After a year of war, Gazans wonder how to deal with tons of rubble

FILE PHOTO: A Palestinian walks past the rubble of houses destroyed by Israeli strikes, amid Israel-Hamas conflict, in Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip (REUTERS)
Short Url
Updated 07 October 2024
Follow

After a year of war, Gazans wonder how to deal with tons of rubble

  • Year of war generates at least 42 million tons of rubble
  • Piled up, rubble would fill Great Pyramid of Giza 11 times

KHAN YOUNIS: In the ruins of his two-story home, 11-year-old Mohammed gathers chunks of the fallen roof into a broken pail and pounds them into gravel which his father will use to make gravestones for victims of the Gaza war.
“We get the rubble not to build houses, no, but for tombstones and graves — from one misery to another,” his father, former construction worker Jihad Shamali, 42, says as he cuts through metal salvaged from their home in the southern city of Khan Younis, damaged during an Israeli raid in April.
The work is hard, and at times grim. In March, the family built a tomb for one of Shamali’s sons, Ismail, killed while running household errands.
But it is also a tiny part of the efforts starting to take shape to deal with the rubble left by Israel’s military campaign to eliminate Palestinian militant group Hamas.
The United Nations estimates there is over 42 million tons of debris, including both shattered edifices that are still standing and flattened buildings.
That is 14 times the amount of rubble accumulated in Gaza between 2008 and the war’s start a year ago, and over five times the amount left by the 2016-17 Battle of Mosul in Iraq, the UN said.
Piled up, it would fill the Great Pyramid of Giza — Egypt’s largest — 11 times. And it is growing daily.
The UN is trying to help as Gazan authorities consider how to deal with the rubble, three UN officials said.
A UN-led Debris Management Working Group plans a pilot project with Palestinian authorities in Khan Younis and the central Gazan city of Deir El-Balah to start clearing roadside debris this month.
“The challenges are huge,” said Alessandro Mrakic, the Gaza Office head for the United Nations’ Development Programme (UNDP) which is co-chairing the working group. “It’s going to be a massive operation, but at the same time, it’s important that we start now.”
Israel’s military has said Hamas fighters hide among civilians and that it will strike them wherever they emerge, while also trying to avoid harming civilians.
Asked about the debris, Israel’s military unit COGAT said it aimed to improve waste-handling and would work with the UN to expand those efforts. Mrakic said coordination with Israel was excellent but detailed discussions on future plans were yet to take place.

Tents amid the ruins
Israel began its offensive after Hamas militants entered Israel on Oct. 7 last year, killed about 1,200 Israelis and took over 250 people hostage.
Nearly 42,000 Palestinians have been killed in a year of conflict, Palestinian health authorities say.
On the ground, wreckage is piled high above pedestrians and donkey carts on dusty narrow paths that were once busy roads.
“Who is going to come here and clear the rubble for us? No-one. Therefore, we did that ourselves,” taxi driver Yusri Abu Shabab said, having cleared enough debris from his Khan Younis home to erect a tent.
Two-thirds of Gaza’s pre-war structures — over 163,000 buildings — have been damaged or flattened, according to UN satellite data. Around a third were high-rise buildings.
After a seven-week war in Gaza in 2014, UNDP and its partners cleared 3 million tons of debris — 7 percent of the total now. Mrakic cited an unpublished preliminary estimate that it would cost $280 million to clear 10 million tons, implying around $1.2 billion if the war stopped now.
A UN estimate from April suggested it would take 14 years to clear the rubble.

Concealed bodies
The debris contains unrecovered bodies, as many as 10,000 according to the Palestinian health ministry, and unexploded bombs, Mrakic said.
The International Committee of the Red Cross says the threat is “pervasive” and UN officials say some of the debris poses a big injury risk.
Nizar Zurub, from Khan Younis, lives with his son in a home where only a roof remains, hanging at a precarious angle.
The United Nations Environment Programme said an estimated 2.3 million tons of debris might be contaminated, citing an assessment of Gaza’s eight refugee camps, some of which have been hit.
Asbestos fibers can cause larynx, ovarian and lung cancer when inhaled.
The World Health Organization has recorded nearly a million cases of acute respiratory infections in Gaza in the past year, without saying how many are linked to dust.
WHO spokesperson Bisma Akbar said dust was a “significant concern,” and could contaminate water and soil and lead to lung disease.
Doctors fear a rise in cancers and birth defects from leaking metals in coming decades. Snake and scorpion bites and skin infections from sandflies are a concern, a UNEP spokesperson said.

Land and equipment shortages
Gaza’s rubble has previously been used to help build seaports. The UN hopes now to recycle a portion for road networks and bolstering the shoreline.
Gaza, which had a pre-war population of 2.3 million crammed into an area 45 km (28 miles) long and 10 km wide, lacks the space needed for disposal, the UNDP says.
Landfills are now in an Israeli military zone. Israel’s COGAT said they were in a restricted area but that access would be granted.
More recycling means more money to fund equipment such as industrial crushers, Mrakic said. They would have to enter via crossing points controlled by Israel.
Government officials report fuel and machinery shortages because of Israeli restrictions that slow clear-up efforts. The UNEP spokesperson said prolonged approval processes were a “major bottleneck.”
Israel did not specifically comment on allegations it was restricting machinery.
The UNEP says it needs owners’ permission to remove debris, yet the scale of destruction has blurred property boundaries, and some property records have been lost during the war.
Several donors have expressed interest in helping since a Palestinian government-hosted meeting in the West Bank on Aug. 12, Mrakic said, without naming them.
A UN official, requesting anonymity to avoid undermining ongoing efforts, said: “Everybody’s concerned whether to invest in rebuilding Gaza if there is no political solution in place.”

 

 


’One war too many’: Lebanese angry with Hezbollah for attacking Israel

Updated 4 sec ago
Follow

’One war too many’: Lebanese angry with Hezbollah for attacking Israel

  • “Hezbollah must surrender its weapons to the state, period,” Randa Harb told AFP
  • “Hezbollah makes decisions without concerning itself with the country or even its support base, it is waging pointless battles,” a store owner said

BEIRUT: When an air strike hit their Beirut neighborhood, people were angry with Israel, but they reserved their deepest rage for Hezbollah, for dragging Lebanon into the Middle East war.
Israel and the United States launched huge strikes on Iran on February 28, killing its supreme leader and sparking a massive retaliatory campaign.
Iran-backed Hezbollah, already weakened by war, attacked Israel in support of its sponsors, pulling Lebanon into a new cycle of strikes, death and mass displacement.
“Hezbollah must surrender its weapons to the state, period,” Randa Harb, an elderly woman who runs a fruit and vegetable stall in the neighborhood of Aisha Bakkar, told AFP.
The densely populated area was struck on Wednesday morning, wounding four people according to the health ministry, and sparking shock across the capital.
Another woman, who refused to give her name, told AFP a relative was wounded, and she accused Hezbollah of forcing “one war too many” on the Lebanese.

- ‘Killing each other’ -

Lebanon was torn apart by a civil war that ended in 1990, with only Hezbollah refusing to hand over its weapons to the state when peace returned.
For decades, it was believed to have an arsenal more powerful than the military’s, and it fought multiple wars with Israel that each took a devastating toll.
The most recent hostilities should have ended in a ceasefire in 2024, but that too proved fragile, with Israel keeping up its strikes even as the Lebanese military sought to disarm Hezbollah under the terms of the truce.
Inspecting the damage in her cousin’s apartment, 46-year-old Amal Hisham screamed: “I do not care about Hezbollah!“
The windows were shattered, and the gold-colored sofas left in tatters.
Hisham was also enraged with Israel, saying she couldn’t just blame one side. “They are all just killing each other,” she said.
“Do you think they are happy about their areas being destroyed? They’re not happy. Their families have been displaced,” she said, referring to Hezbollah members and their wider support base.
“Who will compensate these people?“

- ‘Pointless battles’ -

As soon as the injured had been evacuated, residents began to wonder who the target had been.
A shop owner, also requesting anonymity, believed Hezbollah operatives were hiding there, while others imagined it was Hamas, the group’s Palestinian ally.
“No matter,” said Mohammed Ahmed, 42. “The presence of Hezbollah or Hamas poses a great danger to us.”
“If one wants to be martyred, let him stay where he is... let him be martyred alone, why come to people who are already tired?“
Lebanon is deeply divided along sectarian lines, with Hezbollah rooted in the Shia Muslim community, that was long sidelined by authorities.
Aisha Bakkar is one of several Beirut neighborhoods that are majority Sunni Muslim, while Lebanon is also home to Christians, Druze and others.

- ‘They shot my son’ -

Aziza, who sheltered families fleeing the 2024 war, worries about the massive influx of displaced people from Beirut’s southern suburbs, where Hezbollah holds sway, and which have come under Israeli bombardment.
“We came to welcome them... they shot my son in the leg” after he complained that they had raised Hezbollah’s flag, she said.
In majority-Christian Mar Mikhael on the other side of Beirut, a 68-year-old grocery store owner also deplored the group’s decision to enter the war.
“Hezbollah makes decisions without concerning itself with the country or even its support base, it is waging pointless battles... what good will it do? You fire a missile, they fire a hundred back at you,” he said.
Hezbollah was at the height of its popularity following the 2006 war with Israel, which it claimed to have won.
That changed.
“We never hated the Sayyed,” said Ghada, a municipal worker, referring to late Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah who was killed by Israel in 2024.
“He is the one who stopped Israel,” she said.
Bolstering the belief that Hezbollah was operating solely as an Iranian proxy, the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps announced that Hezbollah had “officially entered the war” around three hours before the Lebanese group had issued its own statement.
Some Lebanese Shia have also grown impatient.
“No one wanted this war,” Lina Hamdan, a Shia lawyer, told AFP, adding that her community “are the first victims.”
A longtime critic, she believes this war may be a “turning point” for Hezbollah, whose military activities were outlawed by the government last week.
While many displaced stranded in the capital refrained from criticizing Hezbollah, some voiced frustration.
“What was the point of this war? Nothing about this makes sense,” said Hiam, a 53-year-old mother sheltering in a school.
Hezbollah runs schools and hospitals, and long provided Shia Lebanese with assistance.
“This time, we are left to fend for ourselves,” Hiam added.