Hamza Shahbaz retains Punjab CM's post, opposition PTI to challenge result in court

Hamza Shahbaz waves to supporters outside a court in Lahore, Pakistan, on June 11, 2019. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 22 July 2022
Follow

Hamza Shahbaz retains Punjab CM's post, opposition PTI to challenge result in court

  • Deputy Speaker rejects ten votes polled for opposition's candidate for violating the party directions
  • PTI announces challenging the election in Supreme Court as legal experts differ with deputy speaker

ISLAMABAD: Hamza Shahbaz, son of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, on Friday managed to retain the coveted slot of Punjab chief minister, with the opposition Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party announcing it would challenge the election result in the Supreme Court of Pakistan.  

Hours of drama followed the crucial election for the chief minister of the country’s most populous province on Friday, which was held on the directions of Supreme Court of Pakistan after 25 members of the opposition PTI were disqualified for voting for the rival Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) candidate, Shahbaz, in violation of party directives.  

In Friday's election, the opposition alliance, comprising former Prime Minister Imran Khan’s PTI and the PML-Q parties, bagged 186 votes and the PML-N-led ruling coalition secured 179 votes in the provincial house of 371.  

But in a shock move, PML-Q chief Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain sent a letter to Deputy Speaker Dost Muhammad Mazari, in which he had directed PML-Q members to vote for Shahbaz, instead of his cousin brother and opposition's nominee, Chaudhry Pervaiz Elahi.   

The deputy speaker read out the letter and announced the ten votes cast by PML-Q members had been rejected in light of Hussain's declaration and the Supreme Court's ruling.  

"I, hereby, disregard the votes of Pakistan Muslim League [Quaid] polled in favour of Chaudhry Pervaiz Elahi," Deputy Speaker Mazari announced.   

The announcement came as a shock to the PML-Q and Khan's PTI party, which had defeated the ruling PML-N in Sunday’s by-elections and won 15 out of 20 Punjab Assembly seats. The other five members disqualified by the election commission had been elected on reserved seats for women and minorities. 

Asad Umar, a senior PTI member, said his party would file a petition against the election result in apex court tonight. 

"The entire nation has its sights on the Supreme Court whether the door of justice would open tonight or not," Umar said on Twitter.

 

 

PTI lawmaker Muhammad Basharat Raja strongly objected to the deputy speaker’s ruling, giving references of Article 63-A of the constitution. He said the parliamentary party leader was the only authorized person to issue directions to his party lawmakers about the vote.   

Raja said PML-Q chief Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain had “no legal authority to issue directions,” but the deputy speaker rejected his argument and said “you may challenge it in the court.”   

According to Article 63-A of the constitution, a parliamentarian can be disqualified on grounds of defection if he or she “votes or abstains from voting in the House contrary to any direction issued by the parliamentary party to which he belongs, in relation to election of the prime minister or chief minister; or a vote of confidence or a vote of no-confidence; or a money bill or a Constitution (amendment) bill.”     

In a unanimous decision in May, ECP members said the PTI dissidents were being de-seated for defecting from the party under Article 63-A of the constitution. The Supreme Court of Pakistan, in its interpretation of Article 63-A, has said votes cast against the party direction “cannot be counted and must be disregarded.”     

The PTI has announced moving the Supreme Court against the deputy speaker’s ruling, describing it as “unconstitutional” and hoping it would be overturned.   

PTI Senator Ali Zafar said it was the mandate of the parliamentary party head and not the party chief to decide about the vote of lawmakers in the house. “The constitution is very clear and the decision of the parliamentary party is supreme with respect to vote in the house,” he told Arab News.  

Barrister Ahmed Pansota said the lawmakers were bound to follow directions of the parliamentary party head, which was done in the PML-Q's case in Friday's election.   

“The Supreme Court has already ruled on these issues and if this matter goes to the apex court for adjudication, I believe the PTI-backed candidate will be declared winner in the chief minister’s election,” he said. 


Pakistan puts border districts on high alert amid Iran protests — official

Updated 6 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan puts border districts on high alert amid Iran protests — official

  • The development comes as Iranian authorities try to suppress protests over faltering economy, with over 2,600 killed
  • Militancy in Balochistan has declined following the return of nearly 1 million Afghans, the additional chief secretary says

QUETTA: Pakistan has heightened security along districts bordering Iran as violent protests continue to engulf several Iranian cities, a top official in Pakistan’s southwestern Balochistan province said on Thursday, with authorities stepping up vigilance to guard against potential spillover.

The development comes as Iranian authorities try to suppress protests, which began late last month over the country’s faltering economy and the collapse of its currency, with more than 2,600 killed in weeks of violence in the Islamic republic.

The clampdown on demonstrations, the worst since the country’s 1979 Islamic revolution, has drawn threats from the United States (US) of a military intervention on behalf of the protesters, raising fears of further tensions in an already volatile region.

Pakistan, which shares a 909-kilometer-long border with Iran in its southwest, has said that it is closely monitoring the situation in the neighboring country and advised its citizens to keep essential travel documents with them amid the unrest.

“The federal government is monitoring the situation regarding what is happening in Iran and the provincial government is in touch with the federal government,” Hamza Shafqaat, an additional chief secretary at the Balochistan Home Department, told

Arab News in an exclusive interview on Thursday.

“As far as the law and order is concerned in all bordering districts with Iran, we are on high alert and as of now, the situation is very normal and peaceful at the border.”

Asked whether Islamabad had suspended cross-border movement and trade with Iran, Shafqaat said trade was ongoing, but movement of tourists and pilgrims had been stopped.

“There were few students stuck in Iran, they were evacuated, and they reached Gwadar,” he said. “Around 200 students are being shifted to their home districts.”

SITUATION ON PAKISTAN-AFGHANISTAN BORDER

Pakistan’s Balochistan province has long been the site of an insurgency by ethnic Baloch separatists and religiously motivated groups like the Tehreek e Taliban Pakistan (TTP). Besides Iran, the province shares more around 1,000-kilometer porous border with Afghanistan.

Islamabad has frequently accused Afghanistan of allowing its soil for attacks against Pakistan, an allegation denied by Kabul. In Oct., Pakistan and Afghanistan engaged in worst border clashes in decades over a surge in militancy in Pakistan. While the neighbors agreed to a ceasefire in Doha that month, relations between them remain tensed.

Asked about the government’s measures to secure the border with Afghanistan, Shafqaat said militancy in the region had declined following the return of nearly 1 million Afghan nationals as part of a repatriation drive Islamabad announced in late 2023.

“There is news that some of them keep on coming back from one border post or some other areas because we share a porous border and it is very difficult to man every inch of this border,” he said.

“On any intervention from the Afghanistan side, our security agencies which are deputed at the border are taking daily actions.”

LAW AND ORDER CHALLENGE

Balochistan witnessed 167 bomb blasts among over 900 militant attacks in 2025, which killed more than 400 people, according to the provincial government’s annual law and order report. But officials say the law-and-order situation had improved as compared to the previous year.

“More than 720 terrorists were killed in 2025 which is a higher number of operations against terrorists in many decades, while over a hundred terrorists were detained by law enforcement agencies in 90,000-plus security operations in Balochistan,” Shafqaat said.

The provincial government often suspended mobile Internet service in the southwestern province on various occasions last year, aimed at ensuring security in Balochistan.

“With that step, I am sure we were able to secure hundreds of lives,” Shafqaat said, adding it was only suspended in certain areas for less than 25 days last year.

“The Internet service through wireless routers remained open for the people in the entire year, we closed mobile Internet only for people on the roads because the government understands the difficulties of students and business community hence we are trying to reduce the closure of mobile Internet.”