In a first, Pakistan top court live-streams hearing on law curtailing chief justice’s powers

The screengrab taken from Pakistan's state-run media shows Chief Justice of Pakistan, Qazi Faez Isa (center), charing a full court bench on hearing of multiple petitions challenging the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act 2023 in Islamabad, Pakistan, on September 18, 2023. (Photo courtesy: PTV News)
Short Url
Updated 18 September 2023
Follow

In a first, Pakistan top court live-streams hearing on law curtailing chief justice’s powers

  • The outgoing government passed the law amid a standoff with the judiciary over holding snap polls in two provinces 
  • The law cuts down chief justice’s powers to constitute panels, hear appeals, assign cases to judges on his team 

ISLAMABAD: In a first for Pakistan, the Supreme Court on Monday began live-streaming hearing of multiple petitions against a law that curtails the powers of the country’s top judge, a day after a new chief justice widely believed to be an activist judge took office. 

The law, the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act 2023, deprived the office of the Chief Justice of Pakistan of powers to take suo motu notices in individual capacity, hear appeals and assign cases to other judges. It proposed a three-member committee led by the chief justice to decide on the matters with a majority vote. 

The outgoing government of Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif had tabled the draft law in parliament amid a tussle with the apex court, particularly former chief justice Umar Ata Bandial, after he had initiated proceedings through a suo motu notice for snap elections in the Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provinces. 

The court ruled that snap polls should be held in both provinces within 90 days of the dissolution of assemblies in January, but the Sharif-led government defied the ruling by refusing to provide funds and security for polls in Punjab. The Pakistan parliament passed the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act 2023 in April, curtailing the top judge’s powers, but it was suspended shortly afterwards by the outgoing chief justice. 

After taking oath on Sunday, Chief Justice Qazi Faez Isa constituted a full court, comprising all 15 judges of the Supreme Court, to hear the petitions challenging the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act 2023 on Monday. The decision to broadcast the case proceedings, the first in the country’s history, came after a full court meeting this morning. 

“Some of us have heard this matter and some of us are going to hear for the first time,” Chief Justice Isa said in his remarks at the outset of the hearing. 

“There was a question because since the bench no longer, one member of the bench has retired, to constitute it. The question also had a reason whether I should be a part of the bench, then the related question would arise should the other two members (two senior judges apart from the chief justice who were part of the committee) be part of the bench... so, I think the best way to resolve it was to constitute a full court.” 

Advocate Khawaja Tariq Rahim, one of the petitioners, contended that parliament was not “omnipotent” and it had to go according to certain constitutional limitations. 

To which, Chief Justice Isa responded by asking the counsel to not insert words which were not written in the law. “This law doesn’t say that parliament is omnipotent,” he said. 

Rahim called the law an “intrusion” by parliament into the affairs of the Supreme Court, which he said prompted him to come forward and file a petition against it. 

“I feel every institution must remain within its own domain,” he said. 

At this Justice Athar Minallah asked Rahim if he could formulate his exact legal proposition. 

To which, the petitioner replied, “My legal proposition is this that this power of forming the benches etc is the domain of the Supreme Court itself.” 

Rahim’s contentions were followed by arguments from another counsel of the petitioners, Imtiaz Siddiqui, before the court adjourned for a break at around 230pm. 

Ahead of the hearing on Monday, Attorney General for Pakistan (AGP) Mansoor Usman Awan submitted the federal government’s response in the matter, requesting the court to reject the petitions against the law. 

The full court comprised Chief Justice Isa, Justice Sardar Tariq Masood, Justice Ijazul Ahsan, Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah, Justice Munib Akhtar, Justice Yahya Afridi, Justice Aminuddin Khan, Justice Sayyed Mazahar Ali Akbar Naqvi, Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhel, Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar, Justice Ayesha A. Malik, Justice Minallah, Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi, Justice Shahid Waheed and Justice Musarrat Hilali. 

During the previous hearing in June, similarities between the Supreme Court (Review of Judgments and Orders) Act 2023, which relates to the right to appeal in suo motu cases, and the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act 2023 were discussed, with Attorney General for Pakistan (AGP) Mansoor Usman Awan saying that parliament could look into “harmonizing” the two laws. 

Welcoming the proposal, the then-chief justice had said the federal government should take the top court into consideration, when making any legislation related to the judiciary. 


‘For sake of humanity’: Thousands rally in northwest Pakistan against Israel’s war on Gaza

Updated 13 sec ago
Follow

‘For sake of humanity’: Thousands rally in northwest Pakistan against Israel’s war on Gaza

  • The rally was organized by the Jamat-e-Islami (JI) religious party, which has held several similar protests in recent months
  • It came as another Israeli strike killed 31 people in Gaza on Sunday amid US national security adviser’s visit to Israel for talks

PESHAWAR: Thousands of Pakistanis, including students, activists and politicians, gathered on Sunday in the northwestern Pakistani city of Peshawar to demand an end to Israel’s war on Gaza.

The rally, called ‘Gaza Million March,’ was organized by the Jamat-e-Islami (JI) religious party, which has held several protests and marches in recent months to condemn Israeli military actions in Palestine.

The war broke out after the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel, which resulted in the deaths of more than 1,100 people. Israel’s retaliatory offensive against Hamas has killed at least 35,456 Palestinians, mostly civilians, according to the Palestinian health ministry.

Speaking to participants of the rally, JI chief Hafiz Naeem-ur-Rehman lamented that men, women, children, journalists and human rights activists had been killed in Palestine, but world leaders and rights groups remained silent.

“They want no one to raise their voice for Palestine or against [Israeli] oppression,” he said, adding, “For the freedom of Palestine, we will march in every street.”

Pakistan's Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) party activists wave the Palestinian national flag alongside their party flag during an anti-Israel protest in Peshawar on May 19, 2024. (AFP)

Participants of Sunday’s rally said they had gathered to express solidarity with Palestinians and raise their voice against Israel’s actions.

“The reason for our assembly here is to show solidarity with Gaza,” said Amir Hamza, 24.

Mian Hafiz Naeem, another participant who came from the Balakot town, criticized Pakistani politicians “for not doing enough” on the Gaza situation.

“They are not realizing that not only Muslims, but humanity is being killed over there,” he said, adding that he came to attend the rally “for the sake of humanity.”

Pakistan does not recognize the state of Israel and maintains its support for an independent Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital, based on pre-1967 borders.

In recent months, the South Asian country has repeatedly raised the issue of Israel’s war on Gaza at the United Nations through its permanent representative, Ambassador Munir Akram.

Dr. Noreena Arshad, a resident of Peshawar who came to the rally along with her daughters, said she did not belong to any political group and came to the rally with the sole purpose of expressing solidarity with the Palestinians.

“I don’t belong to any political party or organization, but I am here to stand in solidarity with Gaza and Palestine,” she told Arab News. “This is the least of faith that we should believe at least in our hearts that they [Palestinians] are being oppressed.”


Over 300 Pakistani students evacuated from Kyrgyzstan following mob violence against foreigners

Updated 9 min 49 sec ago
Follow

Over 300 Pakistani students evacuated from Kyrgyzstan following mob violence against foreigners

  • Separate flights carrying 140, 175 Pakistani students arrived in Islamabad, Lahore respectively on Sunday night
  • Pakistan has started evacuating students from Bishkek after violent attacks last week against foreigners 

ISLAMABAD: Two separate flights carrying over 300 Pakistani students from Kyrgyzstan arrived in Lahore and Islamabad on Sunday night, days after violent clashes in the central Asian country forced Islamabad to evacuate its nationals and arrange for their safe return. 

Videos of a brawl between Kyrgyz and Egyptian students went viral on social media last week, prompting frenzied mobs to target hostels of medical universities and private lodgings of international students, including Pakistanis, in the city. 

Pakistan has since then ramped efforts to repatriate its students from the city, dispatching commercial and special flights to the country. According to official statistics, around 10,000 Pakistani students are enrolled in various educational institutions in Kyrgyzstan, with nearly 6,000 residing and studying in Bishkek. Foreign Minister Dar on Sunday confirmed no Pakistani had died in the clashes. 

The first batch of around 130 Pakistani students from Kyrgyzstan arrived in the eastern city of Lahore late Saturday night. On Sunday, another flight carrying 140 Pakistani students from Kyrgyzstan arrived in Islamabad and was received by Federal Minister of Petroleum Musadik Malik. 

“I have no words to describe your situation but I feel the pain and suffering that you and your parents have gone through,” Malik told the students upon their arrival in the country. He said some students did not want to return to Pakistan on account of their exams. 

“Any student who wants to come, we will bring them,” he vowed. 

Separately, another flight arrived at the Allama Iqbal International Airport in Lahore on Sunday night with 175 Pakistani students from Bishkek. Information Minister Ataullah Tarar welcomed the students, saying that Islamabad was in touch with Bishkek over the current situation. 

“Our ambassador in Kyrgyzstan is in contact with students,” Tarar was quoted as saying by the information ministry. “On Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif’s instructions, special arrangements have made to shift the Pakistani students from the airports [to their homes.]”

Pakistan’s ambassador to Kyrgyzstan Hasan Zaigham said on Saturday that five Pakistani medical students had been injured in the mob attack. One student was admitted to a local hospital with a jaw injury, while the other four were released after receiving first aid.

Pakistan’s foreign ministry said on Saturday it had summoned and handed a note of protest to Kyrgyzstan’s top diplomat in the country in response to violence against Pakistani students in Bishkek.


Fresh floods kill 66 in northern Afghanistan

Updated 19 May 2024
Follow

Fresh floods kill 66 in northern Afghanistan

  • Hundreds of people have died in flash floods this month that have also swamped agricultural lands in Afghainstan
  • The latest heavy floods hit multiple districts of Faryab province Saturday, resulting in human and financial losses

KABUL: Fresh floods killed 66 people in northern Afghanistan, a provincial official said Sunday, after weeks of flooding that has inundated farms and villages and swept away swathes of communities.

Hundreds of people have died in flash floods this month that have also swamped agricultural lands in a country where 80 percent of the population depends on farming to survive.

The latest heavy floods hit multiple districts of Faryab province on Saturday night and “resulted in human and financial losses,” said Asmatullah Muradi, spokesman for the Faryab governor, in a statement.

“Due to the floods 66 people were killed,” he said, adding that at least five people were injured and others were still missing.

The flooding damaged more than 1,500 houses, swamped more than 1,000 acres of agricultural land and killed hundreds of livestock, he said.

The floods came a day after provincial police said more than 50 people were killed in flash flooding in the western province of Ghor.

Just over a week ago, more than 300 people were killed by torrents in northern Baghlan province, according to the UN World Food Programme (WFP) and Taliban officials.

Taliban officials have warned the tolls would go up in regions impacted by flooding, as destroyed infrastructure hampered aid delivery and efforts to find the missing.

The death toll from the Ghor flooding rose from 50 to 55 on Sunday, according to Abdul Wahid Hamas, a spokesman for the provincial governor.

“More than 3,000 homes were totally destroyed due to the floods” in Ghor, he added.

Videos shared on social media platform X by the WFP showed currents of brown water crashing through walls of homes and churning through streets in Ghor.

Residents in Baghlan, Ghor, Faryab and other affected provinces found themselves without shelter, stripped of their homes and livelihoods.

“We were inside our home when rain started and all of a sudden, a flash flood came, we were trying to get things out but it washed away our home, our life, everything,” Ghor resident Jawan Gul told AFP on Saturday.

The flooding also sparked concern for the revered 12th-century Jam minaret, located in a remote part of Ghor, provincial officials said.

Images circulated to media showed brown torrents crashing around the base of the UNESCO World Heritage Site.

“The situation of Jam was very concerning,” Abdul Hai Zaeem, information and culture director in Ghor, told AFP, adding that mud was still piled high around the brick minaret.

The WFP warned that the recent floods have compounded an already dire humanitarian situation in the impoverished country.

Spring floods are not uncommon in Afghanistan, a country of more than 40 million people, but above-average rainfall this year has sparked devastating flash flooding.

Even before the most recent spate of floods, about 100 people had been killed from mid-April to early May as a result of flooding in 10 of Afghanistan’s provinces, authorities said.

The rains come after a prolonged drought in Afghanistan, which is one of the least prepared nations to tackle climate change impacts, according to experts.


Anti-microbial resistance causing 1 million deaths in Pakistan annually — health experts

Updated 19 May 2024
Follow

Anti-microbial resistance causing 1 million deaths in Pakistan annually — health experts

  • Self-medication, unjustified prescription, taking antibiotics for shorter duration major reasons of antimicrobial resistance
  • Officials and public health experts urge people not to use antibiotics without the advice of trained and qualified physicians

KARACHI: Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is the third leading cause of deaths in Pakistan that directly or indirectly results in 1 million deaths in the South Asian country annually, officials and public health experts said on Sunday.

They said this at a press conference in Karachi in connection with the National Antimicrobial Stewardship Summit 2024, organized by Getz Pharma drug manufacturer in collaboration with the National Health Services Ministry, Health Services Academy (HSA) and the National Institute of Health (NIH).

Around 300,000 people die annually due to drug-resistant bacteria, while AMR contributes to 700,000 deaths because of complications following treatment of diseases, according to the experts.

The deaths are linked with “irrational use” of antibiotics as Pakistan is the third largest consumer of antibiotics in the world, after China and India, and consumed antibiotics worth Rs126 billion in 2023 alone.

“Antimicrobial resistance is now the third leading cause of death after cardiovascular disease and maternal and neonatal disorders in Pakistan because we now have infections caused by bacteria that are not responding to third- and fourth-generation antibiotics,” said Prof. Shahzad Ali Khan, vice-chancellor of the Health Services Academy in Islamabad.

“Abuse of antibiotics by doctors, quacks, and people themselves is making these important medicines highly ineffective,” he said, urging people not to use antibiotics without the advice of trained and qualified physicians.

The summit was attended by over 1,400 health care professionals, including health secretaries and directors-general from federal and provincial governments, officials from the NIH, Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan, medical societies and health care regulatory authorities, senior physicians and policymakers.

Khan maintained that antibiotics were “wonder drugs” that saved millions of lives during world wars and pandemics, but their “irrational use or abuse” had led to AMR, which was now becoming a global public health concern.

“Self-medication, unjustified prescription of antibiotics by quacks and physicians, taking antibiotics for a shorter duration, and the production of substandard antibiotics by some companies are some of the major causes of antimicrobial resistance,” he said.

Prof. Javed Akram, former Punjab health minister and president of the Pakistan Society of Internal Medicine (PSIM), said AMR was the third major challenge facing Pakistan after population growth and non-communicable diseases (NCDs).

“People are now dying due to infections that are extremely hard to treat due to the resistance developed by bacteria against these medicines,” Akram said.

“On one hand, Pakistan has become the world capital of diabetes and other non-communicable diseases, and on the other, we have developed Extremely Drug-Resistant (XDR) typhoid, Multi-Drug Resistant (MDR) TB, and various other infections that are extremely hard to treat with most of the available antibiotics. This is because we have been using antibiotics like candies.”

He urged people not to consume antibiotics on their own, saying antibiotics have similar side effects as cancer treatment therapies.

Dr. Afreenish Amir, an NIH representative and senior microbiologist, said AMR had spread to almost all countries and regions, including Pakistan, owing to the “misuse and overuse” of antibiotics.

“This contributes to the increasing burden of infections due to resistant bacteria while limiting treatment options for managing such infections,” she said.

The experts also highlighted the “overuse and abuse” of antibiotics for livestock and said it was responsible for 80 percent of AMR in the veterinary sector. They called for creating awareness among the masses regarding the irrational use of antibiotics in humans, livestock and poultry.

In his keynote address, Prof. Zulfiqar Bhutta, a renowned pediatrician and public health scientist, urged people to get their children vaccinated against typhoid, saying Pakistan was the only country in the world where the Typhoid Conjugate Vaccine (TCV) was being administered to children to prevent the drug-resistant, water-borne disease.

Dr. Wajiha Javed, an associate director of public health at Getz Pharma, said over-the-counter availability of antibiotics, use of these medicines for a shorter duration, and unnecessary prescription of antibiotics by quacks and doctors should be looked into by the authorities.

She said substandard antibiotics containing less or low-grade raw materials were also responsible for AMR and announced that her firm was working work with the government to develop a national action plan on AMR.

On the occasion, a declaration was also signed between the Health Services Academy, NIH and Getz Pharma for the implementation of Antimicrobial Stewardship (AMS), while Memorandums of Understanding (MoUs) were also signed with 13 medical societies in this regard.


Deputy PM Dar, Saudi FM discuss Crown Prince’s visit to Pakistan, bilateral cooperation

Updated 19 May 2024
Follow

Deputy PM Dar, Saudi FM discuss Crown Prince’s visit to Pakistan, bilateral cooperation

  • Deputy PM Ishaq Dar this month said the much-awaited visit was ‘on the cards,’ but neither side has confirmed any dates
  • The statement came amid Pakistan and Saudi Arabia’s efforts to increase bilateral trade and reach investment agreements

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar on Sunday held a telephonic conversation with Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan and discussed with him Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s proposed visit to Pakistan as well as bilateral cooperation between the two countries, the Pakistani foreign ministry said.

Dar this month said the much-awaited visit of the Saudi Crown Prince to Islamabad was “on the cards” and could materialize “any time” during May. But neither of the two sides has confirmed any dates.

His statement followed a series of high-level engagements between the two countries, including the visits of Pakistan PM Shehbaz Sharif to the Kingdom and a visit of the Saudi foreign minister to Islamabad.

On Sunday, Dar and the Saudi foreign minister discussed bilateral relations between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, exploring various avenues for further strengthening cooperation across multiple sectors.

“They reviewed preparations for the visit of the Crown Prince and Prime Minister of Saudi Arabia His Royal Highness Prince Mohammed Bin Salman Al-Saud to Pakistan,” the Pakistani foreign ministry said in a statement.

“Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar underlined that people of Pakistan are eagerly looking forward to the visit of His Royal Highness at a mutually agreed date.”

Pakistan and Saudi Arabia have lately been working to increase bilateral trade and investment, with the Crown Prince last month reaffirming the Kingdom’s commitment to expedite an investment package of $5 billion.

A high-level Saudi business delegation, led by the Kingdom’s Assistant Minister of Investment Ibrahim Al-Mubarak, this month visited Pakistan to explore investment opportunities in various sectors, including mineral, energy, agriculture and petroleum.

The visit by the Saudi Crown Prince would mark his first trip to Pakistan in the last five years. His previous visit took place in February 2019 during the tenure of former prime minister Imran Khan.

On Saturday, Pakistan’s Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi said the proposed visit would prove to be a “game changer” in bilateral ties between both countries.

“The historic brotherly friendship of Saudi Arabia and Pakistan is turning into a beneficial economic relationship,” Naqvi was quoted as saying by his ministry. “The people of Pakistan are looking forward to the visit of the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia.”

Pakistan and Saudi Arabia enjoy strong trade, defense, and cultural ties. The Kingdom is home to over 2.7 million Pakistani expatriates and serves as a top source of remittances to the cash-strapped South Asian country.

Saudi Arabia has also often come to cash-strapped Pakistan’s aid by regularly providing it oil on deferred payment and offering direct financial support to help stabilize its economy and shore up its forex reserves.