Trump blames DC, as military parade plans unravel over costs

1 / 2
Newly inaugurated US President Donald Trump, first lady Melania , Vice President Mike Pence and his wife Karen (R) preside over a military parade during Trump's swearing ceremony in Washington on January 20, 2017. (REUTERS/Mike Segar/File Photo)
2 / 2
French President Emmanuel Macron and US President Donald Trump attend the traditional Bastille Day military parade on the Champs-Elysees in Paris, France, on July 14, 2017. (REUTERS/Charles Platiau/File Photo)
Updated 18 August 2018
Follow

Trump blames DC, as military parade plans unravel over costs

  • Cost of parade estimated at $92 million
  • Trump said he wanted the US to have its own parade after attending Bastille Day celebrations in France last year

WASHINGTON: The cancelation of President Donald Trump’s Veterans Day parade came swiftly when senior White House and Pentagon leaders saw the estimated $92 million price tag play out in public, setting off a chaotic volley of tweets and accusations between the president and the mayor of the nation’s capital.
The drama that unfolded Thursday and Friday also highlighted, not for the first time, a disconnect between the Pentagon and the White House when it comes to turning some of Trump’s more mercurial ideas into reality.
While Defense Secretary Jim Mattis dismissed the price estimate for the parade as fiction — likening the report of it as the work of someone who had been smoking pot — Trump wasn’t denying the projected costs. He was lashing out at Washington, D.C., politicians he claimed were to blame for the sky-high price.
“When asked to give us a price for holding a great celebratory military parade, they wanted a number so ridiculously high that I canceled it. Never let someone hold you up!” Trump tweeted.
He held out hope of holding the parade next year instead, and said this year he would travel to Paris for events marking the centennial of the end of fighting in World War I, which falls on Veterans Day, Nov. 11. “Now we can buy some more jet fighters!” he added.
Despite Trump blaming municipal authorities for the high estimate, the bulk of the cost was the $50 million Pentagon portion that would cover military aircraft, equipment, personnel and other support. The remaining $42 million would cover costs borne by the city and other agencies and largely involved security costs.
The Republican president’s finger-pointing set off a social media spat with D.C.’s Democratic Mayor Muriel Bowser. She shot back on Twitter Friday that she was the one who “finally got thru to the reality star in the White House with the realities ($21.6M) of parades/events/demonstrations in Trump America (sad).”
District of Columbia officials called the price-gouging charge by Trump “patently false.” A city official said the $21.6 million estimate of the costs the city would incur was their “best stab at it,” since they did not know what the exact route would be or how long it would last. The official, who wasn’t authorized to discuss the matter publicly and spoke on condition of anonymity, said there had been little interaction with the Pentagon and few details provided.
Trump decided he wanted a military parade in Washington after he attended France’s Bastille Day celebration in the center of Paris last year. Several months later Trump praised the French parade, saying, “We’re going to have to try and top it.”
It was a demand that drew criticism not just from Trump’s political opponents but some Republicans too. As the Pentagon began planning for the US version, the cost became a politically charged issue — as did the prospect of streets in the nation’s capital being churned up by tank treads.
According to officials familiar with the unfolding events, senior Pentagon leaders were briefed Wednesday about the parade costs. But officials said the estimates were still preliminary and so were not submitted to Mattis or Gen. Joseph Dunford, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
The officials spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss private meetings and conversations.
When details came out publicly Thursday, senior White House officials, including Chief of Staff John Kelly, were angry about the $92 million amount, which was more than triple early estimates of $10 million to $30 million by the White House budget director. It’s not clear when Trump was told, but the order to cancel the parade came quickly and was made by the end of the work day. The Pentagon announced the decision just before 8 p.m.
Throughout the day, multiple US officials had confirmed the $92 million estimate that was put together by the interagency parade planning group. And Pentagon officials did not push back or at any point suggest the reporting was wrong.
Still, when asked about the price Thursday evening, Mattis excoriated the media and said he had seen no such estimate.
“I’m not dignifying that number ($92 million) with a reply. I would discount that, and anybody who said (that number), I’ll almost guarantee you one thing: They probably said, ‘I need to stay anonymous.’ No kidding, because you look like an idiot. And No. 2, whoever wrote it needs to get better sources. I’ll just leave it at that,” Mattis told reporters traveling with him.
He said that whoever leaked the number to the press was “probably smoking something that is legal in my state but not in most” — a reference to his home state of Washington, where marijuana use is legal.
Mattis’ comments came hours after the estimate was made public, and not long after the cancelation decision was made — giving his staff plenty of time to ensure he was made aware of the planning estimate’s accuracy.
One reason for the political sensitivity was that Trump himself had boasted that the cancelation of a major military exercise with South Korea amid easing tensions with North Korea would save the US “a tremendous amount of money.” The Pentagon later said the Korea drills, which typically take place every August, would have cost $14 million — an amount dwarfed by the estimated cost of the parade.
The cancelation of those drills, like Trump’s demand for a parade, initially caught the Defense Department unawares. Mattis was also widely viewed as being unenthusiastic about the president’s plans to set up a Space Force as a new branch of the military — but as in the other cases, he has toed the line of the commander in chief.
The parade was expected to include troops from all five armed services — the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps and Coast Guard — as well as units in period uniforms representing earlier times in the nation’s history. It also was expected to involve a number of military aircraft flyovers, which can carry significant costs in personnel, aircraft and support.
A Pentagon planning memo released in March said the parade would feature a “heavy air component,” likely including older, vintage aircraft. It also said there would be “wheeled vehicles only, no tanks — consideration must be given to minimize damage to local infrastructure.” Big, heavy tanks could tear up streets in the District of Columbia.


‘I was motivated by solving problems the world didn’t care about,’ first Saudi Nobel laureate Omar M. Yaghi tells Arab News

Updated 6 sec ago
Follow

‘I was motivated by solving problems the world didn’t care about,’ first Saudi Nobel laureate Omar M. Yaghi tells Arab News

  • Yaghi became the first Saudi national to win a Nobel Prize, sharing the 2025 Chemistry award for work on metal-organic frameworks
  • Prior to gaining US and Saudi citizenship, he grew up in a Palestinian refugee camp, where water scarcity and hardship shaped his early life

STOCKHOLM: Saudi-American scientist Omar M. Yaghi’s career has been shaped by a rare combination of intellectual audacity and personal history — a lifelong drive to push science beyond known limits, while never losing sight of its capacity to serve humanity.

In 2025, that journey culminated in global recognition when Yaghi became the first Saudi national to receive a Nobel Prize, and only the second Arab-born laureate to be awarded the chemistry prize, after the Egyptian-American scientist Ahmed Zewail in 1999.

Yaghi shared the Nobel Prize in Chemistry with British-Australian scientist Richard Robson and Japanese scientist Susumu Kitagawa.

After stints with Arizona State University, University of Michigan and UCLA, Yaghi joined UC Berkeley in 2012, where he currently holds the James and Neeltje Trett Chair. (AFP)

Together, the three were recognized for more than half a century of contributions to the development of metal-organic frameworks, or MOFs — porous, sponge-like materials with vast internal spaces capable of storing carbon dioxide or harvesting water from the air.

They will also share the 11 million Swedish krona (about $1 million) prize.

Once a niche academic pursuit, MOF science is now studied in more than 100 countries and applied at industrial scale, with uses ranging from climate change mitigation to addressing water scarcity.

Yaghi’s rise to the pinnacle of global science began far from elite laboratories. He grew up in a Palestinian refugee family of 10 children, living on the outskirts of the Al-Wehdat refugee camp in the Jordanian capital, Amman.

The family’s single-room home had no electricity. Water arrived only once a week — sometimes once every two weeks — prompting residents to rush to fill every available bucket before the next long wait.

“It’s not the poetic idea that because I had hardship with water when I was a child that I was determined to solve the problem,” Yaghi told Arab News.

“I was much more motivated by solving problems that the world didn’t really care about. That’s basic science, which is about going to the frontiers of knowledge and being brave enough to solve problems.

“Once you make that great discovery, then it leads to much more benefit than you would have achieved had you done it by initially answering the problems of society,” he said.

His childhood revolved around three defining spaces: the family home near Al-Wehdat, where livestock were raised; the butcher shop his father, Mounes, ran on King Talal Street; and the private Bishop’s School in the historic Jabal Amman district.

The Yaghi family originally came from Al-Masmiyya, a Palestinian village between Jerusalem and Jaffa that was depopulated and destroyed after being occupied by the Zionist paramilitary group Haganah in 1948.

In 2018, Yaghi made a homage visit to Al-Masmiyya, searching for specific locations preserved in family stories of life before the Nakba.

After displacement, the family settled in Amman, where Omar was born in 1965 and where his father built a cattle and butchery business that left a lasting impression on his son.

“This shop figured prominently in my life. There, I learned the power of a work ethic. I learned that when you have a transaction with other people, you should be honest, the power of honesty and of hard work,” he said.

Yaghi watched his parents work relentlessly to support their children’s education. His father rose before dawn and worked until after sunset, while his mother baked fresh bread, prepared meals, cared for the household, and tended the cows.

“I was shy and quiet. And had done my homework separately from the other kids, and didn’t play the games that they were playing, and it seems like I spent most of my childhood sitting in a corner, reading or writing, and observing what was happening around me,” he said.

Although the family was registered as refugees with the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East, his father opted against enrolling his children in UNRWA schools.

“We didn’t go to UNRWA schools because my father felt that he needed reporting on our performance in school on a regular basis,” Yaghi said. UNRWA provided reports only once a term — too infrequent for his father’s liking.

At Bishop’s School, Yaghi studied English and some French alongside mathematics and science, subjects the school emphasized strongly. “Math and science were topics that my father absolutely wanted to see us do very well at,” he said.

At the age of 10, a chance encounter with molecular drawings in the school library proved transformative. He was captivated by their beauty and mystery, later learning that these shapes formed the basic building blocks of all matter, living and non-living alike.

In 1980, aged just 15, Yaghi travelled alone to the US, enrolling at Hudson Valley Community College in Troy, New York, where he studied English, science, and mathematics.

The family’s savings — nearly $9,000 — sustained him for about two years. To survive, he worked odd jobs in supermarkets and tutored fellow students in math.

Although he could read and write English, he soon realized he was unprepared for the speed and idiom of American speech.

He immersed himself in the language, watching news broadcasts and soap operas, speaking with classmates, reading at least one full newspaper story every day, and consulting a dictionary he had brought from Amman.

“Most words that were in the newspaper were not in this dictionary, but I managed to get at least a few new words,” he said. Within three to six months, he had mastered American English.

In 1985, he earned a bachelor’s degree in chemistry from the State University of New York at Albany. Five years later, he completed his PhD at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.

After academic appointments at Arizona State University, the University of Michigan, and UCLA, Yaghi joined UC Berkeley in 2012, where he holds the James and Neeltje Tretter Chair.

He is also the founding director of the Berkeley Global Science Institute and has taught students from 15 countries, including Saudi Arabia, the UAE, China, and the UK.

In 1995, Yaghi coined the term “metal-organic framework” to describe crystalline structures capable of hosting guest molecules within their internal cavities while withstanding temperatures exceeding 300 degrees centigrade.

Four years later, he introduced MOF-5, now considered a classic in the field for its extraordinary internal surface area. By 2003, he had demonstrated that MOFs could be rationally modified — a breakthrough that unlocked their practical versatility.

James Stephenson, CEO of Promethean Particles, said MOFs are prized for their ability to capture carbon dioxide and harvest water, and for the precision with which they can be engineered for specific gases.

A single gram of MOF has a surface area of about 8,000 square meters, measured using the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller method. Stephenson often likens their structure to cages.

“If you think about a cage structure, and at every corner, there is a metal ion, and then the pieces that connect those are linkers. You can have almost limitless combinations of metals and linkers, and by changing them, you can create these cages in different sizes,” he said.

Promethean Particles has led industrial-scale MOF production since 2012 and, in 2022, pioneered their use for carbon capture at Drax, the UK’s largest power plant in North Yorkshire.

“MOFs are known for all this complexity, but really, it’s about the space inside them,” Stephenson said. “It’s about the holes that make them so different. Our approach is to make MOFs at large volumes, as cost-effectively as possible, with safe, abundant raw materials.”

The company already supplies a UK customer operating a MOF-based water harvesting machine. Stephenson says MOFs offer advantages over desalination plants, which are energy-intensive, immobile, and ill-suited to remote areas.

“Dewpoint machines have limitations today with regard to the conditions in which they can extract water from the atmosphere. So the potential for MOFs as a water harvest will allow us to provide access to water to more people,” he added.

According to the World Health Organization, 2.1 billion people worldwide lack access to safely managed drinking water, including 106 million relying on untreated surface sources.

Since 2018, Yaghi has increasingly pursued entrepreneurial ventures, founding Atoco to work on water harvesting and CO2 capture, and co-founding H2MOF for hydrogen storage and WaHa Inc. for water harvesting projects in the Middle East.

He said current energy-efficient MOF prototypes can produce 100 liters of water per day, with the potential to reach 2,000 liters.

“I’m very hopeful that this becomes a major contributor to the supply of water, not just in the arid regions, but also in regions of the world where there may be a lot of water, but it’s not clean,” Yaghi said.

His achievements have brought international recognition. He received the King Faisal International Prize for Chemistry in 2015, and in 2021 King Salman granted him Saudi citizenship for his contributions to reticular chemistry and nanomaterials.

He is also co-director of the KACST-UC Berkeley Center of Excellence for Nanomaterials for Clean Energy Applications and advises the KACST president.

“The Saudis have treated me very well, and they were very kind to confer Saudi citizenship on me. I collaborate with them. As a scientist, my only concern is solving a problem that serves humanity,” he said.

“I am very proud of my Palestinian origin. I was born and raised in Jordan. I became an American citizen. Americans have treated me very well,” he added.

Yaghi has donated a model of MOF-5 to the Nobel Prize Museum, where it will be displayed alongside Zewail’s “femtochemistry apparatus.”

That instrument illustrates Zewail’s technique of capturing chemical reactions within a femtosecond — a span to a second what a second is to 32 million years.

The donation puts Yaghi among hundreds of laureates who have contributed artifacts since the museum’s founding in 2001, marking the centenary of the Nobel Prize, established in 1901.

“I think first and foremost, a scientist is about answering questions that advance the state of knowledge,” Yaghi said.

“I like basic research very much because it allows you to be free in pursuing an intellectual challenge. When you solve an intellectual challenge, you end up providing a base for many benefits to society.”