Pakistan’s election monitor faces shortage of impartial observers amid politically charged environment 

A female voter casts her ballot at a polling station during the by-election for national assembly seats, in Karachi on October 16, 2022. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 06 August 2023
Follow

Pakistan’s election monitor faces shortage of impartial observers amid politically charged environment 

  • FAFEN resumed election work by scrutinizing voter lists amid anticipation for national polls in Pakistan 
  • It plans to send 6,000 election observers in the field this year, a number far lower than in the past 

ISLAMABAD: A leading network of Pakistan’s civil society organizations resumed its election monitoring work by scrutinizing voter lists, informed one of its officials this week, though it encountered challenges while recruiting impartial election observers in a charged environment where people have been quite vocal about their political affiliations. 

The Free and Fair Election Network (FAFEN) has been in the field since 2008 with the primary mandate to observe the polls and critically watch legislative work along with other significant government and parliamentary actions. 

The organization has also used its findings in the past to convince the election commission and parliament to effect necessary adjustments to the legal framework governing electoral contests to make them more transparent. 

“We have already conducted voter list audit to look at the quality of electoral rolls that are going to be used in the next elections,” FAFEN’s Director Programs Muddassir Rizvi told Arab News. “The findings are going to be shared after the elections as part of our election reporting.” 

He said that his organization’s long-term election observers would be looking at candidates and their nomination process in the next stage and see if all political parties get equal opportunity to contest the polls and connect with the voters. 

FAFEN plans to send 6,000 election observers in the field this time, a number far lower than in the past. 

“This is one election where people have not only taken their sides on all sides of the political divide but they are also declaring their political affiliations,” he said. “Thanks to the social media, many people who would otherwise say they are non-partisan now inadvertently say something or the other which shows their political affiliation. So, it is very difficult to find people who are non-partisan in Pakistan to be trained as election observers.” 

Rizvi, however, noted this was not going to compromise the quality of election monitoring. 

“We are going with a smaller number but with a more sound statistical sample which we will be using on election day,” he explained. “Roughly, there will be 100,000 polling stations on the election day and we are targeting to observe around 25 percent.” 

Asked about the politically tense environment of Pakistan, the FAFEN official said it was a good thing that people were aware of their choices. 

“We may disagree with them,” he maintained, “but they have a political choice which is good. This is how we will be developing a democratic critical mass in Pakistan.” 

Rizvi added, however, he was not trying to turn a blind eye to the political polarization in Pakistan on a level where lawmakers were required to interact with each other. 

“At that level, people need to grow up and start talking,” he said. “The entire issue that we have seen for the last one-and-a-half years, or even the last four-and-a-half years, was political disengagement. The previous government didn’t want to engage with the opposition and the new government doesn’t want to engage with the opposition [either].” 

Responding to a question about recent amendments to empower caretaker setups in Pakistan, he said it was not a bad move, though interim administrations should not be allowed to take decisions with long-term consequences. 

“They cannot be just there because we need to have a government,” he argued. “[Only] the symbolism of the government should not be there. They should be functioning governments. They should be able to make decisions.” 


No third meeting with Pakistan army chief on Trump’s calendar – White House official

Updated 7 sec ago
Follow

No third meeting with Pakistan army chief on Trump’s calendar – White House official

  • Reuters reported that Donald Trump was expected to hold a third meeting with Asim Munir in six months over a proposed Gaza force
  • Pakistan’s top military commander has met Trump twice this year, including a White House luncheon without Pakistani civilian leaders

ISLAMABAD: A White House official said on Wednesday there was no meeting scheduled between US President Donald Trump and Pakistan’s army chief Field Marshal Asim Munir, after a Reuters report cited sources saying Munir is expected to travel to Washington in the coming weeks for talks that could focus on a proposed multinational force for post-war security and aid delivery in Gaza.

Trump’s Gaza plan, outlined as part of a 20-point framework, envisages the deployment of troops from Muslim-majority countries during a transitional stabilization phase, intended to support security and governance as the war-ravaged Palestinian territory moves toward reconstruction and a longer-term political settlement.

Reuters reported that Washington saw Pakistan as a potentially significant contributor given its battle-hardened military, which has fought a brief but intense conflict with India this year and continues to combat insurgencies in its remote regions, adding that the visit would mark Munir’s third meeting with Trump in six months.

“This is not on the President’s calendar at this time,” a White House official said on background, responding to an Arab News query about a possible Trump-Munir meeting.

Munir has met Trump twice in recent months. In June, he was invited to a White House luncheon, an unusual and unprecedented interaction in which a US president hosted a Pakistani military leader without the presence of civilian authorities.

A second meeting took place in October, when Trump hosted Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and publicly thanked Munir – whom he described as his “favorite” field marshal – for Pakistan’s efforts toward peace in Gaza, alongside leaders of other Muslim nations.

Pakistan this week reiterated its position the situation in West Asia during an open debate at the UN Security Council, calling for a “time-bound and irreversible” political process anchored in relevant UN resolutions that would lead to the establishment of a sovereign, independent and contiguous Palestinian state.

Islamabad and Washington have meanwhile sought to repair ties after years of strained relations, with both sides working to boost bilateral trade and investment following what officials have described as a favorable tariff deal.