Islamabad police file case against Zahir Jaffer over ‘abusive language’ during Noor Mukadam trial 

Policemen escort Zahir Jaffer, a man who went on trial accused of raping and beheading his girlfriend, after his court hearing in Islamabad, Pakistan, on October 20, 2021. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 04 November 2021
Follow

Islamabad police file case against Zahir Jaffer over ‘abusive language’ during Noor Mukadam trial 

  • Police say Jaffer attempted suicide by banging his head against wall on court premises 
  • Suspect can’t avoid conviction by merely posing as mentally ill, legal expert maintains 

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad police have registered a criminal case against Zahir Jaffer, the prime suspect in the Noor Mukadam murder case, for using “abusive language” inside the courtroom and attempting suicide on the court premises. 

Mukadam, 27, was found beheaded at Jaffer’s house in Islamabad’s upscale F-7/4 neighborhood on July 20. The trial for her murder is one of the most closely watched in Pakistan’s recent history, as the case has sparked public outrage and grabbed media attention unlike any other recent crime against women. 

Jaffer was arrested from the crime scene on the day of the murder and has been in custody since. The trial in the case began last month. 

Video footage broadcast on Pakistani news media showed police officers carrying Jaffer out of the Islamabad court building on Wednesday, after District and Sessions Judge Atta Rabbani directed the police to take him out for using indecent language and repeatedly interrupting the court proceedings with unwarranted comments at the trial hearing. 

“We have registered a criminal case against Zahir Jaffer and a separate charge-sheet for it will be presented in the court,” Assistant Sub-Inspector Waqas Ahmed told Arab News at the Margalla police station. 

“He has not only used abusive language in the courtroom, but also tried to commit suicide by smashing his head against the wall,” Ahmed said. 

The officer said he was not sure if “Jaffer was staging a drama by doing all this or he was genuinely not in his senses.” 

During the hearing on Wednesday, Jaffer repeatedly interrupted the proceedings and used indecent language as Judge Rabbani heard prosecution witnesses, they told Arab News. 

“These proceedings are being prolonged because they don’t have any authority,” Jaffer told the judge at one point. It was unclear who he was referring to as having no authority. 

In the First Information Report (FIR), the police said the suspect had “violated” the sanctity of the court by using abusive language inside the courtroom. The case would be investigated separately and a charge-sheet filed for trial. 

Reached for an opinion, a lawyer maintained that a suspect could not avoid conviction in a case by merely posing as mentally ill, as there was a whole procedure for this to be determined. 

“A judge may refer a suspect to a mental hospital for medical examination and it may take at least six months to finalize a report,” Aftab Bajwa, a Supreme Court attorney, told Arab News. 

“One thing is for sure that a suspect cannot trick the court by posing as mentally ill to avoid conviction or come out of jail on this pretext.” 


Pakistan law minister urges media caution on foreign policy debate amid Middle East tensions

Updated 10 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan law minister urges media caution on foreign policy debate amid Middle East tensions

  • Azam Nazeer Tarar says constitutional limits must be respected when discussing diplomatic matters
  • He says people can express themselves but sensitive external issues fall outside freedom of expression

ISLAMABAD: Federal Minister for Law and Justice Azam Nazeer Tarar urged journalists on Tuesday to exercise caution when discussing the country’s foreign policy, saying constitutional limits must be respected as regional tensions rise following the escalating conflict in the Middle East.

Tarar said citizens have the right to receive accurate information and express their views, but warned that public debate on sensitive diplomatic matters could cross constitutional boundaries and trigger legal consequences.

His remarks come as tensions in the Gulf have intensified after coordinated strikes by the United States and Israel against Iran on Feb. 28, followed by retaliatory Iranian attacks targeting American bases and infrastructure in several Arab states.

The crisis has complicated diplomatic balancing for countries such as Pakistan that maintain ties across the region.

“Journalism is such a profession, and particularly given the way information flows today, it is the right of every person living in Pakistan that correct information should reach them, and every individual also has the right to express what is in their heart,” Tarar told the media.

“However, we cannot ignore constitutional limits and restrictions,” he said, adding that criticism often arises when authorities register criminal cases or initiate prosecution after those limits were crossed.

The minister said debate that frames Pakistan’s foreign policy choices in binary terms — such as whether the country stands with Iran or Gulf states — risks undermining delicate diplomatic relations.

He maintained even the Constitution of Pakistan does not permit people to casually comment on such issues, adding that the public should trust the state in managing these matters.

“Your constitution, which is the fundamental document and the social contract with the state, the agreement between the state and its citizens about how life is to be conducted here, also obliges you to exercise great caution in such discussions and commentary, as they do not fall within the bounds of freedom of expression,” he said.

The remarks come amid debate in the country about limits of online free speech, as authorities frequently invoked the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) to pursue cases related to digital content.

Critics say the law has been used to curb dissent and intimidate journalists and activists, while the government maintains it is necessary to combat misinformation, cybercrime and threats to national security.

Tarar said legal action should not automatically be viewed as excessive if authorities enforce constitutional limits.

“Every profession also has a basic responsibility to conduct itself within the limits of the law,” he added.