary elections earlier this month and have called for the Syrian refugees to return home.

Sarah’s parents hope their daughter can get a scholarship to study outside Lebanon, allowing the family of five to move somewhere safer. “If my children leave school they’ll be lost,” her mother Fatima said.

The family recounted their ordeal from the tent they share in Lebanon’s eastern Bekaa Valley.

Sarah recalled the harrowing day of shelling in Damascus, when she and her younger brothers took shelter on the first floor. One of the shells exploded nearby, covering everyone in dust.

“When I saw my wife and children covered with dust and shaking, I told myself we have to leave,” her father Ghadir said.

The family found relative safety in Lebanon, but little else. They rely on UN assistance, and Ghadir gets occasional work at a nearby restaurant. At one point he set up a stand on the side of the road to sell corn, but he abandoned it when Lebanese security forces stormed the area, fearing he would be caught without a work permit.

Despite everything she has been through, Sarah is excelling in school. She loves learning English and dreams of being a cardiologist.

Samah Khalil, who provides counseling to students at the school, says many of the children suffer from trauma that makes it difficult for them to study or interact with others — but Sarah was able to recover quickly.

“Sarah is a special student, she is the best in her class and she is loved by her classmates,” she said. “She is great in every aspect.”

Mary Joy Pigozzi, the executive director of Educate A Child, which provides psychological counseling in the UNRWA schools, says EAC has worked hard to foster the skills that young people need to become future leaders.

“Like Sarah, some of these children have had to overcome many difficult situations, which makes it even more important that we prioritize their educational opportunities,” she said. “Access to quality education is a human right.”


LA residents are still battling toxic hazards a year after historic wildfires

Updated 13 sec ago
Follow

LA residents are still battling toxic hazards a year after historic wildfires

  • People whose homes were left standing are still living with the hazards, including new trauma for those afraid of what still lurks inside
  • A crowdsourced data effort by Altadena residents has found many homes still standing remain unsafe
ALTADENA: “DANGER: Lead Work Area” reads a sign on a front door of an Altadena home. “May damage fertility or the unborn child. Causes damage to the central nervous system.”
Block after block there are reminders that contaminants still linger.
House cleaners, hazardous waste workers and homeowners alike come and go wearing masks, respirators, gloves and hazmat suits as they wipe, vacuum and power-wash homes that weren’t burnt to ash.
It’s been a year of heartbreak and worry since the most destructive wildfires in the Los Angeles area’s history scorched neighborhoods and displaced tens of thousands of people. Two wind-whipped blazes that ignited on Jan. 7, 2025, killed at least 31 people and destroyed nearly 17,000 structures, including homes, schools, businesses and places of worship. Rebuilding will take years.
The disaster has brought another wave of trauma for people afraid of what still lurks inside their homes.
Indoor air quality after wildfires remains understudied, and scientists still don’t know the long-term health impacts of exposure to massive urban fires like last year’s in Los Angeles. But some chemicals released are known to be linked to heart disease and lung issues, and exposure to minerals like magnetite has been associated with Alzheimer’s disease.
Ash in the area is a toxic soup of incinerated cars, electronics, paints, furniture and every other kind of personal belonging. It can contain pesticides, asbestos, plastics, lead or other heavy metals.
Many with homes still standing are now living with the hazards left by the fires.
People forced back into their Altadena homes
Nina and Billy Malone considered their home of 20 years a safe haven before smoke, ash and soot seeped inside, leaving behind harmful levels of lead even after professional cleaning. Recent testing found the toxin is still on the wooden floors of their living room and bedroom.
They were forced to move back home in August anyway, after insurance cut off their rental assistance.
Since then, Nina wakes up almost daily with a sore throat and headaches. Billy had to get an inhaler for his worsening wheezing and congestion. And their bedroom, Nina said, smells “like an ashtray has been sitting around for a long time.” She worries most about exposure to unregulated contaminants that insurance companies aren’t required to test.
“I don’t feel comfortable in the space,” said Nina, whose neighbors’ homes burned down across the street.
They’re not alone.
Data shows dangerous lead levels still in homes
According to a report released in November by the Eaton Fire Residents United, a volunteer group formed by residents, six out of 10 homes damaged from smoke from the Eaton Fire still have dangerous levels of cancer-causing asbestos, brain-damaging lead or both. That’s based on self-submitted data from 50 homeowners who have cleaned their homes, with 78 percent hiring professional cleaners.
Of the 50 homes, 63 percent have lead levels above the Environmental Protection Agency’s standard, according to the report. The average lead levels were almost 60 times higher than the EPA’s rule.
Even after fires were extinguished, volatile organic compounds from smoke, some known to cause cancer, lingered inside of people’s homes, according to a recent study. To mitigate these risks, residents returning home should ventilate and filter indoor air by opening windows or running high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) purifiers with charcoal filters.
Zoe Gonzalez Izquierdo said she can’t get her insurance company to pay for an adequate cleanup of her family’s Altadena home, which tested positive for dangerous levels of lead and other toxic compounds.
“They can’t just send a company that’s not certified to just wipe things down so that then we can go back to a still contaminated home,” Gonzalez said, who has children ages 2 and 4.
Experts believe the lead, which can linger in dust on floors and windowsills, comes from burned lead paint. The University of Southern California reported that more than 70 percent of homes within the Eaton Fire were built before 1979, when lead paint was common.
“For individuals that are pregnant, for young children, it’s particularly important that we do everything we can to eliminate exposure to lead,” said pediatrician Dr. Lisa Patel, executive director for the Medical Society Consortium on Climate and Health and a member of the climate group Science Moms.
The same goes for asbestos, she added, because there is no safe level of exposure.
‘We have to live in the scar’
People who lived in the Pacific Palisades, which was also scorched, face similar challenges.
Residents are at the mercy of their insurance companies, who decide on what they cover and how much. It’s a grueling, constant battle for many. The state’s insurer of last resort, known as the California Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan, has been scrutinized for years over its handling of fire damage claims.
Homeowners want state agencies to enforce a requirement that insurance companies return a property to pre-fire condition.
Julie Lawson won’t take any risks. Her family paid about $7,000 out of pocket to test the soil in their Altadena home, even though their insurance company had already agreed to pay to replace the grass in their front yard. They planned to test for contaminants again once they finished remediating the inside, the process of making a home contaminant-free after a fire. If insurance won’t cover it, they’ll pay for it themselves.
Even if their home is livable again, they still face other losses — including equity and the community they once had.
“We have to live in the scar,” she said. “We’re all still really struggling.”
They will be living in a construction zone for years. “This isn’t over for us.”
Challenges and mental health toll
Annie Barbor with the nonprofit United Policyholders has been helping people navigate the challenges, which include insurance companies resisting to pay for contamination testing and industrial hygienists disagreeing on what to test for.
She sees the mental health toll it’s having on people — and as a survivor herself of the 2017 Tubbs Fire in Northern California, she understands it.
Many were at first joyful to see their houses still standing.
“But they’ve been in their own special kind of hell ever since,” Barbor said.
Now residents like the Malones are inspecting their belongings, one by one, fearing they may have absorbed toxins.
Boxes, bags and bins stuffed with clothes, chinaware and everything in between fill the couple’s car, basement, garage and home.
They have been painstakingly going through their things, assessing what they think can be adequately cleaned. In the process, Nina is cleaning cabinets, drawers, floors and still finding soot and ash. She wears gloves and a respirator, or sometimes just an N-95 mask.
Their insurance won’t pay to retest their home, Billy said, so they’re considering paying the $10,000 themselves. And if results show there’s still contamination, their insurance company told them they will only pay to clean up toxins that are federally regulated, like lead and asbestos.
“I don’t know how you fight that,” said Nina, who is considering therapy to cope with her anxiety. “How do you find that argument to compel an insurance company to pay for something to make yourself safe?”