Daesh frustrates aid effort in northwest Syria

Syrian children queue to receive food distributed by aid workers at a makeshift camp north of Aleppo. (AFP/File)
Updated 07 May 2019
Follow

Daesh frustrates aid effort in northwest Syria

  • Around 2.7 million of its roughly 3 million residents need humanitarian assistance, according to the UN

BEIRUT: Threats, interference and aid deliveries in jeopardy — relief workers say Daesh terrorists are adding to the huge challenges they face in violence-plagued northwest Syria where a fragile cease-fire is at risk.

The Idlib region, controlled by a former Al-Qaeda affiliate, is one of the last areas of the country that the Bashar Assad regime has yet to recapture.

Around 2.7 million of its roughly 3 million residents need humanitarian assistance, according to the UN.

Most rely heavily on food, medicine and other aid brought across from Turkey by the UN and charity groups.

But efforts by the “de-facto authorities” in Idlib “to tamper with, impede or frustrate the delivery of humanitarian assistance including by undermining the safety of humanitarian workers, has been an unfortunate reality,” said Rachel Sider of the Norwegian Refugee Council (NRC).

The Hayat Tahrir Al-Sham (HTS) militant group and its civil wing — the so-called Salvation Government — cemented control over Idlib in the beginning of the year.

“The interference has increased since January,” said a humanitarian worker in Idlib, who wanted to remain anonymous for fear of retaliation.

“There is not a single aid organization that has been spared threats, arrests, or closure for very silly reasons,” he said, even as Idlib has come under increased bombardment by the regime and its ally Russia over the past month.

In April, Daesh militants threatened to detain him because he refused to provide them with food baskets his team was distributing at a camp for the displaced in southern Idlib, he added. “They told me I should give them aid,” said the 27-year-old.

He said HTS also detained him for four days seven months ago in Idlib city for photographing aid deliveries without their authorization.

Militants beat him, confiscated his laptop, and broke his camera, he said.

“They told me I should thank God I was being released alive.”

Paul Donohoe of the International Rescue Committee said “aid groups face interference from armed groups in Idlib, such as the restricting of access to vulnerable populations or attempting to influence beneficiary selection and the location of aid delivery.”

He declined to provide more detail but a second humanitarian worker in Idlib, who also asked to remain anonymous, said several projects by international aid agencies have been dropped in recent months because of such meddling.

A plan to provide bakeries in Idlib with free flour was scrapped because the Salvation Government insisted on limiting beneficiaries to bakeries it is affiliated with, the 29-year-old said.

“Our activities as an organization have become very modest since this happened to us,” he added.

The governing body is also trying to ensure its affiliates are among those who secure tenders with aid agencies, which attempt to avoid this through screening, he said. “They want a cut of any project implemented in the area,” he added. The encroachment has sparked concern that relief items and aid money may fall into the wrong hands.

Sider, of the NRC, said: “In this environment, aid agencies cannot completely eliminate the risk of diversion and we’d like donors to recognize this.”

The UN has said it is taking extra measures to combat diversion.

They include “additional screening from partners, suppliers, even workers, staff, and third party monitoring, including the use of modern technology — barcoding, establishing hotlines — to be able to be sure that aid reaches the right people,” the UN regional coordinator for Syria, Panos Moumtzis, told AFP.

There has yet to be any major decrease in humanitarian assistance but some donors have cut funding, said Ahmed Mahmoud, Syria director for the Islamic Relief charity.

“So far, five major hospitals have had to close entirely and seven other medical facilities — including hospitals focusing on paediatrics and obstetrics — severely cut back their operations due to funding cuts,” he said.

Though there could also be other reasons, “some donors may have concerns regarding the shifts in control in northwestern Syria, which may have affected their funding decisions.

“As one facility after another shuts its doors, the pressure only grows on those that remain,” he said.

For its part, the Salvation Government denies jeopardizing relief efforts.


Israeli soldiers fired 900 bullets during massacre of Palestinian aid workers, investigation finds

Updated 12 sec ago
Follow

Israeli soldiers fired 900 bullets during massacre of Palestinian aid workers, investigation finds

  • Researchers use visual and audio analysis to reconstruct Gaza ambush of emergency vehicles that left 15 people dead
  • Israeli troops executed some victims at close range, according to recordings and witnesses

LONDON: Israeli soldiers fired more than 900 bullets during a massacre of Palestinian aid workers that included “execution-style” killings, a detailed reconstruction of one of the worst atrocities of the Gaza war has found.

The investigation recreated a 3D digital version of the scene of the killings and used audio analysis of recordings to pinpoint how the attack unfolded in March last year.

Fifteen Palestinian aid workers were killed when Israel troops ambushed their vehicles in Tel Al-Sultan, near Rafah, southern Gaza. The victims included ambulance crews from the Palestinian Red Crescent Society, rescue teams from the Palestinian Civil Defense sent to help, and a member of the UN agency for Palestinian refugees UNRWA.

Israel tried to hide evidence of the killings by crushing the vehicles left at the scene and burying them in the sand, along with the victims’ bodies.

The joint investigation published on Monday was carried out by London-based researchers Forensic Architecture and Earshot, an audio analysis agency.

Israeli soldiers “subjected Palestinian aid workers to continuous assault by gunfire for over two hours” in an attack that started shortly after 5 a.m. on March 23, the study found.

The position of each vehicle in the convoy as the shooting began. (Forensic Architecture)

Contrary to Israel’s initial claims that events unfolded in a combat zone, “there was no exchange of fire in the area, and no tangible threat to the safety of those soldiers,” the report said. 

The researchers documented at least 910 gunshots from three recordings from the scene. At least 844 shots were recorded within a five-and-a-half-minute period in video taken by paramedic Refaat Radwan, one of the victims.

More than 90 percent of the bullets were fired directly toward the emergency vehicles and aid workers during the initial period of the attack, with at least five soldiers firing simultaneously.

The investigation concluded that the emergency lights and markings of the vehicles ambushed would have been clearly visible to the soldiers.

Israeli troops continued shooting as they advanced on the vehicles before carrying out perhaps the most disturbing act of the attack.

“Upon reaching them, they moved through the vehicles and shot several of the aid workers at close range,” the report said.

One of the shots was fired between one and four meters away from paramedic Ashraf Abu Libda and coincided with the last time his voice was heard on recordings, “suggesting that these were the shots that killed him.”

A 3D reconstruction of Asaad Al-Nasasra and Muhammad al-Hila embracing while under Israeli fire. Muhammad was shot and killed while in this position while Asaad survived, researchers found. (Forensic Architecture)

The initial attack started at about 4 a.m. when Israeli forces opened fire on an ambulance sent to the scene of an Israeli airstrike, killing the two crew members inside.

Three more ambulances were sent to search for the missing crew. Once they found the vehicle, they were joined by a Palestinian Civil Defense ambulance and a fire truck.

“All vehicles were clearly marked and had their emergency lights on,” the report said.

Within minutes of the five vehicles arriving at the scene, and as the aid workers approached their fallen colleagues, the Israeli soldiers opened fire.

The driver of a UN Toyota truck that passed the site about an hour later was also killed.

Researchers were able to map the positions and movements of the Israeli troops throughout the attack with the help of echolocation and audio-ballistic analysis.

Opinion

This section contains relevant reference points, placed in (Opinion field)

This enabled them to work out the distance and the direction of the source of the gunshots from the devices making the recordings.

Researchers also detailed the extent of the Israeli military’s efforts to “conceal and disrupt evidence of the attack.”

This included burying the victims’ bodies, burying mobile phones, and crushing and partially burying the victims’ vehicles. 

Analysis of satellite images revealed how Israel transformed the site with earth-moving machinery in the hours following the attack.

One of the two survivors of the ambush was detained for more than a month, tortured, and interrogated.

The bodies of 14 of the victims were found in a mass grave near the site on March 30, while the remains of another victim were found a few days earlier nearby.

A forensic doctor who examined some of the bodies told The Guardian newspaper that there was evidence of execution-style killing given the location of the wounds. 

Coming during the height of Israel’s two-year war on Gaza that has killed more than 72,000 Palestinians, the massacre of aid workers sparked international outcry.

In the aftermath, Israel gave varying accounts of what happened, initially claiming that its troops thought they were facing an attack.

On April 20, the Israeli military said an inquiry into the attack had identified “several professional failures, breaches of orders, and a failure to fully report the incident.”

A duty commander was dismissed for “providing an incomplete and inaccurate report during the debrief,” but there have been no further measures against those who carried out the attack.