Turkey’s new amnesty law excludes dissident journalists and politicians 

Police officers walk along a deserted street during a two-day curfew to prevent the spread of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Istanbul. (Reuters)
Short Url
Updated 15 April 2020
Follow

Turkey’s new amnesty law excludes dissident journalists and politicians 

  • Move to fight coronavirus in overpopulated prisons criticized for political bias

ANKARA: The Turkish parliament ratified a controversial bill on Monday night to fight against overpopulation in prisons amid the coronavirus outbreak.

However, the law, prepared by the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) and its nationalistic coalition ally MHP, has been criticized for reducing the sentences of tens of thousands of prisoners and releasing mafia leaders, while dissident journalists and human rights activists, lawyers and politicians will remain behind bars. 
The law will reduce sentences for inmates, except for those jailed on charges related to terrorism, violence against women and children, and sexual abuse. Some inmates over 65 and women with children below the age of six, as well as sick prisoners who cannot take care of themselves, will be subject to home confinement.
Up to 100,000 prisoners are expected to be released. The release of mafia leaders and reduction of their sentences were among key MHP requests during negotiations over the bill, considering the nationalistic roots of many imprisoned “godfathers” in Turkey.
Faik Oztrak, spokesperson for the main opposition party, said: “You keep journalists in prisons, you release the thieves. This is clearly political opportunism. Those who accept bribes will be freed; those who report bribery will go to jail.”

The law is against the principle of equality in the constitution. It is unlikely to boost the feeling of justice in the society considering tens of thousands of political prisoners remain in jail just for speaking out in a peaceful way.

Ahmet Ozmen, Prominent lawyer

Former co-leaders of the pro-Kurdish party HDP, Selahattin Demirtas and Figen Yuksekdag, along with several deputies of the party, remain in prison.
Lawyer Ahmet Ozmen, former head of the Diyarbakir Bar Association, said that the amendments did not meet the expectations of human rights activists.
“It is against the principle of equality in the constitution. It is unlikely to boost the feeling of justice in the society considering tens of thousands of political prisoners remain in jail just for speaking out in a peaceful way,” he told Arab News.

HIGHLIGHTS

• The new amnesty law has been criticized for reducing the sentences of tens of thousands of prisoners and releasing mafia leaders, while dissident journalists and human rights activists, lawyers and politicians will remain behind bars.  

• Following the failed coup in 2016, the number of prisoners rose to about 300,000. According to data from the Council of Europe, Turkey has the second largest prison population in Europe.

Some 50,000 people convicted or jailed pending trial over terror-related charges are excluded from the scope of the legislation.
So far, 17 prisoners in five prisons have contracted COVID-19 and three prisoners in open prisons have died. The bill comes amid fears that the epidemic could spread across the prison population. 
“Whilst any steps to reduce the chronic overcrowding in Turkey’s prisons are welcome, it is deeply disappointing that the tens of thousands of prisoners in pretrial detention — a measure that must only be used when there are no alternatives to custody — will not be considered for release,” said Amnesty International’s Turkey Campaigner, Milena Buyum.
“Those convicted in unfair trials under Turkey’s overly broad anti-terrorism laws are also now condemned to face the prospect of infection from this deadly disease,” she said.
There are about 282,000 prisoners in 355 prisons, while about 37,000 are jailed on terrorism charges, according to official statistics. The Journalists’ Union of Turkey says there are 85 journalists in prison.
“Excluding Turkish journalists, already jailed on baseless charges, from prison release amid COVID-19 is a cruel and needless threat to their health and lives. The IPI reiterates our call for immediate release of all journalists,” the International Press Institute (IPI) said.
Following the failed coup in 2016, the number of prisoners rose to about 300,000. According to data from the Council of Europe, Turkey has the second largest prison population in Europe and the most overcrowded prison system.


New poll shows only 6% of Arabs accept recognizing Israel

Updated 19 sec ago
Follow

New poll shows only 6% of Arabs accept recognizing Israel

  • Reasons ‘mainly linked to its colonial, racist, and expansionist nature’
  • More than 40,000 people in 15 Arab countries surveyed on wide range of issues

CHICAGO: Eighty-seven percent of citizens in the Arab world oppose recognition of Israel while only 6 percent accept it, according to a new survey by the Arab Center Washington DC.

The 2025 Arab Opinion Index, conducted nine times since 2011, surveyed more than 40,000 people in 15 Arab countries on a wide range of issues including politics, economy and identity. 

“An overwhelming majority … oppose recognition of Israel,” Tamara Kharroub, deputy executive director and senior fellow at the ACW, said during a live webinar on Tuesday attended by Arab News.

That finding has been consistent and within range in every poll conducted since 2014, according to the center’s polling data.

The 15 countries surveyed are Algeria, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Libya, Mauritania, Morocco, Palestine, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Syria and Tunisia. 

The highest rates of opposition to recognizing Israel were recorded in Libya (96 percent), Jordan (95 percent), Kuwait (94 percent) and Palestine (91 percent).

A conclusion cited in the poll said: “Those who opposed recognizing Israel cited various factors, mainly linked to its colonial, racist, and expansionist nature and its continued occupation of Palestinian territory. Cultural or religious explanations were largely absent.

“The reasons cited by respondents clearly indicated that their position on recognizing Israel is not likely to change as long as its colonial nature persists.”

Kharroub said the number that accept recognition of Israel “dropped by 2 percentage points in the 2025 Arab Opinion Index, compared to the 2022 survey.”

She added of those 6 percent, “half made such a move conditional on the formation of an independent Palestinian state.”

Yousef Munayyer, ACW’s head of the Palestine / Israel Program and senior fellow, said: “Israel continues to be widely perceived as a threat and not a partner. This is something that has only been escalated in recent years.”

He added: “Normalization lacks popular legitimacy, not just because of the lack of support for it among Arab public opinion, but also because the threat perception in the region has changed significantly over the last several years, and that’s perhaps one of the most important developments since the genocide in Gaza began.”

Seventy percent oppose a peace deal between Syria and Israel that does not include the return of the Syrian Golan Heights.

Other findings include the broader public view that despite different nationalities, 76 percent of respondents see the Arab world as being a “single nation” or an “Arab nation.”

The full survey report can be viewed at www.ArabCenterDC.org.