Prosecution's CCTV footage shows Noor Mukadam attempted to escape twice before murder — media

Women rights activists light candles at a park in Islamabad on July 25, 2021, against the brutal killing of Noor Mukadam, the daughter of former Pakistan envoy to South Korea, in the federal capital earlier this week. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 10 November 2021
Follow

Prosecution's CCTV footage shows Noor Mukadam attempted to escape twice before murder — media

  • Mukadam once ran out of Zahir Jaffer's house, once jumped from first floor but was prevented by guard from leaving
  • Trial for her murder is one of the most closely watched in Pakistan's recent history as case has sparked public and media outrage

ISLAMABAD: The prosecution in the Noor Mukadam murder case on Tuesday submitted the transcript of CCTV footage showing events that preceded the woman's murder at an Islamabad house in July, local media reported, saying the victim had jumped from the first floor of the chief accused’s house but was prevented by staff from leaving the premises. 

Mukadam, 27, was found beheaded at Zahir Jaffer's house in Islamabad’s upscale F-7/4 neighborhood on July 20. The trial for her murder is one of the most closely watched in Pakistan's recent history, as the case has sparked public outrage and grabbed media attention unlike any other recent crime against women. Jaffer was arrested from the crime scene on the day of the murder and has been in custody since. 

He was indicted last month. Others charged in the case include Jaffer's parents, Zakir Jaffer and Asmat Adamjee, their three household staff, Iftikhar, Jan Muhammad and Jameel, and six workers from Therapy Works, a counselling centre from where Jaffer had received certification to become a therapist and where he had been receiving treatment in the weeks leading up to the murder.

The trial in the case began last month.

“According to the transcript, submitted in the court of Additional Sessions Judge Ata Rabbani today, the time of the digital video recorder was 35 minutes ahead of the Pakistan standard time,” Dawn reported, outlining the transcript of the CCTV footage. 

As per the newspaper report, Noor could be seen entering Jaffer’s home while speaking on her phone on July 18 at 10:18pm. At 2:39am on July 19, the two are seen coming out of the house carrying bags which they placed in a taxi parked outside. They both then went back inside.

At 2:41am, Noor came running barefooted towards the gate but a guard closed the gate to prevent her from leaving. Zahir was then seen coming out of the house, grabbing Noor, and forcing her back into inside while she begged and pleaded. 

“Sometime later at 2:46am, according to the transcript, the pair were once again seen exiting the house and approaching the gate. This time, they sat in the taxi across the street with their baggage and could be seen departing in the car,” Dawn said. “They return just minutes later at 2:52am and go back inside the house with their bags while Iftikhar and a black dog could also be seen in the yard.”

On July 20 at 7:12pm, according to Dawn, Noor could be seen jumping from the first floor of Jaffer's house with a cell phone in her hand. She fell onto a grill beside a ground floor gallery. 

“She then staggered towards the main gate and wanted to go out but Iftikhar and the gardener could be seen closing the door to stop her,” the newspaper reported. “Zahir jumped from the first floor as well, ran towards Noor and then trapped her in a cabin beside the gate. He snatched Noor's mobile phone from her and dragged her back inside the house."


Pakistan Supreme Court halts trial of prominent lawyer over alleged anti-military tweets

Updated 57 min 11 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan Supreme Court halts trial of prominent lawyer over alleged anti-military tweets

  • Top court orders lower court to pause proceedings after lawyers allege due-process breaches
  • Mazari-Hazir, husband face charges under cybercrime law that carry up to 14 years in prison

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s Supreme Court on Thursday halted the cybercrime trial of prominent human rights lawyer Imaan Mazari-Hazir and her husband, Hadi Ali Chattha, after their lawyers argued that a lower court had recorded witness testimony in their absence, violating due-process rules.

Mazari-Hazir, one of Pakistan’s most outspoken civil liberties lawyers, and Chattha are being prosecuted under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) over posts on X that authorities say incited ethnic divisions and portrayed the military as involved in “terrorism.” Both reject the allegations. If convicted under the relevant PECA provision, they face a prison term of up to 14 years.

The case has drawn broad attention in Pakistan’s legal community because Mazari-Hazir, who has been repeatedly detained over her criticism of the security establishment, argues that the trial court ignored basic procedural guarantees despite her medical leave request. The case also comes as Pakistan faces sustained scrutiny over the use of PECA against activists, journalists and political dissenters, with lawyers arguing that lower courts often move ahead without meeting minimum fair-trial standards.

The couple’s lawyer, Riasat Ali Azad, said his clients filed a petition in the Supreme Court because the lower court had moved ahead improperly.

“Today, the Supreme Court of Pakistan has stayed the lower court proceedings, the trial court proceedings and has said that the [Islamabad] High Court should decide our pending revision petition for which a date has already been fixed,” he told reporters.

Azad said the violation was clear under Pakistan’s Code of Criminal Procedure, which requires evidence to be recorded in the presence of the accused.

“Yet, on that very day, evidence of four witnesses was recorded in their absence, and a state counsel was appointed to conduct cross-examination on their behalf,” he said. “All these things are against the right to a fair trial under Articles 10 and 10-A.”

A three-judge bench led by Justice Muhammad Hashim Khan Kakar ordered the trial court to pause proceedings and instructed the Islamabad High Court to hear the couple’s pending criminal revision petition first.

The trial had been scheduled to resume on Dec.15, but the Supreme Court’s stay now freezes proceedings before both the additional sessions judge and the special PECA court. 

The Islamabad High Court is expected to hear the criminal revision petition next week.

Chattha, who is also a lawyer, said the SC ruling underscored the need for procedural safeguards.

“It is a victory for the constitution and the law,” he said, arguing that the trial court had ignored their request to re-record witness statements in their presence.