Trump-Khan twitter spat rattles US and Pakistan’s relations

In a televised interview on Monday, President Trump alleged that Pakistan had “never told us (America) that he was living there”, accusing Islamabad of deliberately hiding Bin Laden while taking billions of dollars of US taxpayers’ money as aid. (AFP/File)
Updated 20 November 2018
Follow

Trump-Khan twitter spat rattles US and Pakistan’s relations

  • Islamabad summons envoy to lodge a protest
  • Washington expected to issue a statement to address the diplomatic row

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan has summoned the US Chargé d’Affaires (CdA) in Islamabad, Ambassador Paul Jones, “to register a strong protest” against the unwarranted and unsubstantiated allegations leveled by President Donald Trump on Islamabad’s role in fighting terrorism and in the arrest of Osama bin Laden.
Foreign Secretary Tehmina Janjua told Jones on Tuesday that “such baseless rhetoric about Pakistan was totally unacceptable”.
US Embassy’s spokesperson in Islamabad confirmed to Arab News “that Ambassador Jones did meet with the Foreign Secretary at her request”, without sharing Jones’ response to the statement. The matter is most likely to be addressed at the state briefing in Washington and possibly at the White House on Tuesday, the spokesperson added.
In a televised interview on Monday, President Trump alleged that Pakistan had “never told us (America) that he was living there”, accusing Islamabad of deliberately hiding Bin Laden while taking billions of dollars of US taxpayers’ money as aid.
“Rejecting the insinuations about OBL (Osama Bin Laden), the Foreign Secretary reminded the US CdA that it was Pakistan’s intelligence cooperation that had provided the initial evidence to trace the whereabouts of OBL,” a senior ministry official said.
Following several comments posted by Trump on Twitter, Prime Minister Imran Khan hit back and reminded the US president of Pakistan’s sacrifices in supporting the “war against terror” and in the US invasion of Afghanistan in 2001.
“The record needs to be put straight on Mr. Trump’s tirade against Pakistan: 1. No Pakistani was involved in 9/11 but Pak decided to participate in US War on Terror. 2. Pakistan suffered 75,000 casualties in this war & over $123bn was lost to economy. US “aid” was a minuscule $20 bn,” he tweeted.
In May this year, the US Committee on Armed Services House of Representatives — citing serious concerns on Pakistan’s commitment in tackling the insurgency ostensibly thriving in its porous border with Afghanistan — called for drastic cuts to the monetary assistance provided to Islamabad.
From roughly $2 billion, the Coalition Support Fund (CSF) — which is paid to Pakistan annually — was reduced to hundreds of millions, but with strings attached. Later in September, days ahead of US Secretary Mike Pompeo’s visit to Pakistan, the US canceled $300 million in its CSF to Islamabad, asserting the lack of “decisive actions” on part of Pakistan to support Trump’s South Asia strategy, which it claimed was vital for its success in ending the Afghan war.
The dramatic drop in funds is part of punitive measures in Washington’s South Asia and Afghan policy unveiled last year – a counter to Pakistan’s failure to comply with US demands. 
Furthermore, Trump in one of his several tweets said: “We no longer pay Pakistan the $Billions because they would take our money and do nothing for us, Bin Laden being a prime example, Afghanistan being another. They were just one of many countries that take from the United States without giving anything in return. That’s ENDING!”
Earlier on Tuesday, Foreign Ministry Spokesman, Dr. Muhammad Faisal, told Arab News that the funds should not be viewed as aid but “reimbursements to be made to Pakistan under the CSF” for the logistical and operational support extended to the US which is “discontinued”. 
Trump’s accusations against Pakistan have driven a nail into the very issues between Islamabad and Washington which both sides have been trying to mend, even as they look to “reset an environment” of frosty relations. However, they have failed to meet eye to eye on certain matters as it conflicts with national interests.
Following Trump’s accusations, the Pentagon, however, said on Tuesday that its relations with Pakistan’s military remain unchanged.
“The US and Pakistan have a strong mutual interest in the region. As you know, they are critical (and) vital to the South Asia strategy and including the facilitation of a peace process that would lead to a stable and peaceful Afghanistan,” Col Rob Manning, director of defense press operations told journalists at a news conference.
“Trump-Khan twitter brawl is not policy level (dispute),” Qamar Cheema, a foreign relations expert, told Arab News, playing down the impact of the social media exchange.
He added that tweets between Trump and retired Navy Admiral William McRaven were “a domestic political fight” which eventually led to the “US-Pak diplomatic commotion”. 

TRUMP'S TWEETS

KHAN'S REACTION


Davos braces for Trump’s ‘America First’ onslaught

Updated 4 sec ago
Follow

Davos braces for Trump’s ‘America First’ onslaught

  • Trump will descend on the Swiss ski resort for an address Wednesday, at a meeting whose theme is “A Spirit of Dialogue“
  • Brende acknowledged that “our annual meeting is taking place against the most complex geopolitical backdrop since 1945“

PARIS: All eyes will be on Donald Trump next week as politicians and business leaders head to the World Economic Forum, wondering how to square the mercurial US leader with the Davos creed of open markets and multilateralism.
After a year of roiling the liberal international order since his return to office, Trump will descend on the Swiss ski resort for an address Wednesday, at a meeting whose theme is “A Spirit of Dialogue.”
“We’re pleased to welcome back President Trump,” Borge Brende, the forum’s chief executive, told an online press conference ahead of the Davos summit, six years after Trump’s previous in-person appearance during his first term.
He will bring along the largest US delegation ever, Brende added, setting the stage for private meetings on geopolitical flashpoints from Ukraine and Venezuela to Gaza, Greenland and Iran.
Trump told an event in Detroit, Michigan on Tuesday that he plans next week to “provide much more detail about our housing policies so that every American who wants to own a home will be able to afford one.”
His message to American voters, delivered before business and political elites, comes with US households feeling the squeeze from high costs of living as November’s midterm elections approach.
Brende noted that “the interest is to come together at the beginning of the year to try to connect the dots, decipher, and also see areas where we can collaborate.”
But with a protectionist tariff blitz and marked disdain for traditional US allies defining Trump’s second term, the chances of forging common strategies for the world’s biggest challenges appear slim.
Brende acknowledged that “our annual meeting is taking place against the most complex geopolitical backdrop since 1945.”
Economist Karen Harris at consulting firm Bain & Co. said “2025 will ultimately be seen as the year in which neoliberal globalization ended and... the post-globalization era began.”
It’s a shift in which “the US prioritizes national security, its own security, and uses the economy as a tool to achieve some of those goals,” she said, adding that this is a “very Chinese view of the economy as well.”
China is sending Vice Premier He Lifeng to Davos, while EU Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen and Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky will also attend.
Six of the Group of Seven leaders will also make appearances — only Japan will be absent.
Trump is bringing at least five key deputies including Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, Brende said, alongside Steve Witkoff, his special envoy for the Middle East and Ukraine.

- ‘Broad rejection’ -

Addressing Davos by video last year, days after his second inauguration, Trump warned nations to shift manufacturing to the US or face punishing tariffs — a direct repudiation of decades of ever-opening trade.
In his latest upending of the global order in place since World War II, Trump this month pulled the United States out of 66 international organizations including around half linked to the United Nations.
This rejection of cooperative partnerships “is precisely a broad rejection of multilateral institutions,” said Philippe Dauba-Pantanacce, head of geopolitical analysis at the British bank Standard Chartered.
As a result, even if global trade manages to adapt to Trump’s tariff frictions, “we may end up with a world that continues its globalization, maybe with some adaptation and changes but... increasingly without the US,” Dauba-Pantanacce added.
A case in point is the European Union’s agreement this week to the Mercosur trade deal with South American countries, or China’s shift of exports from the United States to other parts of the globe.
With his tariffs, trade “is a subject where Trump has made a lot of noise,” Pascal Lamy, former head of the World Trade Organization, told AFP.
“But unlike what has been the case with geopolitics, whether it’s Ukraine, China, Iran or Venezuela, the impact on the global economy has been limited so far,” he said.
Among the 850 CEOs or board chairs set to attend are Nvidia’s Jensen Huang and Microsoft’s Satya Nadella.