Pakistan’s top court reserves verdict on petition against changes to accountability laws

Pakistan's frontier constabulary personnel stand guard at the entrance of National Accountability Bureau (NAB) court, during the case hearing of former Pakistan's prime minister Imran Khan, in Islamabad, Pakistan, on May 23, 2023. (Photo courtesy: AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 05 September 2023
Follow

Pakistan’s top court reserves verdict on petition against changes to accountability laws

  • Ex-PM Khan challenged amendments in top court last year, saying they provided benefit to influential persons
  • Changes made to accountability laws last year restrict NAB from acting on federal, provincial or local tax matters

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court of Pakistan on Tuesday reserved its verdict on former prime minister Imran Khan’s petition against amendments made to Pakistan’s accountability laws last year, local media widely reported. 

The NAB (Second Amendment) Bill 2021, passed by both houses of parliament in May 2022, states that all “pending inquiries, investigations, trials or proceedings under this ordinance, relating to persons or transactions... shall stand transferred to the authorities, departments and courts concerned under the respective laws.”

It also restricts the country’s anti-corruption watchdog, the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) from acting on federal, provincial or local tax matters and removes regulatory bodies from NAB’s domain. The bill reduces the four-year term of the NAB chairman and prosecutor-general to three years, sets a three-year term for judges of accountability courts, and makes it mandatory for them to decide a case within a year.

On June 25, 2022, Khan moved the Supreme Court against the NAB (Second Amendment) Bill 2021. Khan’s petition said the amendments were made to benefit influential accused persons and legitimize corruption, adding that the amendments were tantamount to “depriving the citizens of Pakistan of having access to law.”

A three-member bench of the apex court, comprising Chief Justice Umar Ata Bandial, Justice Ijazul Ahsan and Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah, heard Khan’s petition on Tuesday. During the hearing, the chief justice inquired whether there were any sections in the amendments according to which the cases could be transferred to another relevant forum. 

“After these amendments, a lot of the National Accountability Bureau’s work has come to an end,” Justice Bandial said, according to Pakistan’s English language newspaper Dawn, after he was told by Khan’s lawyer Khawaja Haris that a lot of pending NAB cases have returned after the amendments. 

Haris said that as per the amendments, an investigation would be conducted, after the review of which the cases could be sent to other forums. Khan’s counsel also informed the court that after changes to the law, neither did NAB have the authority to deal with the cases nor to send them to other relevant forums.

“After the amendments, the pending investigations and inquiries have gone to the mortuary,” Justice Ahsan was quoted as saying by Dawn. “Till the mechanism for the transfer of inquiries is formed, the public’s rights will be directly affected.”

The chief justice said toward the end of the hearing that ensuring the public prospers and is secure is the state’s responsibility. “We will soon announce a short and sweet verdict of the case,” Justice Bandial said, according to Dawn. 


Pakistan police ‘water-cannoned’ Imran Khan’s sisters during sit-in outside prison — party 

Updated 7 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan police ‘water-cannoned’ Imran Khan’s sisters during sit-in outside prison — party 

  • Former senator on the scene says police fired water cannon three times at protesters outside Adiala Jail
  • Police have yet to issue an official response, declined immediate comment when contacted by Arab News

ISLAMABAD: Pakistani opposition party, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), on Wednesday accused police of using a water cannon in freezing temperatures to disperse supporters and the three sisters of former prime minister Imran Khan who were holding an overnight sit-in outside the Adiala high-security prison to demand a meeting with him.

Khan, a former cricket star who became prime minister in 2018, has been in jail since 2023 on multiple charges ranging from corruption to terrorism. He denies wrongdoing, saying the cases are politically motivated to keep him out of politics. 

Last week, Information Minister Attaullah Tarar announced a complete ban on all meetings with Khan at Adiala Jail, calling him an “extremist consumed by war hysteria.” Even before the ban, the PTI had repeatedly claimed Khan was being denied regular meetings with lawyers and family despite court rulings allowing visitation. 

Videos circulating widely on social media on Tuesday late night and Wednesday morning showed a small crowd, including Khan’s sisters Aleema and Uzma, running as jets of water were fired from a police vehicle outside the prison complex in the city of Rawalpindi, near Islamabad. Police have yet to issue an official response and declined immediate comment when contacted by Arab News.

“Pakistani authorities used water cannons to disperse Imran Khan’s sisters and peaceful PTI workers outside Adiala Jail, despite a court order allowing a meeting with the jailed former PM,” PTI wrote on X, calling the action a violation of “basic human rights and freedom of assembly in freezing weather!”

Former senator Mushtaq Ahmad, who is not a PTI member but says he went to support the protest, told Arab News he witnessed the water cannon deployed three times against roughly 100–150 demonstrators.

“The water cannon was directed at three sisters of Imran Khan who were there to demand their meeting with their incarcerated brother order of Islamabad high court. One sister fell down on slippery ground after that,” Ahmad said.

He added that he had been stopped repeatedly at checkpoints on the way to the prison and had to take alternative routes to reach the sit-in.

Khan has remained a dominant political figure even from behind bars, drawing large crowds and online support. His party insists he is being punished for challenging Pakistan’s military establishment, an accusation the army denies. Last week, military spokesperson Lt. Gen. Ahmed Sharif Chaudhry said Khan’s narrative had become a “national security threat,” warning the party against dragging the armed forces into political disputes.

PTI has held repeated demonstrations demanding Khan’s release since his arrest in 2023, several of which have ended in confrontation with police and casualties on both sides. 

Last week, Information Minister Tarar, as he announced a ban on meetings with Khan in prison, said the government would take “swift and firm” action against anyone attempting to create unrest outside the prison:

“It is now time to restore the writ of the state. There will be no jail meetings, nor will gatherings be allowed.”