Pakistani urges talks as army says two Indian jets shot down

Pakistani Christians carry posters featuring images of Pakistani Army Chief General Qamar Javed Bajwa as they chant slogans against India in Islamabad on February 27, 2019. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 25 July 2020
Follow

Pakistani urges talks as army says two Indian jets shot down

  • Military spokesman says one Indian pilot in custody, Pakistan struck six Indian targets from within its airspace
  • Prime Minister Khan says Pakistan and India should “resolve our problems through dialogue”

ISLAMABAD: The spokesman for the Pakistani military said on Wednesday the country had carried out airstrikes on six targets across its border with India and shot down two Indian warplanes in the steepest escalation of conflict between the two nuclear-armed neighbors since they fought a brief war in the Himalayas in 1999.

Pakistan’s actions on Wednesday come a day after it said Indian jets had violated the Line of Control (LoC) which splits the disputed Kashmir valley into two parts, one administered by Pakistan, the other by India.

India claims it hit a militant training camp inside Pakistan on Tuesday morning but Pakistan says Indian jets were barely in its airspace for a few minutes before being chased away by Pakistani warplanes without any damage to lives or infrastructure.

Tensions between the two arch-rivals have sharply risen since a suicide car bombing by Pakistan-based militants in Indian-controlled Kashmir killed at least 40 Indian paramilitary policemen on February 14. New Delhi had warned of a “strong response.”  

Pakistan’s retaliatory airstrikes on Wednesday dramatically increase the risk of escalation between the two nations who have fought three wars since they gained independence from the British in 1947, two of them over Kashmir.

“Pakistan armed forces and Pakistan air force had no choice but to give an answer … in the manner of a responsible nation,” Military Spokesman Maj. Gen. Asif Ghafoor said at a press conference in the garrison city of Rawalpindi.

Ghafoor said Pakistan had identified military and administrative posts in three locations in Indian-administered Kashmir and struck on open ground at a safe distance from the sites to avoid military and civilian casualties.

“We don’t want escalation; we don’t want to go towards war,” Ghafoor added, saying the military’s aim was simply to send India a message that Pakistan had “the will, capability, and resolve” to defend itself.

After Pakistan’s airstrikes in India, two Indian jets crossed into Pakistan to take retaliatory action but were shot down, the army spokesman said. The wreckage of one of the two planes fell in Pakistan-administered Kashmir and the other across the border in the Indian part of the valley.

Ghafoor later tweeted that an India pilot had been arrested and would be treated as per the "norms of military ethics."

The Indian government rejected the Pakistani account and foreign minister Raveesh Kumar said India had shot down a Pakistani jet that violated its airspace on Wednesday. The Pakistani military spokesman denied the jet was shot down and insisted Pakistan had not breached the Line of Control.

"They (India) have violated our air space but Pakistan has not crossed the LoC. That's because we are a responsible nation," Ghafoor said.

In an address to the nation on Wednesday afternoon, Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan urged New Delhi to opt for talks to resolve outstanding issues.

“We should sit down and resolve our problems through dialogue,” the prime minister said.

"The history of the world teaches us that there are miscalculations in war,” Khan added. “My question to the Indian government is: the [nuclear] weapons you have and the weapons we have, can we afford miscalculation? Shouldn't we think that if this [conflict] escalates, what will it lead to?"

In separate phone calls to the foreign ministers of India and Pakistan, U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo urged them to avoid “further military activity.”

“I expressed to both ministers that we encourage India and Pakistan to exercise restraint, and avoid escalation at any cost,” Pompeo said in a statement on Wednesday.

China and the European Union have also called for restraint.


Pakistan accuses India of manipulating Indus waters, warns of risks to regional peace

Updated 19 December 2025
Follow

Pakistan accuses India of manipulating Indus waters, warns of risks to regional peace

  • India announced in April it was putting the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance over a gun attack in disputed Kashmir it blamed on Pakistan
  • Islamabad says it has witnessed ‘unusual, abrupt variations’ in the flow of Chenab river, accusing New Delhi of ‘material breaches’ of treaty

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan on Friday accused India of manipulating flows of Indus waters in violation of a 1960 water-sharing treaty, warning that unilateral actions over the transboundary waters could heighten tensions and pose risks to regional peace.

The Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), mediated by the World Bank, divides control of the Indus basin rivers between the two nuclear-armed neighbors. India said in April it was holding the treaty “in abeyance” after a gun attack in Indian-administered Kashmir killed more than 26 tourists. New Delhi blamed the assault on Pakistan, Islamabad denied it.

The treaty grants Pakistan rights to the Indus basin’s western rivers — Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab — for irrigation, drinking, and non-consumptive uses like hydropower, while India controls the eastern rivers — Ravi, Beas, and Sutlej — for unrestricted use but must not significantly alter their flow. India can use the western rivers for limited purposes such as power generation and irrigation, without storing or diverting large volumes, according to the agreement.

Speaking to foreign envoys in Islamabad, Pakistani Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar accused New Delhi of “material breaches” of the IWT that may have consequences for regional stability, citing “unusual, abrupt variations” in the flow of Chenab river from April 30 to May 21 and from Dec. 7 to Dec. 15.

“These variations in water flows are of extreme concern for Pakistan as they point to unilateral release of water by India into River Chenab. India has released this water without any prior notification or any data- or information-sharing with Pakistan as required under the treaty,” he said.

“India’s most recent action clearly exemplifies the weaponization of water to which Pakistan has been consistently drawing attention of the international community.”

There was no immediate response from New Delhi to the statement.

Dar said this water “manipulation” occurs at a critical time in Pakistan’s agricultural cycle and directly threatens the lives and livelihoods as well as food and economic security of its citizens.

He shared that Indian actions prompted Indus Water Commissioner Mehar Ali Shah to write a letter to his Indian counterpart, seeking clarification on the matter as provided under the Indus Waters Treaty.

“We expect India to respond to the queries raised by Pakistan’s Indus water commissioner, refrain from any unilateral manipulation of river flows, and fulfill all its obligations in letter and spirit under the Indus Waters Treaty provisions,” the Pakistani deputy premier said.

Dar also accused India of consistently trying to undermine the IWT by building various dams, including Kishenganga and Ratle hydropower projects, which he said sets “a very dangerous precedent.”

“Alarmingly, India is now subverting the treaty’s own dispute resolution mechanism by refusing to participate in the Court of Arbitration and neutral expert proceedings. India is pursuing a deliberate strategy to sabotage the well-established arbitration process under the treaty provisions,” he said.

The South Asian neighbors have been arguing over hydroelectric projects on the shared Indus river system for decades, with Pakistan complaining that India’s planned hydropower dams will cut its flows.

In August, the International Court of Arbitration rendered an award on issues of general interpretation of the IWT, explaining the designed criteria for the new run-of-river hydropower projects to be constructed by India on the western rivers of Chenab, Jhelum and Indus, which Islamabad said vindicated its stance.

In its findings, the Court of Arbitration declared that India shall “let flow” the waters of the western rivers for Pakistan’s unrestricted use. In that connection, the specified exceptions for generation of hydro-electric plants must conform strictly to the requirements laid down in the Treaty, rather than to what India might consider an “ideal” or “best practices approach,” according to the Pakistani foreign office.

“Pakistan would like to reiterate that Indus Waters Treaty is a binding legal instrument that has made an invaluable contribution to peace and stability of South Asia,” Dar said.

“Its violation, on the one hand, threatens the inviolability of international treaties and on the other, it poses serious risks to regional peace and security, principles of good neighborhood, and norms that govern inter-state relations.”