Labor drought in Europe’s east as workers go west

A 'cook job' advertisement is seen in front of a restaurant in Budapest, Hungary, on March 18, 2017. Once an eldorado of cheap labor, companies in eastern and central Europe are struggling to fill thousands of jobs as workers up sticks and head to wealthier EU nations. (AFP / ATTILA KISBENEDEK)
Updated 19 March 2017
Follow

Labor drought in Europe’s east as workers go west

BUDAPEST, Hungary: A decade ago, business was booming for Hungarian construction firm owner Geza Borgulya.
He was making an annual profit of some five million euros ($5.4 million) and had around 60 staff including surveyors and bricklayers.
Now, the 44-year-old has barely a dozen employees left.
“I’m glad if I make a million in earnings,” he told AFP in the central town of Rackeve.
Borgulya largely blames the decline on Hungarian workers heading to neighboring Austria where wages are significantly higher.
“Those who work in western Europe easily earn 70 euros a day, we can’t keep up with that here,” said Borgulya.
Once an eldorado of cheap labor, companies in eastern and central Europe are struggling to fill thousands of jobs as workers up sticks and head to wealthier EU nations.
A staggering 20 million people have moved from the region to western Europe since the early 1990s, many of them headed for Germany and Britain, according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
The exodus, coupled with low birth rates and rapidly aging populations, has left gaping holes in job markets across the region.
From health care and computer technologies to manufacturing and food industries, few sectors have been exempt from the drought.
The diaspora, which began with the fall of the Iron Curtain, was exacerbated by ex-communist countries’ accession to the EU and the financial crisis.
Some 400,000 Hungarians have emigrated from the nation of 10 million since 2008, official figures show.
“I have lost at least twelve people over the past three years, who have gone to England, Austria and Sweden,” said a restaurant owner in Budapest, who did not want to be named.
Hospitals suffer
The situation is even more acute in neighboring Romania, the EU’s second-poorest country after Bulgaria.
Three million Romanians, or 15 percent of the population, have left in recent years, with a majority of working age. Hospitals are particularly hard hit.
“We don’t know what to do anymore to attract new recruits,” said Ionela Danet, who runs a hospital in the city of Curtea de Arges in southern Romania.
She has been trying to hire at least 20 doctors.
“We have state-of-the-art equipment, we’re on a tourist route, the region is beautiful and not far from Bucharest. Yet no one’s applying,” Danet told AFP.
The exodus from the region has “exacerbated shortage” of labor and “lowered potential growth” in workers’ home countries, the IMF found in a report last year.
It’s also forced companies to bump wages, increasing costs without boosting productivity.
Although eastern and central states have the EU’s fastest-growing economies and unemployment rates are relatively low, employers fear that the labor shortage will soon turn into a serious obstacle for foreign investment.
While the Czech Republic has 140,000 vacant jobs primarily in the manufacturing sector, car-making hub Slovakia needs technicians while Bulgaria is desperate for engineers.
“Large companies are worried that if the issue isn’t resolved, it will create... insuperable problems for their future projects,” Bulgaria’s economy ministry warned this month.

Generous perks
To remedy the situation, corporations are trying to lure back workers with generous perks.
In Hungary, burger giant McDonald’s is offering free accommodation to out-of-town staff, while cashiers can earn close to 1,000 euros at German budget supermarket chain Lidl — a salary equivalent to that of an expert in chemical engineering.
Meanwhile Polish companies have turned to foreign workers from Ukraine to help fill the void left by the recent departure of some 2.4 million nationals.
An estimated one million Ukrainians are residing in Poland, making up a large chunk of restaurant and shop employees in the capital Warsaw.
“Without the Ukrainians, the Polish economy would be in deep trouble, particularly regarding less skilled positions,” said Maciej Witucki, president of Work Service, one of Poland’s largest employment agencies.
However emigration isn’t the only cause for the labor drought.
A lack of investment in education and training has also left tens of thousands of young people without formal skills or employment.
In response, governments have rolled out apprentice schemes and teamed up with private businesses to draw recruits, in the hope that they’ll take up domestic jobs.
The EU plans to toughen migrant labor rules and Britain’s decision to quit the bloc might also drive down the number of arrivals.
Following last year’s so-called “Brexit” vote — spurred by a divisive debate on immigration — eastern workers face an uncertain future in Britain.
Until now, only a modest fraction of them have returned home, according to IMF data, but that could change in the coming years.


US abstains in UN vote voicing support for Ukraine

Updated 3 sec ago
Follow

US abstains in UN vote voicing support for Ukraine

  • The resolution also called for an immediate and unconditional ceasefire and “comprehensive, just and lasting peace“
  • The US delegation had pressed for a separate vote on paragraphs involving Ukraine’s territorial integrity and international law but this idea was rejected

UNITED NATIONS: The UN General Assembly voiced support for Ukraine Tuesday on the fourth anniversary of Russia’s invasion, with the United States among countries abstaining from the vote.
The assembly passed a resolution saying it was committed to “the sovereignty, independence, unity and territorial integrity of Ukraine within its internationally recognized borders.”
It passed by a tally of 107 countries in favor, 12 against and 51 abstentions, which included the United States.
The resolution also called for an immediate and unconditional ceasefire and “comprehensive, just and lasting peace.”
The US delegation had pressed for a separate vote on paragraphs involving Ukraine’s territorial integrity and international law but this idea was rejected.
The transition from Joe Biden to Donald Trump in the White House last year has seen firm, unconditional US support for Ukraine cool dramatically.
Trump has brought Russian leader Vladimir Putin back in from the diplomatic cold and Washington has repeatedly refused to condemn the Russian invasion of 2022.
US deputy ambassador Tammy Bruce said she welcomed the UN appeal for a ceasefire.
But she said the resolution includes “language that is likely to distract” from diplomatic efforts to end the war rather than support them. She did not identify these words.
Still, leaders of the G7 global powers, including Trump, on Tuesday reaffirmed their “unwavering support for Ukraine” in a statement on the fourth anniversary of the invasion.
A month after Trump returned to power in January 2025, the United States voted against a UN General Assembly resolution calling for a “just and lasting peace” to end the war.
The US delegation later won Security Council passage of a Russian-backed resolution that called for peace but made no mention of Ukraine’s territorial integrity, frustrating Ukraine’s European allies.
Until then, the council had failed to speak out on the war because Russia consistently used its veto power.
“Despite peace efforts led by the US and supported by Europe, Russia continues to demonstrate no genuine willingness to stop this aggression,” Ukraine’s Deputy Foreign Minister Mariana Betsa said.
Russia’s deputy ambassador Anna Evstigneeva answered, saying Ukraine should focus on diplomacy to end the war “rather than initiating yet another politicized vote.”
In Washington, Ukraine’s Ambassador to the US Olga Stefanishyna urged the Trump administration to intensify pressure on Russia.
“We hope that the US government this particular day... will get to the understanding that the language which is understood by Russians is not the dialog or diplomatic effort, it’s the pressure,” Stefanishyna told reporters.
She expressed hope that US lawmakers would soon pass a bill imposing tariffs and secondary sanctions on countries doing business with Russia in order to choke its economy and ability to finance the war.
Stefanishyna added that Ukraine is in desperate need of air defenses at a time when Russia has been intensifying its attacks on civilians and critical infrastructure during a brutal winter.
While acknowledging that “it’s too premature to speak about any settlement in the nearest period of time,” she said that any deal to end the war must include powerful US and EU Security guarantees.