Court holds disaster management authority responsible for tourist deaths at Murree resort town

A vehicle is seen covered with snow after a heavy snowfall in Murree, Pakistan, around 70 kilometers (45 miles) northeast of the capital, Islamabad, on January 8, 2022. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 13 January 2022
Follow

Court holds disaster management authority responsible for tourist deaths at Murree resort town

  • Twenty-two tourists died trapped in their cars in the resort town last Saturday after they were caught in a snowstorm
  • The Islamabad High Court said the authority should have made adequate preparations to deal with the situation

ISLAMABAD: A Pakistani court on Thursday castigated the country's top disaster management authority for the death of several tourists in Murree last week amid an intense snowstorm.

According to the local media, Islamabad High Court (IHC) Chief Justice Athar Minallah blamed the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) for the tragedy, saying people would not have lost their lives if relevant officials had taken appropriate measures to deal with the situation.

Twenty-two tourists died trapped in their cars last Saturday after a storm clogged roads and stranded them overnight in freezing weather.

Police said some of the victims froze to death in their cars, while others died from asphyxiation after inhaling exhaust fumes in snow-bound vehicles.

"You are responsible for this incident," the chief justice told an NDMA representative according to Dawn. "Every [official] included in the NDMA law is responsible for these deaths. The whole state is responsible for these deaths."

"If preparations and measures had been taken, 22 people and children would not have died," he continued while asking if the NDMA had ever prepared a plan for Murree district.

The chief justice instructed the prime minister to call a meeting of the National Disaster Management Commission next week, asking the NDMA official to submit a report on behalf of the commission in the court by January 21.

The IHC decided to look into the Murree tragedy after one of the residents of the resort town, Hammad Abbasi, requested it to probe the development and hold those responsible for the deaths of tourists accountable.

Earlier this week, the authorities sealed 15 hotels in Pakistan's picturesque hill station, blaming them for overcharging tourists during the blizzard which forced many of them to spend the night in their vehicles.

The action was taken after several tourists complained on social media that hotels had taken advantage of stranded people by heavily charging them for accommodation.


Too warm to freeze: Climate shift threatens ice hockey in Pakistan’s Hunza Valley

Updated 7 sec ago
Follow

Too warm to freeze: Climate shift threatens ice hockey in Pakistan’s Hunza Valley

  • Rising temperatures, falling snowfall disrupt community-run tournament dependent on natural ice
  • Scientists report shorter snow seasons across Hindu Kush-Himalayan region as climate risks grow

HUNZA, Pakistan: Aleena Gul used to watch the pool beside her home in Pakistan’s Hunza Valley freeze solid each winter, transforming it into a makeshift ice hockey rink.

This year, it barely froze at all.

“If we see, there’s a big difference between 2018 and now in 2026,” said Gul, a local player whose family has hosted the community tournament for eight seasons.

“Winter used to begin in November and everything would freeze, . It’s January now and the ice still hasn’t frozen properly,” said Gul, a local player whose family has hosted the community tournament for eight seasons.

The change has disrupted a small but growing winter sports tradition in the mountainous region near the Chinese border, where residents say colder, longer winters once provided reliable natural ice.

Scientists studying the wider Hindu Kush-Himalayan region have reported fewer extreme cold events and shorter snow seasons, with snowfall increasingly failing to settle. Weather data for Hunza shows winter precipitation down by about 30 percent since the late 2010s, with some recent winters two to three degrees Celsius warmer.

That is a challenge for a region reliant on visitors, where winter tourism depends heavily on snowfall and freezing temperatures.

The community-run ice hockey tournament in Hunza depends entirely on natural ice. When Gul’s pool failed to freeze properly this year, organizers scrambled to find an alternative venue nearly two hours north, in a town close to the Chinese border.

Even there, conditions were difficult.

“I expected better ice conditions, but when I saw the rink I felt a bit sad. Many of our players fell. The surface had too many bumps and wasn’t strong,” said Yahya Karim, another player.

Of three matches scheduled on the first day, only one went ahead.

“Today, we got ready at almost around 9 o’clock. When we got called for the match, we saw that the ice was not in a good condition. So, all these things are very unexpected for us. And this is a side effect of climate change,” Gul said.

Naseer Uddin, co-founder of the youth organization SCARF, said volunteers had worked for about a week preparing the arena.

“We worked on this arena for about a week. We had planned [a match] here. Then, suddenly, when the sun came out today, so we had to switch suddenly because the ice in this arena has been spoiled,” he said.

Sadiq Saleem, president of the Altit Town Management Society, said residents were witnessing a noticeable change.

“We are witnessing a sudden shift in Hunza’s weather pattern, [both] in the snowfall and freezing [temperature] here. We are seeing a big shift in the intensity of winter here,” he said.

The girls’ match eventually went ahead, and Gul’s team emerged victorious. But the uncertainty over ice conditions has left many wondering how long the tradition can survive.

Climate change has become a growing concern for Pakistan, which contributes less than 1 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions yet is frequently ranked among the countries most vulnerable to global warming.

This week, Pakistan’s National Disaster Management Authority warned of an elevated risk of glacial lake outburst floods in the north as rising temperatures threaten to accelerate snow and glacier melt. Seasonal forecasts point to higher-than-normal temperatures and possible early heatwave conditions in Gilgit-Baltistan and upper Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, regions that include Hunza.

For now, players in the valley are making do with what winter brings. But as temperatures rise, even a simple backyard rink is no longer guaranteed.