Pakistani diaspora divided over Musharraf's death sentence

Supporters of the All Pakistan Muslim League (APML), the party of former military ruler Pervez Musharraf, carry placards as they shout slogans during a protest following a special court's verdict, in Islamabad on December 18, 2019. (AFP)
Short Url
Updated 18 December 2019
Follow

Pakistani diaspora divided over Musharraf's death sentence

  • The ex-military ruler was convicted of high treason and sentenced to death on Tuesday
  • APML representatives in UAE say the verdict will be appealed

DUBAI: The Pakistani community in the United Arab Emirates, where President Gen. Pervez Musharraf has been living in self-exile, received his sentencing to death with mixed reactions.

Musharraf was convicted of high treason and sentenced in absentia by a special court in Islamabad on Tuesday morning.

Abubaker Afendi, a Pakistani businessman based in Dubai, told Arab News this was the first time in 72 years that the courts have taken a strong stance.

“This is the best decision that will go down in history,” he said, adding that Musharraf had all the right to appeal against it.

“It also shows that no one is above the law,” he said.

Javed Khamisani, another Dubai-based businessman, said the sentencing might make certain quarters happy, but he was not in favor of the decision.

“We may have reservations about some of Musharraf’s decisions, but overall he has done the best for Pakistan, as compared to other politicians who have caused the country harm for their personal benefits,” he said and argued that the judiciary has recently taken many “questionable” decisions.

Safa Mansoor, a PR professional with a keen interest in politics, said there should be no sympathy for Musharraf. “He is reaping what he sowed. He made the biggest mistake by participating in the US-led war on terror which killed thousands of Pakistanis,” she said.

“But I also think that Musharraf’s death penalty is harmful to Pakistan’s overall image and could undermine Pakistan army’s sacrifices in the region,” she added.

Housewife Farya Ahmed was of the view that the sentencing was too harsh. 

“There are many other leaders who have caused more harm to the country than Musharraf but they are walking free in fact they have been able to get bails,” she said, adding that “Musharraf should have been given a chance to defend himself at least.”

Businessman Omer Khan said the sentencing was an eyewash. “These are all theatrics. If Musharraf, who is very sick, is not coming back to the country, how will he be hanged?”

“Hanging a sick hospitalized man and sending a convict abroad shows how blindly justice is being meted out,” Khan said.

Sidrah Ali, a healthcare professional, said that Musharraf’s eight-year rule was the country’s best ever after 1970. “Our GDP grew by 8.9 percent and he changed the higher education system. He did things for the country which elected rulers have not been able to do. It is unfair to sentence him without a proper trial,” she added.

The president of Musharraf's All Pakistan Muslim League (APML) youth wing in the UAE, Malik Mubasher, told Arab News on Tuesday that “the decision is sudden and was not expected,” and the verdict will be appealed.

“(Party) members protested the verdict and said it was one-sided,” he said, adding that “Musharraf issued a video message one week ago saying that he was very unwell.”

Musharraf, 78, is suffering from amyloidosis, a rare disease caused by a buildup of an abnormal protein called amyloid in organs and tissues throughout the body. 


Pakistan parliamentary panel discusses rollout of local messaging app for officials next year

Updated 7 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan parliamentary panel discusses rollout of local messaging app for officials next year

  • Officials say ‘Beep’ aims to provide a secure, locally built messaging platform for government use
  • The committee voices dissatisfaction with Internet services, calls for fair 5G spectrum auction

ISLAMABAD: A Pakistani parliamentary committee on Tuesday discussed plans to roll out a locally developed messaging application for government officials next year, even as lawmakers voiced strong dissatisfaction with the country’s Internet services during a hearing marked by complaints over poor connectivity.

Local media reported that the proposed app for secure official communication came up during a meeting of the National Assembly’s Standing Committee on Information Technology and Telecommunication, where members also raised concerns about sluggish mobile Internet speeds and the performance of the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA).

Pakistani officials announced last year that local engineers had developed and successfully tested a government messaging platform intended to reduce reliance on foreign applications and strengthen data security. The National Information Technology Board (NITB) said the application — known as Beep — had been successfully undergoing trial runs since 2023.

“The purpose of launching Beep is to provide a secure messaging platform for public sector employees nationwide,” NITB Chief Executive Faisal Iqbal Ratyal told the committee during the hearing, according to Pakistan’s English-language broadsheet Dawn, expressing hope that the project would meet its June 30, 2026 deadline.

In an official statement issued after the meeting, the committee praised the National Information Technology Board, calling its performance commendable and its projects aligned with the broader national interest.

The statement said the committee also expressed dissatisfaction with the PTA’s performance, noting that complaints raised in successive meetings largely related to the quality of Internet services and that no significant improvement had been observed so far.

It said official assessments portraying services as satisfactory did not reflect ground realities, as the public faced “severe difficulties” accessing Internet services, with connectivity in some areas described as almost non-existent.

Lawmakers also called for the forthcoming 5G spectrum auction to be conducted in a fair and transparent manner, reiterated that the auction should be held in Pakistani rupees and said spectrum prices should not be set unnecessarily high.

Any concessions granted to telecom operators, the committee said, must be tied to improvements in network and infrastructure.

Pakistani users across the country have frequently complained of sluggish 4G Internet connections in recent months, citing disruptions to calls on messaging platform WhatsApp.

Last year, media reports said the government was installing an Internet firewall to monitor and regulate online content, prompting concern among digital rights activists.

The PTA has rejected assertions that a national firewall was responsible for disruptions, saying in September that slow Internet speeds were due to outdated infrastructure and rising data consumption.