UK government fails to deliver on its promise to define Islamophobia

Home Office statistics show Muslims are the most targeted faith group in England and Wales, accounting for more than 40 percent of religiously motivated hate crime. (Reuters/File Photo)
Short Url
Updated 31 October 2022
Follow

UK government fails to deliver on its promise to define Islamophobia

  • Expert adviser hired in 2019 to define Islamophobia was given no financial resources, staff or support

LONDON: Three years since promising to establish a working definition of Islamophobia, the UK government will be questioned on the issue in parliament on Tuesday amid a growing backlash for its inaction. 

Home Office statistics show Muslims are the most targeted faith group in England and Wales, accounting for more than 40 percent of religiously motivated hate crime. 

Meanwhile, a slew of scandals has revealed anti-Muslim sentiment within the Conservative Party.

In 2018, a group of MPs and peers drew up a working definition to be adopted, stating the absence of one was allowing Islamophobia to “increase in society to devastating effect,” The Independent reported

Describing Islamophobia as a “type of racism that targets expressions of Muslimness,” the definition was accepted by Labor and other opposition parties but rejected by the Conservative government. 

In May 2019, the late James Brokenshire — then the communities secretary — said the government would establish a working definition of Islamophobia, adding: “To get a firmer grip on the nature of this bigotry and division we agree there needs to be a formal definition of Islamophobia to help strengthen our efforts.”

An expert adviser was hired but his work was halted after Boris Johnson became prime minister, The Independent reported.

Imam Qari Asim said that several letters to ministers have gone unanswered, including one requesting a meeting with current communities secretary, Michael Gove.

Asim claimed he was given no office, no financial resources, no staff, and no terms of reference to create the definition, and that the government demonstrated a “lack of meaningful engagement.” 

According to The Independent, Gove fired him without notice in June after accusing him of supporting “a campaign to limit free expression” in connection with a controversial film depicting the life of the Prophet Mohamed’s daughter, which Asim denied. 

In a letter responding to his dismissal, the imam said the government had “reinforced perceptions that it is not serious about addressing growing anti-Muslim hatred in this country.”

No new advisers have been appointed and there is no ongoing work on defining Islamophobia.

According to The Independent, Gove recently spoke out against the creation of a definition during a debate on extremism in September. 

“I think there are dangers if a university or another organization, which should be the home of free debate, uses a definition like that to police what people can say in order to penalize them for it,” Gove said. 

Marking the start of Islamophobia Awareness Month, Labour MP Afzal Khan will raise a point of order on Tuesday, asking why successive prime ministers have not responded to any of his letters about bigotry in the past two years.

“Their lack of action since 2018, coupled with the damning allegations made by Conservative MP Nusrat Ghani, all show that they simply do not take the issue seriously,” he told The Independent.

“Year after year, British Muslims are victims of the highest proportion of religiously motivated hate crime. This trend shows no sign of abating under the Conservative government.

“Yet, this revolving door of chaos has meant that consecutive prime ministers have failed to tackle Islamophobia and deliver on their promises.”

Yasmin Qureshi, the shadow minister for women and equalities, warned that the “scourge of Islamophobia is on the rise,” with hate crimes targeting Muslims up year-on-year.

“The Conservatives are the only political party in the UK to reject the APPG on British Muslim’s definition of Islamophobia,” she told The Independent. “Now Michael Gove has broken his promise to develop an alternative.

“With the revolving door of prime ministers scrabbling round to fix the mess they’ve created with the economy, it’s clear that tackling Islamophobia is an afterthought.”


Pope Leo to visit Italy’s Lampedusa island in July

Updated 9 sec ago
Follow

Pope Leo to visit Italy’s Lampedusa island in July

VATICAN CITY: Pope Leo XIV in July will visit the Italian island of Lampedusa, a landing point for migrants crossing the Mediterranean Sea from North Africa, the Vatican announced om Thursday.
The US pontiff has previously thanked the people of Lampedusa, which is just 145km off the coast of Tunisia, for the welcome they have given over the years to those who arrived, often on leaky, overcrowded boats.
Leo has also repeatedly spoken out against measures to clamp down on illegal migration. 
He called the US administration’s treatment of immigrants “inhuman.”
Leo will visit Lampedusa on July 4, as part of a program of visits within Italy this summer, which includes a trip to Pompeii on May 8, the anniversary of his election, the Vatican said.
On May 23, he will meet pilgrims in the so-called “Land of Fires” in Campania, a southern Italian region blighted by toxic waste dumped by the mafia.
Leo’s predecessor, Francis, chose Lampedusa for his first official visit after becoming pontiff in July 2013.
In a definitive speech of his papacy, Francis denounced what he called “the globalization of indifference,” and the defense of migrants became a cornerstone of his papacy.
Leo became the first US head of the world’s 1.4 billion Catholics last May following Francis’s death.
In October, Leo said states had a right to protect their borders but a “moral obligation” to provide refuge.
“With the abuse of vulnerable migrants, we are witnessing, not the legitimate exercise of national sovereignty, but rather grave crimes committed or tolerated by the state,” he said, according to a speech published by the Vatican.
“Ever more inhuman measures are being adopted — even celebrated politically —that treat these ‘undesirables’ as if they were garbage and not human beings.”
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s government has taken a tough line on irregular migration, restricting the activities of charity rescue boats and seeking to speed up returns of people who fail to qualify for asylum.
Her ministers last week agreed on a new draft law that would allow the imposition of a “naval blockade” to stop migrant boats from entering Italian waters.
Almost 2,300 migrants have landed on Italy’s shores so far this year, compared to 5,600 in the same period in 2025 and 4,200 in the same period in 2024.
Yet many die trying to make the crossing, with at least 547 lives lost along Mediterranean routes so far this year, according to the UN’s International Organization for Migration.
Leo, who was born in Chicago and spent two decades as a missionary in Peru, has said he loves to travel. 
He spent many years on the road when he served two, six-year terms as the superior of his Augustinian religious order, which required him to visit Augustinian communities around the world.
Pope Leo himself has said he hopes to visit his beloved Peru, as well as Argentina and Uruguay, trips that could happen toward the end of the year.