Palestinians criticize European Commission president over ‘racist trope’ in video message to Israel

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has been criticized by Palestinians for using an “anti-Palestinian, racist trope” in her praise for Israeli democracy. (Reuters/File Photo)
Short Url
Updated 27 April 2023
Follow

Palestinians criticize European Commission president over ‘racist trope’ in video message to Israel

  • In comments marking Israel’s 75th anniversary, Ursula von der Leyen said it ‘the desert bloom,’ a phrase Israelis use to describe what they see as the nation’s successful development
  • Palestinians accused her of ‘propagandist discourse’ that undermines the EU ‘and casts serious doubts on its declared commitment to international law and human rights’

LONDON: European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has been criticized by Palestinians for using an “anti-Palestinian, racist trope” in her praise for Israeli democracy during her comments to mark the 75th anniversary of the founding of Israel.

In a video posted on Twitter by the EU embassy in the country, von der Leyen, who visited Israel and Palestine last year, paid tribute to Israel as “a vibrant democracy in the heart of the Middle East.”

“We have more in common than geography would suggest; our shared culture, our values and hundreds of thousands of dual Israeli-EU citizens have created a deep connection,” she said, adding: “Your freedom is our freedom.”

She also praised the relationship between the EU and Israel but her comment about Israel making “the desert bloom” was strongly condemned by the Palestinian Foreign Ministry. The phrase is often used by Israelis to describe what they perceive to be the country’s successful development since it was established in 1948.

“The State of Palestine rejects the inappropriate, false and discriminatory remarks by the president of the European Commission, particularly the ‘make the desert bloom’ anti-Palestinian, racist trope in relation to Israel’s 75-year colonial project,” the ministry said.

It accused von der Leyen of “propagandist discourse” that undermines “the European Union’s standing and casts serious doubts on its declared commitment to international law and human rights.”

A spokesperson for the European Commission told the BBC on Thursday it was “unpleasantly surprised” by the “inappropriate statement” from the Palestinian Foreign Ministry “accusing the president of the European Commission of racism.”

The spokesperson said the commission was “requesting clarification” over what it described as an “unacceptable reaction” to the video.


UN rights chief slams dangerous ‘tit-for-tat dynamic’ in Mideast war

Updated 4 sec ago
Follow

UN rights chief slams dangerous ‘tit-for-tat dynamic’ in Mideast war

  • Turk deplored the extensive attacks in residential areas, on health facilities, schools, cultural property and water and energy infrastructure
  • He stressed that “under the laws of war, civilians and civilian infrastructure must be protected at all costs“

GENEVA: The United Nations rights chief voiced alarm Tuesday at the Middle East conflict’s deepening impact on civilians, warning of the dangers of the seeming “tit-for-tat dynamic” between the warring sides.
The United States and Israel began striking Iran on February 28, prompting waves of Iranian strikes across the Gulf.
With hostilities intensifying, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Turk deplored the extensive attacks in residential areas, on health facilities, schools, cultural property and water and energy infrastructure.
“This apparent tit-for-tat dynamic, involving essential infrastructure with extremely significant civilian impacts, will only increase risks for civilian populations more broadly, with potentially dire consequences across the entire region,” he warned in a statement.
Turk stressed that “under the laws of war, civilians and civilian infrastructure must be protected at all costs.”
“All parties are bound by these rules, and must be held to account if they do not,” he said, warning: “the world is watching.”
The UN rights chief warned that “strikes against vital civilian infrastructure in the Middle East — as well as the widening geographic spread of strikes — are further increasing risks for populations across the region, and beyond.”
He pointed to strikes on a water desalination plant and fuel facilities in Iran over the weekend, igniting fires and reportedly disrupting water access for dozens of villages.
It also prompted warnings of “acid rain” that could cause chemical burns and serious lung damage.
“The foreseeable impacts on civilians and the environment of these strikes raise serious questions as to compliance of these attacks with the requirements of international humanitarian law of proportionality and precaution,” Turk said.
“This warrants careful legal scrutiny.”
He also highlighted the broader impact of the war.
The plunge in commercial shipping activity through the Strait of Hormuz was taking a severe toll on access to energy, food and fertilizer across the region and beyond — hitting the world’s most vulnerable people the hardest.
Turk raised concern about reports of detentions, charges and other forms of repression and intimidation against people in a number of countries, in connection with their expression of opinions around the Middle East conflict.
He demanded that all those arbitrarily detained be released immediately and unconditionally.
“States are reminded of their obligation under international human rights law to respect and protect people’s right to freedom of expression — particularly in times of crisis,” he said.