BBC under fire after accusation of ‘gaslighting’ staff over antisemitic concerns

The BBC is facing criticism after accusations that it has “gaslighted” staff who raised concerns about the handling of antisemitic complaints in the corporation. (Reuters/File Photo)
Short Url
Updated 02 August 2024
Follow

BBC under fire after accusation of ‘gaslighting’ staff over antisemitic concerns

  • More than 200 Jewish staff sign letter calling for inquiry into ‘serious institutional racism problem’
  • BBC chairperson Samir Shah accused of dismissive approach after suggesting signatories use formal routes for making complaints

LONDON: The BBC is facing criticism after accusations that it has “gaslighted” staff who raised concerns about the handling of antisemitic complaints in the corporation.

More than 200 Jewish staff members, contributors and suppliers signed a letter addressed to Samir Shah, the BBC chairperson, calling for an inquiry into what they described as a potential “serious institutional racism problem.”

The letter cited social media posts and “impartiality breaches in matters of public controversy relating to Israel and Gaza,” highlighting comments by “Match of the Day” presenter Gary Lineker, “The Apprentice” contestant Asif Munaf, and several BBC Arabic staff members.

It also included a 30-page dossier of anonymous complaints detailing staff experiences of antisemitism and the associated fear and mental health toll on Jewish BBC employees.

Responding to the letter, Shah stated that the board “holds the (BBC) executive to account through the assurances we seek and the questions we ask of the decision-making process.”

He urged the signatories to use the BBC’s formal routes for making complaints, adding: “I am satisfied that where we have made errors, the executive have acted appropriately and handled matters in accordance with the guidelines as they apply to my colleagues.”

According to reports by The Guardian, Shah’s response was met with anger from some of the signatories, who felt frustrated by what they perceived as the broadcaster’s “gaslighting” approach to its Jewish staff.

The controversy arises days after former BBC TV news presenter Huw Edwards pleaded guilty to three counts of making indecent pictures of children, along with accusations of abuse on “Strictly Come Dancing.”

These incidents increased pressure on the corporation and raised questions about its ability to effectively address such problems.


Tucker Carlson claims he was detained at Israeli airport

Updated 20 February 2026
Follow

Tucker Carlson claims he was detained at Israeli airport

DUBAI: Earlier this week, Tucker Carlson flew to Israel to interview US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee, according to media reports.

Carlson, who reportedly refused to leave Tel Aviv’s Ben Gurion Airport complex, conducted the interview at the airport, after which he said he and his staff were detained and their passports were seized.

“Men who identified themselves as airport security took our passports, hauled our executive producer into a side room and then demanded to know what we spoke to Ambassador Huckabee about,” Carlson said in a statement to The New York Post.

However, Carlson’s claims have been contradicted by Huckabee and Israeli authorities.

Huckabee, a former Arkansas governor and Fox News host, said on social media platform X that “EVERYONE who comes in/out of Israel (every country for that matter) has passports checked & routinely asked security questions,” including himself, despite holding a diplomatic passport and visa.

The US Embassy in Israel also described the interaction as routine passport control procedures.

The Israel Airports Authority said in a statement that Carlson and his staff “were not detained, delayed, or interrogated.”

They were asked “a few routine questions, in accordance with standard procedures applied to many travelers,” and this conversation took place in a separate room within the VIP lounge to protect their privacy, the statement added.

“No unusual incident occurred, and the Israel Airports Authority firmly rejects any other claims.”

Carlson has faced criticism in recent years over his commentary on Israel, with critics accusing him of amplifying narratives that are hostile to Israel and, at times, antisemitic. He has also questioned Israel’s treatment of Christian communities in the region.

After Fox News canceled his show in April 2023, he launched his own program, “The Tucker Carlson Show” in 2024.

The show has featured controversial figures, including Darryl Cooper, who has made statements widely condemned as Holocaust denial, and white nationalist commentator Nick Fuentes.

In his interview with Fuentes, Carlson labeled Huckabee a “Christian Zionist.”

Carlson has also criticized Huckabee for not doing enough to protect Christian interests in the region. In one video, he said: “Why not go ahead and talk to Christians and find out their side of the story? Why aren’t American Christian leaders like Mike Huckabee or Ted Cruz, people who invoke the Christian Bible to justify what they’re doing, why haven’t they done this?”

Huckabee responded to the video on X, writing: “Instead of talking ABOUT me, why don’t you come talk TO me?  You seem to be generating a lot of heat about the Middle East. Why be afraid of the light?”

Carlson accepted the invitation, and their teams coordinated the interview, leading to his brief visit to Israel.