Tory peer gets flak for letter to BBC asking if Pakistani staff behind Modi film

People watch the BBC documentary "India: The Modi Question", on a screen installed at the Marine Drive junction under the direction of the district Congress committee, in Kochi on January 24, 2023. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 31 January 2023
Follow

Tory peer gets flak for letter to BBC asking if Pakistani staff behind Modi film

  • The BBC documentary alleges then CM Modi had ordered police to turn a blind eye to 2002 Gujarat riots 
  • BBC defends journalists, says the film was ‘rigorously researched according to highest editorial standards’ 

ISLAMABAD: Rami Ranger, a Conservative peer, has been accused of writing a “racially charged” letter to the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), asking if the broadcaster’s Pakistani staffers were behind its recent documentary about Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s leadership during the 2002 riots in the Indian state of Gujarat, The Guardian reported on Monday. 

Ranger hit out at the documentary, titled “India: The Modi Question,” that has caused significant controversy in India and been banned by Indian authorities over the depiction of Modi’s role in the 2002 riots that killed at least 1,000 people, mostly Muslims. 

Lord Ranger, who is already under investigation by the standards commissioners in the House, wrote to the BBC director general, Tim Davie, to complain about the film and demanded to know “if your Pakistani-origin staff were behind this nonsense,” according to The Guardian report. 

In response to Ranger’s scathing attack on the BBC, Chris Elmore, Labour’s vice-chair, said it was unacceptable for the Tory peer to “put pressure on the BBC in this way” and called his comments about Pakistani journalists “racially charged” and “deplorable,” demanding an explanation from UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak. 

“What he is doing about the scandal and sleaze engulfing his party from all angles and how this meets his promise of integrity, professionalism and accountability,” The Guardian quoted Elmore as asking PM Sunak. 

The two-part BBC program alleges that Modi had ordered police to turn a blind eye to deadly riots while he was chief minister of the Gujarat state. 

Modi, who aims for a third term in elections next year, has been haunted for decades by allegations of complicity in the violence. He has previously denied accusations that he failed to stop the rioting, and in 2013 an Indian supreme court panel said there was insufficient evidence to prosecute him. 

The BBC said it had yet to receive Ranger’s letter, but the broadcaster defended the journalists behind the documentary on Modi. 

The film was “rigorously researched according to highest editorial standards” and the corporation was “committed to highlighting important issues from around the world,” a BBC spokesperson said. 

“A wide range of voices, witnesses and experts were approached, and we have featured a range of opinions – this includes responses from people in the BJP [Modi’s Bharatiya Janata party],” the BBC spokesperson was quoted as saying. 

“We offered the Indian government a right to reply to the matters raised in the series – it declined to respond.” 


Pakistan, three European states agree joint strategy to curb illegal migration

Updated 5 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan, three European states agree joint strategy to curb illegal migration

  • Pakistan, Italy, Spain and Greece agree to expand legal migration pathways
  • European Union to support Pakistan’s enforcement and institutional capacity

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan, Italy, Spain and Greece have agreed to adopt a coordinated strategy to curb illegal migration while expanding legal pathways, an official statement said on Thursday, as Islamabad seeks to consolidate a crackdown it says has already reduced irregular migration to Europe by 47 percent.

The development comes during Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s visit to Italy where he attended a four-nation conference in Rome with his counterparts from the three European states focused on tackling human smuggling networks and regulating migration flows.

Pakistan stepped up its enforcement drive in 2023 after hundreds of migrants, including many Pakistanis, drowned in a shipwreck off Pylos in one of the Mediterranean’s deadliest disasters.

Since then, authorities say they have intensified airport screening, arrested more than 1,700 suspected human smugglers and launched technology-driven systems to detect forged travel documents.

“Pakistan, Italy, Spain and Greece agreed to adopt a coordinated strategy to curb illegal immigration at all levels,” the interior ministry said in a statement.

“The three countries agreed with the Pakistani interior minister’s proposal to curb illegal immigration through legal pathways,” it added.

The ministry said all three European states decided to provide full support to Pakistan to enhance its capacity under the European Union framework.

Naqvi also met Greek Migration and Asylum Minister Athanasios Plevris, with both officials agreeing to finalize a Migration Cooperation Agreement and to establish a joint working group to improve coordination.

He also welcomed support from Greece in developing and strengthening the skills of Pakistani police and paramilitary forces in technology-based operations.

The statement said the four countries agreed to further strengthen a joint rapid response mechanism and decided to hold the next quadrilateral meeting later this year.

A decision was also taken to repatriate criminals involved in serious crimes from Europe to Pakistan for legal action, according to the ministry.

Pakistan has said European ministers acknowledged a 47 percent drop in illegal migration in 2025 following its expanded crackdown.

Last December, Pakistan announced plans to roll out an artificial intelligence-based immigration screening system in Islamabad, and in September the Federal Investigation Agency released a list of more than 100 “most wanted” human smugglers while identifying major trafficking hubs.