India slams Twitter for not complying with new IT rules

Growing tensions between India’s government and US big tech have angered firms that have spent millions of dollars to build hubs in the country. (File/AFP)
Short Url
Updated 16 June 2021
Follow

India slams Twitter for not complying with new IT rules

  • Twitter deliberately defied the country's new IT rules, said India's technology minister.
  • The rules are aimed at regulating content on social media firms such as Facebook, WhatsApp messenger and Twitter,

NEW DELHI: India’s technology minister said on Tuesday that Twitter Inc. had deliberately defied and failed to comply with the country’s new IT rules, which became effective in late May.

The new rules or the so-called Intermediary Guidelines, announced in February, are aimed at regulating content on social media firms such as Facebook, its WhatsApp messenger and Twitter, making them more accountable to legal requests for swift removal of posts and sharing details on the originators of messages.

The rules also require big social media companies to set up grievance redressal mechanisms and appoint new executives to coordinate with law enforcement.

India’s technology ministry wrote to Twitter on June 5, warning the company of “unintended consequences” if it did not obey the rules, Reuters previously reported.

Prasad did not directly say on Tuesday whether Twitter had lost intermediary protections, but a senior government official told Reuters that Twitter may no longer be eligible to seek liability exemptions as an intermediary or the host of user content in India due to its failure to comply with new IT rules.

“There are numerous queries arising as to whether Twitter is entitled to safe harbor provision,” Prasad tweeted. “However, the simple fact of the matter is that Twitter has failed to comply with the Intermediary Guidelines that came into effect from the 26th of May.”

Twitter, Prasad added, had chosen the “path of deliberate defiance when it comes to the Intermediary Guidelines.”

Twitter did not respond to a request for comment though it said on Monday it was keeping India’s technology ministry apprised of the steps it was taking.

“An interim Chief Compliance Officer has been retained and details will be shared with the Ministry directly soon,” it said. “Twitter continues to make every effort to comply with the new guidelines.

New Delhi-based digital advocacy group Internet Freedom Foundation said it was only up to courts, and not the government, to decide whether companies such as Twitter remained intermediaries for alleged non-compliance such as appointment of executives.

Growing tensions between India’s government and US big tech have riled firms that have spent millions of dollars to build hubs in their largest growth market, to the extent some are rethinking expansion plans, people close to the matter have told Reuters previously.


Transparency is key to trust, says CNNIC exec

Updated 48 sec ago
Follow

Transparency is key to trust, says CNNIC exec

  • Cathy Ibal outlines CNN’s multi-platform strategy and approach to AI amid shifting audience habits

DUBAI: Overall trust in news has stayed stable for the third year in a row at 40 percent, according to the Reuters Institute’s Digital News Report 2025.

Yet the news industry is growing more fragmented as engagement with traditional media sources such as TV and print declines and audiences turn to social media and video platforms for news, the same report found.

In this environment, Arab News spoke to Cathy Ibal, senior vice-president of CNN International Commercial, about the evolving nature of the news, particularly broadcast, industry.

CNN recognizes the shift in “the way that people access, consume and engage with news media,” and has adapted as a network to be present across various channels including TV, digital, mobile, and social media, among others, she said.

While CNN is synonymous with “breaking news,” “which is when we have our largest audience spikes and interest,” she said that it is part of the network’s mission “to be essential to people every day” through content across varied topics including business, technology, and health.

In the Middle East region, CNN audiences are 1.5 times more likely than the global average to engage with the network via social media and mobile apps, according to research by Differentology.

They are also 1.5 times more likely to rely on user-generated content as a primary news source compared with the global average.

CNN is “acutely aware of the dynamic nature of content consumption in the Middle East,” where a significant proportion of the population is under the age of 30, resulting in “an accelerated take-up of new technology, and therefore ways of consuming news media,” Ibal said.

“To that end, we have a considerable content offering for and about the region,” she added, referring to shows such as “Connect the World” with Becky Anderson and “CNN Creators,” as well as CNN Arabic. 

Despite changing audience behavior, Ibal believes there is something “uniquely powerful” about traditional TV, from both an audience and advertiser perspective. Ultimately, a multi-platform approach allows the network and advertisers to connect with more diverse audiences in different ways.

One of the key focuses of the network’s branded content studio, Create, for example, is content strategy. “The same piece of content cannot simply be created for one platform and reused on others,” Ibal said.

“We always say that powerful storytelling must be at the heart of a well-performing campaign. The role of content strategy is to determine how to best tell that story in different native environments.”  

Artificial intelligence is increasingly becoming more commonplace in the newsroom, with approximately 81 percent of journalists using AI tools in their work regularly, according to a 2025 global study.

Still, audiences remain skeptical about the use of AI in news. Only 12 percent of respondents are comfortable with fully AI-generated news, rising to 43 percent when a human being leads with some AI help, and 62 percent for entirely human-made news, according to the same study.

The key to earning and maintaining trust, according to Ibal, is transparency.

Commercially, CNN has used automation and machine learning for many years, specifically for audience targeting and personalization, as well as to automate time-consuming tasks in its branded studio and to analyze large data sets for audience insight and campaign evaluation.  

Editorially, the network’s approach to using AI is “rooted in responsibility and transparency,” Ibal said. With major global events, such as elections, coming up, CNN is investing in areas such as AI-driven fact-checking and misinformation detection tools that identify manipulated images, deepfakes, and misleading content before it reaches audiences, she added.

Ibal said: “Any use of AI across CNN — whether for commercial, editorial or product development — must adhere to our standards and practices and strict AI guidelines to ensure our audiences and brand partners can always trust our work in this area.”