Book review: Revolution through the eyes of a hesitant change-maker

Donia Kamal’s writing is even-tempered and her narrative is rooted in history, making for a captivating read. (Photo supplied)
Updated 30 May 2018
Follow

Book review: Revolution through the eyes of a hesitant change-maker

  • “Cigarette Number Seven” by Donia Kamal is a carefully paced novel about a young woman whose life has revolved around a non-traditional upbringing
  • Kamal’s writing is even-tempered and her narrative is rooted in history, making for a captivating read.

CHICAGO: “Cigarette Number Seven” by Donia Kamal is a carefully paced novel about a young woman whose life has revolved around a non-traditional upbringing that has led her to the edge of the Egyptian revolution in Cairo. Joining in with the sit-ins at Tahrir Square and taking care of her father, Nadia’s life crescendos and decrescendos from significance into apathy as she looks back at everything that has brought her to this point in life.

Author Donia Kamal is a novelist and producer. She has an extensive history of producing documentaries and television shows in the Middle East. “Cigarette Number Seven” is her second novel, which was first published in Arabic by Dar Merit in 2012. The novel was translated into English by Nariman Youssef, who translates fiction, poetry, song lyrics, and even the 2012 Egyptian constitution draft, and published in 2018 by Hoopoe, an imprint of the American University in Cairo Press.

Kamal’s narrator, Nadia, remembers small details of her past, but never the full picture. She remembers Umm Kulthum playing on the radio while her grandmother cooks in a fifth-floor apartment. Nadia remembers the smell of coffee brewing, onions being cut and garlic being peeled, but not much about anything else, least of all her mother who leaves her in her grandparents’ care when she moves to the Gulf to find work.

Nadia moves in with her activist father after her grandmother dies and it is with him that her life begins to take shape. Thus begins her time as a revolutionary. Although Nadia feels conscious, convinced her voice is too thin to appeal to anyone, she marches with her father and friends.
Kamal’s book offers an individual perspective of the Egyptian revolution. Through her main character, Nadia, and her father, Kamal is able to pinpoint what it is in ordinary people’s lives that brought them out to protest and demonstrate. Kamal reveals how the zealous atmosphere helps to keep them motivated. Even after violent encounters, there is a collective spirit that cannot be broken, as Kamal writes: “Still, the spirit of the square was like a magic balm over these wounds. The square was mighty and clear. It had power and influence and spirit… With unbelievable continuity it pushed us to carry through what we were doing.”
Kamal’s writing is even-tempered and her narrative is rooted in history, making for a captivating read.


What We Are Reading Today: ‘The Bell Jar’

Photo/Supplied
Updated 20 December 2025
Follow

What We Are Reading Today: ‘The Bell Jar’

  • The bell jar — clear, enclosing, and distorting the air she breathes — becomes the perfect image of Greenwood’s entrapment. Just as telling is the fig tree she imagines, with each fig representing a possible future: writer, traveler, mother, lover

Author: Sylvia Plath

Sylvia Plath’s “The Bell Jar” (1963) is a raw and luminous portrait of a young woman standing at the edge of adulthood, grappling with ambition, doubt, and the suffocating weight of expectation. 

Through the eyes of the novel’s troubled protagonist Esther Greenwood, Plath reveals the loneliness that can lie hidden beneath achievement and the unease brought on by future expectations.  

The novel opens in New York, where Greenwood’s magazine internship seems the gateway to success. Yet the city’s glamor soon feels hollow, and the confidence around her thin and brittle. 

Her sense of direction begins to fade, and the life laid out before her starts to feel both too small and impossibly distant.  

The bell jar — clear, enclosing, and distorting the air she breathes — becomes the perfect image of Greenwood’s entrapment. Just as telling is the fig tree she imagines, with each fig representing a possible future: writer, traveler, mother, lover. 

Torn between these possibilities, she hesitates until the figs shrivel and drop. This image, perhaps more than any other, reveals how fear of choice can quietly undo a person.   

Plath’s writing is sharp and deeply humane. She exposes the subtle pressures shaping women’s lives at that time without sentiment or complaint. 

The narrative’s erratic rhythm mirrors the character’s disoriented state of mind, where thought and memory blur at the edges. 

“The Bell Jar” speaks to anyone who has felt caught between possibility and paralysis, between who they are and who they are expected to be. 

Plath writes with precision and compassion, turning confusion into clarity and despair into something almost inspiring.