Trying civilians in military courts lacks transparency, UK government says after verdicts announced

A Union Jack flag flutters in the wind outside the Houses of Parliament in London, Britain, on March 29, 2024. (REUTERS/File)
Short Url
Updated 23 December 2024
Follow

Trying civilians in military courts lacks transparency, UK government says after verdicts announced

  • 25 civilians sentenced by a Pakistani military court to periods of two to 10 years of “rigorous imprisonment” on Saturday
  • Case relates to accusations thousands of Khan supporters stormed military installations, torched general’s house in 2023

ISLAMABAD: The United Kingdom said on Monday trying civilians in military courts lacked transparency and undermined the right to a fair trial, days after 25 civilians were sentenced by a Pakistani military court to periods of two to 10 years of “rigorous imprisonment” in connection with attacks on military facilities in 2023.

The Dec. 21 ruling underscores concerns among supporters of jailed former prime minister Imran Khan that military courts are going to play a bigger role in cases involving the 72-year-old cricketer-turned politician, who is facing multiple charges including allegedly inciting attacks against the armed forces. He is currently facing these charges in a civilian court, but his Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party fears he may also be taken to military trial. 

The government says thousands of Khan supporters stormed military installations and torched a general’s house on May 9, 2023, among other violence, to protest against the former PM’s arrest by paramilitary soldiers that day in a land graft case. At least eight people were killed in the violence. 

“While the UK respects Pakistan’s sovereignty over its own legal proceedings, trying civilians in military courts lacks transparency, independent scrutiny and undermines the right to a fair trial,” a Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office spokesperson, said. “We call on the Government of Pakistan to uphold its obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.”

The Pakistan government and military have not yet responded to the UK statement, which follows one by the European Union, saying the military court verdicts were “inconsistent” with Pakistan’s international obligations.

On Saturday, while announcing the military court verdicts, the army’s media wing said the sentences were an “important milestone in dispensation of justice to the nation.”

“It is also a stark reminder to all those who are exploited by the vested interests and fall prey to their political propaganda and intoxicating lies, to never take law in own hands,” the army said in a statement.

Others charged over the violence were being tried in anti-terrorism courts but justice would only be fully served “once the mastermind and planners ... are punished as per the Constitution and laws of the land,” the military said, in what was widely seen as a veiled reference to Khan. 

The ruling comes days after Khan was indicted by an anti-terrorism court on charges of inciting attacks against the military. An army general who served under him as his spy chief, Faiz Hamid, is facing a military investigation on the same charges.

Pakistan’s Supreme Court last week allowed military courts to announce verdicts in concluded trials of nearly 85 supporters of Khan on charges of attacking army installations. However, it made such verdicts conditional on the outcome of appeals against the jurisdiction of military courts over civilians.

The court last year provisionally allowed military courts to try civilians.

With inputs from Reuters


Traders estimate $18 million losses as rescue operations continue after Karachi mall inferno

Updated 5 sec ago
Follow

Traders estimate $18 million losses as rescue operations continue after Karachi mall inferno

  • DNA testing underway to identify victims still missing after blaze destroys 1,200 shops
  • Emergency services dispatched on Tuesday to another fire at Karachi’s New Vegetable Market

KARACHI/ISLAMABAD: Karachi’s business community on Tuesday estimated losses of about $18 million after a devastating fire tore through a major shopping plaza in the city, with rescue teams continuing search and recovery operations at the site amid fears that more victims may still be trapped under the debris.

The fire broke out late Saturday at Gul Plaza, a multi-story shopping complex in Karachi’s congested Saddar area, spreading rapidly through the building, which has over 1,200 shops, and trapping workers and shoppers inside. Recovery efforts have been slowed by severe structural damage and fears of collapse, officials said.

Dr. Summaiya Syed, Karachi’s chief police surgeon, said 20 deaths had been confirmed so far, with identification still underway for several bodies recovered from the site.

Karachi has a long history of deadly fires in commercial buildings, often blamed on overcrowding, aging infrastructure and weak enforcement of fire safety regulations in a city of more than 20 million people.

Atiq Mir, president of the Karachi Tajir Ittehad, which represents around 600,000 small traders across the city, said assessments by traders now put the financial damage from the Gul Plaza fire at nearly Rs5 billion ($18 million), far higher than initial estimates. 

“The plaza had at least 8000-10,000 laborers and then those affiliated to them. We can easily say nearly 10,000 families have been affected by this fire,” Mir told Arab News. 

He urged the government to announce a compensation grant of at least Rs5 billion ($18 million) and said the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry would be the most appropriate body to oversee transparent distribution of relief funds.

On Monday, the provincial government of Sindh said it would provide Rs10 million ($36,000) in compensation to the family of each person killed in the Gul Plaza fire. 

Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah also announced the formation of a joint committee involving provincial officials and the Karachi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (KCCI) to assess losses and oversee rehabilitation of affected traders. He said authorities were exploring temporary arrangements to relocate 1,000 to 1,200 shops so businesses could resume operations as quickly as possible.

Citing past precedents such as the Bolton Market arson and the Cooperative Market fire, Shah said similar compensation and recovery mechanisms had previously helped traders rebuild their livelihoods and would guide the current response.

On Tuesday, Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab said heavy machinery had been deployed to clear debris and allow access to Gul Plaza’s basement, where search teams believe victims may still be trapped.

“Under all circumstances, the rescue operation must be completed and the search for victims further accelerated,” Wahab said during a visit to the site, according to a statement. 

“All departments of the Karachi Metropolitan Corporation will remain on alert until every missing person is traced and the operation is concluded.”

As rescue operations intensified at Gul Plaza, emergency services were dispatched to another fire at Karachi’s New Vegetable Market, officials said, underscoring persistent safety challenges.

Deputy Mayor Salman Abdullah Murad said fire brigade units and Rescue 1122 teams were immediately deployed and the blaze was brought under control.

“The fire is under control and there is no danger,” Murad said, adding that the affected area had been secured and cooling operations were underway.

Police officials said no casualties were reported in the vegetable market incident.